Any Memrise users? (spaced-repetition website)

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

dap

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Apr 23, 2010
Messages
123
Reaction score
48
I don't think it is very popular in the States yet compared to Europe and other places, but there is a great website called Memrise that is basically a well put-together spaced repetition program. It makes spaced repetition flashcards interactive and game-like, and organizes everything for you.

I use the website extensively for language work and absolutely love it. There are courses on Memrise for just about everything--tons of language stuff, geography, history, science, etc. It is also extremely easy to make your own course. And perhaps best of all--you and other users can submit "mems" to go along with each card to serve as mnemonic devices. It is also great if you can get more friends involved and "follow" them, letting you see how much work everyone has done that week and compete against each other for motivation 🙂

There is a medical school course built by students from a UK school that some here may find interesting as well. The course is understandably huge, but many of the other courses are much smaller (e.g. you can do a quick course just on carpals and tarsals).

Just thought I'd share in case anyone finds it useful!
 
I don't think it is very popular in the States yet compared to Europe and other places, but there is a great website called Memrise that is basically a well put-together spaced repetition program. It makes spaced repetition flashcards interactive and game-like, and organizes everything for you.

I use the website extensively for language work and absolutely love it. There are courses on Memrise for just about everything--tons of language stuff, geography, history, science, etc. It is also extremely easy to make your own course. And perhaps best of all--you and other users can submit "mems" to go along with each card to serve as mnemonic devices. It is also great if you can get more friends involved and "follow" them, letting you see how much work everyone has done that week and compete against each other for motivation 🙂

There is a medical school course built by students from a UK school that some here may find interesting as well. The course is understandably huge, but many of the other courses are much smaller (e.g. you can do a quick course just on carpals and tarsals).

Just thought I'd share in case anyone finds it useful!

Anki.
 
I used memrise for the guardian mandarin challenge, and i loved it. never tried anki. what's the difference?
 
Anki is pure awesomeness. I wish I knew about it sooner, especially for the MCAT. For those who are interested, you can read more about it here.
 
Firecracker. Pricey though.
 
I used memrise for the guardian mandarin challenge, and i loved it. never tried anki. what's the difference?
Anki is incredibly flexible...it syncs between website, phone, and computer. You can use it offline, include pictures, audio, etc. You can make custom card templates to automatically create tons of cards from a single set of information. You can adjust all of the spacing and the 'due' numbers, etc. You can do image occlusion.

That being said, it doesn't have the 'game' aspect that Memrise seems to have...but it's not really made for that, I suppose. You could probably set Anki up to have a similar 'mnemonics' aspect if you want to mess with card templates a bunch.
 

I used Anki pretty extensively before I found out about Memrise.

While Anki is a great program there are really only two aspects of it that I think are advantageous when compared to Memrise. One of them being that you can use it offline, the other being a higher degree of customization with respect to numbers and timing.

But in my opinion those are really the only advantages Anki has. And most of us have internet all the time anyway (I'm in Turkey and I don't have any problem having near-constant access to internet, so I would be surprised if you folks in America did), so that makes the first one nearly moot. Memrise and anki both sync between computer and mobile devices, and are both customizable when it comes to how to set up cards.

However, I think Memrise has some additional advantages over Anki. These are some of them in no particular order.

1. The interface. The user interface for Anki is so 1995. Memrise is beautiful and fun to look at/work with.
2. Gamification. Memrise feels like playing a game. You get points, track your progress, etc. And it adds extra motivation when you can see that five of your friends have worked harder than you this week. When I was using both programs I was always wanting to take time away from Anki to use Memrise, until eventually I just quit Anki.
3. "Mems" - this is huge. For instance, when I needed to learn the Arabic script, which has 28 letters and medial, final, isolated, and initial forms for most of those, along with vowel markings, which basically all just look like similar scribbles on paper, I used this incredible course, which provides a memorable animation/gif for each letter and form. These are called "mems" and you can make them yourself or use some made by others for the same course. The program for creating mems is excellent and takes about 7 seconds to have a mem with a picture without ever leaving the page.
4. The courses are much, much better. Many of the courses on memrise are something I would pay good money for. That Arabic course I mentioned above, in addition to having the .gifs to make each letter instantly memorable, also reinforces each section of letters you have learned by transliterating famous names like Britney Spears that would use those letter sounds. It then moves into basic vocabulary, some verbs, and then puts it all together with sentences and phrases in the end. That's just one example. Many courses (like the medical school one I posted) also have multimedia integrated into them, to teach you before and recap after you learn a new section. With anki you just download a list of words form the server. Or spend a bunch of time making your own list. But many of the courses on Memrise are actually courses, not just lists. And if you really are a make-your-own course person, the Memrise set up is pretty powerful with databases, lists, import/export, ability to include alternate non-shown answers, amount of items per level, etc.
5. Recognition, then recall. Memrise is set up so that when you are learning you start with recognition. First you rewrite the term you are trying to learn while you can see it. The first time it is tested it is as multiple choice. Then you get the prompt and have to type the term (e.g. "uncinate process") yourself. If you type in the term entirely right, you get full points and a larger time interval. Partially right (e.g. spelling, only get one or two words of a phrase) you get a shorter interval until you need to review. If you can't write anything or write something that isn't close to the answer, you have the shortest interval (actually it re-teaches it then gives you a shorter interval).
6. Timing. Everything is timed. Each question has a clock winding down on the right side, so you have to work to recall quickly, like on an exam.
7. Effort vs. results. I found that in order to learn and retain the same amount of information I had to put in more effort for Anki. If I've been in class all day learning grammar and my brain is fried, I am basically useless trying to work on Anki. But with memrise so much of the work is done for you, and I don't feel like I am draining my brain any more to work for a little while on memrise. And yet I still retain the information even better than on Anki (I almost never score below 90% on Memrise review, very often 100%).


Obviously, use whatever you feel works best for you. But I don't want people to come to this thread and see 3 one-word answers that just say "Anki" and assume that they shouldn't even give Memrise a try. I suggest trying both for a week or so and seeing which fits your style more.

Also, I posted this thread in the pre-med forum rather than the med forum because I wasn't specifically talking about studying for medical school, but just any kind of studying in general. Again, I use this program mostly for language stuff and some history stuff. When it comes to actual medical school, although that Durham University course looks nice, I still plan to use Firecracker as my spaced repetition program.

Happy studying 👍
 
Firecracker. Pricey though.

This is my plan. I did the anki thing for MCAT and though it worked, I'd rather not spend all day making the things. Sure it helps you learn, but not enough to justify the time in my experience.
 
This is my plan. I did the anki thing for MCAT and though it worked, I'd rather not spend all day making the things. Sure it helps you learn, but not enough to justify the time in my experience.

I'm loving it so far this year. I didn't have any interest in taking the time to make my own flashcards, especially when I don't have the knowledge of what is and is not important in the long run, so I'm happy to pay somebody else to take care of those parts for me.
 
Firecracker. Pricey though.
This is my plan. I did the anki thing for MCAT and though it worked, I'd rather not spend all day making the things. Sure it helps you learn, but not enough to justify the time in my experience.
I'm loving it so far this year. I didn't have any interest in taking the time to make my own flashcards, especially when I don't have the knowledge of what is and is not important in the long run, so I'm happy to pay somebody else to take care of those parts for me.

So a "default" set of cards in FC are good enough, and you don't need to make as many cards in FC as you would in Anki/Memrise? I was told that FC is usually for MS1 materials, but would you use it until 1st semester of MS2 before studying for boards? I was just curious on how exactly FC works out.
 
So a "default" set of cards in FC are good enough, and you don't need to make as many cards in FC as you would in Anki/Memrise? I was told that FC is usually for MS1 materials, but would you use it until 1st semester of MS2 before studying for boards? I was just curious on how exactly FC works out.

The set of cards in FC seems reasonably comprehensive as far as I can tell; there are ~1100 topics for Step 1, and each topic can have anywhere from 3-30 testable concepts associated with it. FC definitely covers M2 material as well as M1. Indeed, one of the challenges I've run into is that it can be hard to bank M1 stuff without pulling in some M2 stuff (i.e. trying to bank normal physio, but the topic includes some clinical info that we won't cover until next year). I can't weigh in on whether or not most people use it during dedicated study period since I don't really know anything and haven't thought about that yet, but if you've banked all the stuff slowly over the course of the first two years and your daily question load isn't ridiculously high I don't see why you wouldn't keep doing it.

Personally I'm using it as one of my main study resources for class and it's working great, the Step 1 aspect of it is gravy to me at this point. I think this may change over time as I get more stuff banked and have to spend more time working on review of old topics.
 
I used Anki pretty extensively before I found out about Memrise.

While Anki is a great program there are really only two aspects of it that I think are advantageous when compared to Memrise. One of them being that you can use it offline, the other being a higher degree of customization with respect to numbers and timing.

But in my opinion those are really the only advantages Anki has. And most of us have internet all the time anyway (I'm in Turkey and I don't have any problem having near-constant access to internet, so I would be surprised if you folks in America did), so that makes the first one nearly moot. Memrise and anki both sync between computer and mobile devices, and are both customizable when it comes to how to set up cards.

However, I think Memrise has some additional advantages over Anki. These are some of them in no particular order.

1. The interface. The user interface for Anki is so 1995. Memrise is beautiful and fun to look at/work with.
2. Gamification. Memrise feels like playing a game. You get points, track your progress, etc. And it adds extra motivation when you can see that five of your friends have worked harder than you this week. When I was using both programs I was always wanting to take time away from Anki to use Memrise, until eventually I just quit Anki.
3. "Mems" - this is huge. For instance, when I needed to learn the Arabic script, which has 28 letters and medial, final, isolated, and initial forms for most of those, along with vowel markings, which basically all just look like similar scribbles on paper, I used this incredible course, which provides a memorable animation/gif for each letter and form. These are called "mems" and you can make them yourself or use some made by others for the same course. The program for creating mems is excellent and takes about 7 seconds to have a mem with a picture without ever leaving the page.
4. The courses are much, much better. Many of the courses on memrise are something I would pay good money for. That Arabic course I mentioned above, in addition to having the .gifs to make each letter instantly memorable, also reinforces each section of letters you have learned by transliterating famous names like Britney Spears that would use those letter sounds. It then moves into basic vocabulary, some verbs, and then puts it all together with sentences and phrases in the end. That's just one example. Many courses (like the medical school one I posted) also have multimedia integrated into them, to teach you before and recap after you learn a new section. With anki you just download a list of words form the server. Or spend a bunch of time making your own list. But many of the courses on Memrise are actually courses, not just lists. And if you really are a make-your-own course person, the Memrise set up is pretty powerful with databases, lists, import/export, ability to include alternate non-shown answers, amount of items per level, etc.
5. Recognition, then recall. Memrise is set up so that when you are learning you start with recognition. First you rewrite the term you are trying to learn while you can see it. The first time it is tested it is as multiple choice. Then you get the prompt and have to type the term (e.g. "uncinate process") yourself. If you type in the term entirely right, you get full points and a larger time interval. Partially right (e.g. spelling, only get one or two words of a phrase) you get a shorter interval until you need to review. If you can't write anything or write something that isn't close to the answer, you have the shortest interval (actually it re-teaches it then gives you a shorter interval).
6. Timing. Everything is timed. Each question has a clock winding down on the right side, so you have to work to recall quickly, like on an exam.
7. Effort vs. results. I found that in order to learn and retain the same amount of information I had to put in more effort for Anki. If I've been in class all day learning grammar and my brain is fried, I am basically useless trying to work on Anki. But with memrise so much of the work is done for you, and I don't feel like I am draining my brain any more to work for a little while on memrise. And yet I still retain the information even better than on Anki (I almost never score below 90% on Memrise review, very often 100%).


Obviously, use whatever you feel works best for you. But I don't want people to come to this thread and see 3 one-word answers that just say "Anki" and assume that they shouldn't even give Memrise a try. I suggest trying both for a week or so and seeing which fits your style more.

Also, I posted this thread in the pre-med forum rather than the med forum because I wasn't specifically talking about studying for medical school, but just any kind of studying in general. Again, I use this program mostly for language stuff and some history stuff. When it comes to actual medical school, although that Durham University course looks nice, I still plan to use Firecracker as my spaced repetition program.

Happy studying 👍
Fair enough. To each their own. However, to me the main benefit is in creating the cards myself. I have learned ridiculous amounts in Anki cramming where I actually never reviewed the cards...making them is the real value. To me, the ability to remember everything in a few hours in a manner that leaves me a long-term retention tool is golden.

The game aspect is unappealing to me...the idea of being publicly premed would have horrified undergrad me (post-bacc me just doesn't have enough people around to do the 'game' aspect), and 'game' type things always annoy me because no one else uses the program.
Mems: sounds cool, sounds like a definite advantage for Memrise...doesn't sound like something I would need or use. Sounds like an annoying speedbump.
Courses: I don't want a course, I don't want a pre-made deck. I want something that helps ME learn, something that I can extrapolate into learning anything I want.
Timing: You can definitely make timing a thing on Anki. Takes about 2 button clicks.
Portability: Sorry, but 'requires internet access' < 'does not require internet access' on that front. Now, perhaps memrise doesn't require internet (I'm inferring that it does, however, from your post).

So yes, sounds like Memrise has some advantages over Anki; I'll have to check it out. But the two points you raised FOR Anki are my favorite aspects (and you left out the card templates, which is HUGE!), so I don't see switching anytime soon.

In the end, sounds like Memrise is a pretty cool deal. Doesn't sound like it's for me. Doesn't sound like Anki is for you. C'est la vie.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: dap
OK, I joined Memrise, tried out a course in a language I have never taken a class in (just browsed some casual online pronunciation tips a few summers ago when I first became interested in the language). I am now 6 levels into an 11 level course and have racked up ~30,000 points.

The good: it's easy to get into. No setup, no fuss, the audio and vocab lists are all premade. The interface is quite nice, though I would not like to use this on a smartphone.
The bad: It feels...simplistic. It's insanely repetitive, it goes way too slow, etc. Maybe it's just the course I'm in. I tried adding a 'mem' once because it seemed prudent, but honestly I can't imagine actually needing one at the pace this goes...and honestly I don't think I'm a fan of the mems anyway. I feel that I'm brushing the surface of the information because the program asks me the same question 18x instead of having me learn 18x as much. I don't get the "I can do whatever I want with this!" feel that I get from Anki, but that's OK. These are two very different program with very different goals.

In the end, I think I'll keep using memrise...for my non-core academics. If I want to learn some vocab in a new language, or quickly jump through some things that I think are interesting, but not crucial to fully understand, memrise it is. Anki DOES take a lot of time when you're first making your decks (actually, mostly just when you make your card templates), and for some things it's not worth the time investment. However, to me, the time I spend sorting through the information is what forces me to actually learn...memrise seems to shallow for actual "I need to know this" learning, and it's too limited. It's like the Apple version of spaced repetition - easy entry, pretty interface, less flexibility and raw power.
 
It's like the Apple version of spaced repetition - easy entry, pretty interface, less flexibility and raw power.

I actually think this is a pretty good way to describe it. It also makes sense that I like it, as having used apple products for a few years, but now having been on a PC for a little over a year, I absolutely cannot wait to go back to the simplicity and hand-holding of apple next time I need a computer. Different strokes for different folks.

As for the pace, I know what you mean. Some courses move very slowly. If you make your own course you can have it move along much more quickly, but unfortunately not if you join someone else's course. This is by far my biggest complaint about Memrise--that you can't edit other people's courses for your own use. But for me it's a small price to pay for everything else the site offers.
 
Also mehc012, I have to say I decided I liked you very early in this thread based on your picture. We may have different taste in computers and study methods, but we have very similar taste when it comes to coat colors.
 
Also mehc012, I have to say I decided I liked you very early in this thread based on your picture. We may have different taste in computers and study methods, but we have very similar taste when it comes to coat colors.
And here I thought your colors were red-yellow-yellow! 😛
 
Last edited:
Top