An MD/DO analogy

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

DrOctagon

oooh, i like it like that
10+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Jul 5, 2004
Messages
59
Reaction score
0
Ever since i decided to attend an osteopathic med school, ive been placed in the situation of explaining what the osteopathic philosophy is. One lonely afternoon, I thought up an analogy that would make the explanation a lot easier..

I figure allopathic medicine is like microsoft and osteopathic medicine is like apple. a few comparable points can be made:

- Both are parallel computing operating structures. although windows is huge and apple is significantly less prominent in the US, there are the select few that will vouch for apple any day over windows due to the lack in stability, etc... similarly, a a select group of people will prefer DO's to MD's due to thier own reasons, which i dont think i need to get into

- just like medicine, the general public associates medicine with MD's rather than DO's, just like the general public associates computing with microsoft rather than apple. but neverthelss, both perform the same overall functions and provide the same enormous service to the general public

- although a lot smaller and less prominent, mac's are a lot more stable and in many cases are able to handle problems that pc's cannot, (ie. safeguards from many viruses, much more stable.etc) osteopathic medicine can provide in some cases, where allopathic med cannot

- when u hear that a person for microsoft you might get some "oooh's" and "aaah's" as is it is such a big name company, but probably not as many "oooh'" for a person employed by apple. likewise, having an MD next to ur name might needs no explanation, but a DO next to ur name will incite some raised eyebrows. still, both are programmers/physicians and both provide the same service to the company/population that seek its services

- programmers that work for microsoft are not people that ddint get job's at microsoft and decided to apply for jobs at apple. they are simply a different group of people that belieeve that apple could suit them better as a company. comparatively, those that attend osteopathic schools are geenrally not students that get rejected from allopathic schools, just students that find a better niche in osteopathic schools

- basically both groups, employees of microsoft and apple work in parallel to provide the same services and have chosen thier path because they enjoy thier chosen path whether it be the microsft or apple corporation, not because one is better than the other (although some might feel this way), but because of thier passion for developing computing needs to the public, just as us future physicans are learning through osteopathic or allopathic means because of our passion for medicine above all else

i might have rambled.. and it could be incoherent (its 3am) so i might have to edit it later to make more sense, but i thought id share in case anyone would like to use it as a comparison when trying to find a good analogy between DO's and MD's when explaining to a non-medically educated person.

feel free to correct me if this doesnt suit the comparison well. gracias.
 
Interesting...I don't think I have ever heard it put that way before.


😳
 
very creative. 👍
 
i like my ipod. its apple and it works with my PC too.
 
not really, but interesting.
 
How about for us uber computer nerds: Windows vs Linux :laugh:
 
bgreet said:
How about for us uber computer nerds: Windows vs Linux :laugh:

might work better if DO schools were free and open source so students could alter their curriculum to their liking.
 
DrOctagon said:
those that attend osteopathic schools are geenrally not students that get rejected from allopathic schools, just students that find a better niche in osteopathic schools

I personally have no opinion on the matter but when I lurk in the pre-allo forum I always see people with low stats saying..."oh well, I guess I can just get my DO or go to the Caribbean"

So DO schools are easier to get into not because they are inferior but just due to supply/demand?
 
agree with dnelson. There are some that go to osteo because they couldn't get into an allo. Tainted love!
 
The computer analogy is a good one. But another one that relates more to the health field is the one on Dentists. Did you know that there are 2 diff types of dentists...a DDS and (can't think of it right now, someone please fill in the blank)

This one usually takes care of all questions
 
Is it true all DO schools are privately funded?
 
Smooth Operater said:
Is it true all DO schools are privately funded?


If they are private schools.

oklahoma, ohio and michigan osteopathic schools are affiliated with their state schools so they are funded by the state
 
Eyecon82 said:
The computer analogy is a good one. But another one that relates more to the health field is the one on Dentists. Did you know that there are 2 diff types of dentists...a DDS and (can't think of it right now, someone please fill in the blank)

This one usually takes care of all questions

DMD
 
Eyecon82 said:
If they are private schools.

oklahoma, ohio and michigan osteopathic schools are affiliated with their state schools so they are funded by the state

Texas and (I think) California also have state-funded osteopathic colleges
 
NJ has a state funded school as well. There are a few of them out there.
 
Eyecon82 said:
The computer analogy is a good one. But another one that relates more to the health field is the one on Dentists. Did you know that there are 2 diff types of dentists...a DDS and (can't think of it right now, someone please fill in the blank)

This one usually takes care of all questions

I use this one myself, but just to get the point across that they are equal. It's not really an accurate analogy, because if I'm not mistaken, DDS and DMD are identical degrees, just different names. I don't think there is any philosophical or educational difference whatsoever between schools granting DDS and those granting DMD. Another example is BA vs. AB.
 
as a pre-DO, dansw would be considered a mac, as opposed to a PC.

thought id clear the the bad joke up so we all can laugh at him, err... i mean with him. :laugh:
 
Fin-Nor said:
apple = macintosh

hehe...DUH!! i completely forgot the analogy of pc's verses apple....DUH!!!...stupid me...for some reason i was thinking of maccaroni and cheese or something...ok...it has been a long boring day at work....I CANNOT WAIT TILL SCHOOL STARTS!!! 😕 😕
 
Eyecon82 said:
hehe...DUH!! i completely forgot the analogy of pc's verses apple....DUH!!!...stupid me...for some reason i was thinking of maccaroni and cheese or something...ok...it has been a long boring day at work....I CANNOT WAIT TILL SCHOOL STARTS!!! 😕 😕

HAHAHA... macaroni and cheese :laugh: :laugh: :laugh:
 
really.jpg
 
Top