Any thoughts on these programs?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

DrRowing81

Full Member
10+ Year Member
5+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2006
Messages
37
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Location
Boston
  1. Resident [Any Field]
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Hey,

Narrowing down my list now, and having a real tough time deciding my rank order. I was wondering if anyone had any input (either residents or applicants who interviewed at these programs) to help me out. I am leaning towards CT surgery, but am keeping my mind open during residency to other possible fellowships ( I already know the problems in CT surgery, so no need to respond to that).

University of Rochester: It sounds like a strong program, with great research opportunities, facilities were outstanding. Graduates get great fellowships (not many going into CT though) and go on to hold awesome academic positions. Drawback is the location and weak in CT surgery

Allegheny General: Seems like a very good program. Very strong CT surgery, lots of graduates going into it. Possible 4+3 combined program. Residents seemed very happy, excellent turnout on the interview. Drawbacks, it is a community program, and not many graduates get competitive fellowships like peds, plastics, transplant.

BIDMC: Awesome research opportunities, way ahead of the curve when it comes to technology, MIS, and skills labs. Boston is an awesome city. Graduates basically go wherever they want for fellowships. Drawbacks, I have heard the residents get worked very very hard, possibly malignant (although the residents seemed very happy and were very honest about what goes on there). Also, not very good trauma experience. Not planning on trauma, but i think that a good program should have good trauma exposure.

Boston University: solid program, great trauma exposure. Residents seem very happy and laid back. Facilities are awesome with the new integrated medical center, boston is awesome. Drawbacks, no night float (i think they do alot of Q3) CT surgery not very good.

VCU: solid program, nice and warm in richmond 🙂 Building all kinds of great facilities, flagship VA which is amazing. Not sure about how great the fellowships graduates get are. Sounds like it might be slightly malignant and not 80 hour workweek compliant and residents are trying to hide it.

ANY THOUGHTS ON ANY OF THESE PROGRAMS WOULD BE GREATLY APPRECIATED. I also interviewed at Rush, temple, emory if anyone wants to trade opinions (cant rank them due to couples match reasons)
Thanks!!
 
366 views by you people.....and NOBODY has interviewed at these places or has any opinions on them...WOW....come on a little help people
 
Yes i understand.....but it hasnt been three hours....its been almost 3 WEEKS!!
Any advice would be appreciated.....I am couples matching so I cant really go where "I" want to go, so thats why I really need to figure out which of the programs I can rank is going to be the best one for me. Sorry, and thanks!
 
I sent you a PM about my thoughts. Hopefully you got it.
 
I didn't interview at any of these. MY current preceptor wen to Rochester about a billion yerars ago for IM, and said that it is grey and over cast from Oct to March.
Boston is a nice place to live, but expensive, even to rent. BIDMC is a well known name. BU is considered lesser than the other Boston programs (excpet Tufts), according to my MGH trained attending.

I know that isn't great info, but I wanted to contribute.
 
A lot of people may not feel comfortable expressing their opinions about programs at this time since it's ranking season and there may or may not be PDs "lurking" on the site. Though it's an anonymous forum you'd be surprised at how easy it is to identify who someone is. You may hate a program, but you don't want it documented for all to see. At least not until after Match Day 😉
 
ok thanks guys, i understand the fear of "lurkers", althought I have seen people post many times on other threads. But regardless....if anyone does have any helpful info....just drop me a private message, one or two people have done this before....I think that is the best bet.
Thanks
 
Didn't interview at any of those places (don't like the NE). An intern I met told he had a classmate at VCU and she works 100 most weeks, but apparently she likes this, so take that for what its worth.
 
Top Bottom