lsuhockeyplayer said:
Are you really that blind to think that essentially an IQ test can tell some one that they will not make it in professional school?
So now the MCAT is IQ test simply because you didn't do well on it? Typical excuse from a guy who scored poorly on it. So are you telling us you are dumb? For a person with a lot of pride, it shocks me that you will settle on explaining to everyone that your low MCAT score was due to your IQ as opposed to your preparation. Did it ever cross your mind that you probably didn't study as much as you should have for the exam? Do you actually count the number of hours you study for the exam or do you just assume you studied a given amount. Try actually counting your hours and you will probably find the 6 hours you thought you studied in a given day turned out to be 2 or 3 hours with a lot breaks thrown in between. I personally know a lot of people who cry :"Woe is me, I studied and I still did bad." When you actually sit down with them and ask them to write down their day's events, you discover they waste a lot of time and are not aware of it. They also don't study "everyday" like they say they do. Just like you have people who downplay how much they study, there are those who hype how much they study. You are one of those people.
And no, I earned over a 30 on the MCAT and I studied far more than you did. When I said I put in 8 hours a day studying, I literally put in 8 hours per day including the weekends for 3 months in the summer. Some days, I put in 12-15 hours.
Oh and I know what the rebuttal will be the "boards is just like the MCAT or harder the huge difference is the boards is not a weed out point they dont try to screw you up with little tricks of the trade.
What are you basing this on, your intuition? How the hell would you know since you have never taken the boards. Are you that naive to make an opinion based on no first hand knowledge whatsoever? Take it from someone who has taken Step I, and scored over a 30 on the MCAT, Step I is much more of a weed out exam than you could ever imagine. How do you think residency programs distinguish between medical students especially since every medical school has their own grading criteria. Some are pass/fail with no class rank. Some are letter grade. Some are percentages. Some are Honors, High Pass, Pass, Fail. Grades are subjective and ambiguous which is why programs rely so heavily on Step I scores. So when everyone wants derm, radiology, emergency medicine, orthopedic surgery, peds at Boston Childrens, Medicine at Hopkins or Mayo, how do you think they distinguish among candidates with similar grades?
And before you chime in with another lousy excuse, keep in mind the type of people that are taking the boards. These are people who have been successfully admitted to medical school. You are competing with the best of the best so the exam is that much harder. You will find that out in medical school too. Your professors will deliberately make questions difficult to weed out the best students in the class since everyone in medical school is fairly intelligent.
Yes, I know people who got 20,21 and 22 on the MCAT and became successfull doctors. I also know they were admittedly lazy and didn't put in the time to study for the MCAT. They were not students who studied really hard and had to take the exam three times to get a mediocre score. Likewise, I just think you are unaware of how much preparation is required to achieve a competitive score on the MCAT which is why I don't think you are dumb. I just think you are naive.
You just sound like a classic case of the guy who memorizes the Kaplan book but doesn't understand what he is memorizing. The MCAT is only an IQ test to those who don't understand the concepts well enough to apply them. Memorizing all of the lists in Kaplan is the easy part. Applying what you memorized is much more difficult. You have to do many passages and understand why you missed what you did. In my experience the difference between the low 20's and high 20' on up is the application aspect. I did literally thousands of questions and looked up answers.