Thank you. 🙂 I'm cautiously optimistic.
Update:
The meeting with my CEO went well enough. She initially tried to go down the road of counter-counter offer, but I said my mind was already made up and "you know me, it's not a question of pay."
My opinion to anyone else who might encounter this situation is: before you make a counter offer, be sure you would be willing to forgo any further possibilities if the counter-offer was accepted. I believe negotiations should be done in good faith. If you play both sides to get the highest offer, you probably paid for it with distrust and marked yourself for payback.
I volunteered to stay on as a consultant/PRN to help with the pharmacy operations to ensure a smooth transition. To show a sign of loyalty and good will goes a long way. And PRN is extra money. Win-win. The 180 degree opposite arrangement is kind of ironic.
Most staffing positions need 2 weeks notice, but de-facto standards for leadership positions are 1 month. Give as much time as you can without undue hardship to both sides. Higher the position, harder it is to find a replacement. Also, on a personal level, some company would not cash out your PTO without a minimum amount of notice. That's can be a lot of money, and the hiring company would understand if you give it to them straight. Further more, know your vestment schedule, eg. many company vest 401k matching by increasing % per year, if you reach the next year mark, the amount of 401k match that goes with you go up. If you have a sign-on bonus or stock options, again, know what are the dates that matters.
You can negotiate more than just pay. One of the things you tend to lose when you switch company is the seniority. Eg. I had been with mine for 2 years, I was due for a PTO bump in 3 years. Its not unfair to see if you can swing that the new position, especially if it's just a lateral move. Admittedly, I wasn't successful on this, and it's not big deal to me since I hardly ever took any time off. But to those with more family and obligations, it might be important.
Anyway, waaaaaaaaaaaahooooo! I went to happy hour with my HIM buddy today, he had heard, but it's good to finally just let it all out during happy hour, not having to keep a secret from a friend any more. 🙂