Anesthesiology 2025 match application signaling advice

[scrubsandgas123]

(deleted)

---

Members don't see this ad.

 

[medschoolaspirant]

Is this true that anesteisia after signal implementation, you only get interviews from signal schools, (only if you did pick right ones). You dont get much oitside of signal schools. Also does it make sense to use signal wisely not using them for home or away programs. Use signals on other program outside of it?

 

[scrubsandgas123]

Is this true that anesteisia after signal implementation, you only get interviews from signal schools, (only if you did pick right ones). You dont get much oitside of signal schools. Also does it make sense to use signal wisely not using them for home or away programs. Use signals on other program outside of it?

With anesthesia now having 15 signals total I think it’s becoming more and more “signal to interview” and even then no one is guaranteed an interview after signaling now😢

 

[medschoolaspirant]

Will you use your signal for your aways or save them for other target programs? Meaning will away give interview irrespective of using signal?

 

[Cornfed101]

Will you use your signal for your aways or save them for other target programs? Meaning will away give interview irrespective of using signal?

Ask the PD when you rotate

 

[voxveritatisetlucis]

If you don’t match, then nobody really has a chance.

 

[MDMechEngr]

Just looking for some honest advice about signaling/how competitive I will be since I understand anesthesiology is quickly becoming more competitive with each cycle.

From low to mid-tier US MD school in the Midwest
6-7 publications/10 poster presentations (3 at ASA)/2 paid summer research internships (including FAER MSARF)
5/6 H with 1 HP on cores, H on anesthesia and peds anesthesia rotations
Step 1 pass (P/F) and my shelf average was 84.5 I think
3-4 volunteering experiences and strong LORs + GHHS
top 25% and applying to AOA
maybe will do away rotations after ERAS submission to show my face and meet the department

have not taken step 2 yet but just needed advice on how many signals I should give to reach/top tier programs vs mid-tier and regional programs

Your average shelf scores indicate you likely will be between 260 to 270 on S2 if you put in the time. AOA and GHHS are like icing on a bunt cake. You will be competitive for a high tier program if you keep up the good work. I applied with less pubs than you and matched a very competitive specialty. If you hit around 265 S2, you will be lit.

 

[scrubsandgas123]

Will you use your signal for your aways or save them for other target programs? Meaning will away give interview irrespective of using signal?

Since my aways are after Eras submission I’ll def gold signal any aways since I’m only doing them at places I actually wanna be at

 

[scrubsandgas123]

Your average shelf scores indicate you likely will be between 260 to 270 on S2 if you put in the time. AOA and GHHS are like icing on a bunt cake. You will be competitive for a high tier program if you keep up the good work. I applied with less pubs than you and matched a very competive specialty. If you hit around 265 S2, you will be lit.

This is reassuring thank you. Currently in my study month studying for just that reason. Our AOA is a huge popularity contest with students voting all in a room+open discussion so I’m not expecting much since it’s always been rigged at our school historically rip

 

[AnonymousPD]

All,

The advice I am giving to applicants is that they should generally assume that without a signal, programs are unlikely to review your application outside of special circumstances. Most commonly those would include you being a student at the home institution, or someone with with a personal connection to a program is making a specific referral on your behalf.

As the specialty has gotten more competitive, programs are able to fill their residency positions (and interview slots) with quality applicants from their signal groups. The more competitive/popular residency programs are able to do so out of their gold signal group.

The decision on who to use your signals on should be largely based on the relative strength of your overall application. Most programs no longer have to choose between a less competitive application from someone with a high level of interest, or a strongly competitive application from someone with an unknown level of interest. There are enough competitive applications from interested applicants to go around for everyone. Do not think that a gold signal will help you get into a program you are not already competitive for.

Now that we are in the 3rd year of signaling, both programs and applicants are starting to figure out how best to navigate this new landscape. If you have any questions, make sure you talk to people at your home programs. If you have a question about how a specific program is going to handle their signals, it is totally okay for you to contact them to ask. The advice we are able to give now is miles and away better than we were able to give 3 years ago.

 

[scrubsandgas123]

Your average shelf scores indicate you likely will be between 260 to 270 on S2 if you put in the time. AOA and GHHS are like icing on a bunt cake. You will be competitive for a high tier program if you keep up the good work. I applied with less pubs than you and matched a very competitive specialty. If you hit around 265 S2, you will be lit.

I got my score back last Wednesday! I got a 270

 

[MDMechEngr]

I got my score back last Wednesday! I got a 270

Congrats! You will match a top program if you can bring your A-game to the interviews.

 

[Dr. Anonymouss]

I had 6 interviews from signals and 1 interview non signal (USMD, 260 step). I’d say signals are very important and make sure to use them appropriately to maximize your chances.

I also remember while doing an away the PD for that program told me that they will only interview those who signal them and they heard the same from other anesthesia PDs. My class had no data to reference on how important this was and which programs prioritized it. Luckily your class certainly will, so utilize this information!

 

[Shunsui]

Your average shelf scores indicate you likely will be between 260 to 270 on S2 if you put in the time. AOA and GHHS are like icing on a bunt cake. You will be competitive for a high tier program if you keep up the good work. I applied with less pubs than you and matched a very competitive specialty. If you hit around 265 S2, you will be lit.

is that 84 percentile? or raw score?

 

[scrubsandgas123]

is that 84 percentile? or raw score?

There is no raw score for NBME exams, everything is EPC (estimated percent correct). Percentiles-wise Texas Tech has a good PDF that shows percentile breakdown for your EPC on shelves. 270 on Step 2 for me was 96% percentile

 

[Dr. Anonymouss]

I was recently told by a PD that without signaling, there is apparently <5% chance anyone will receive an interview from that location!

Yeah it’s very program specific. You can check the Reddit channel for 2024 match and see there were programs which seemed to not care. That is less reliable info than anything the ACGME would publish, but I haven’t checked to see if they have come out with interview data by signals yet. Nevertheless, yes, signals are very important and can mean the difference between your application being reviewed or it being deleted.

 

[Fencing Doctor 319]

Seems this is a cut to the chase moment. DO, so doesn't really matter where I attend. Looking Anesthesiology. Fortunate enough to get 4 Sub-I's (was offered 3 more that conflicted). Great recommendations so far from all clinicals. 258-262 Step 2. No one cares about COMLEX, but my score is super-high. Have an advantage - 2 of my clinicals give automatic interviews. Shoot-Moderate-Safe: How do I allocate my 5 Golds? If this is really about 15 signals are probably my only shot at interviews, and interviews have to parlay a reasonable chance at a match, how many shoots (low % of DO) can I reasonably take? Thanks all!