- Joined
- Mar 16, 2009
- Messages
- 341
- Reaction score
- 0
the parents thing and emotional and financial dependence is probably one aspect that an american will never or find it EXTREMELY difficult to understand about asians or muslim cultures...
I understand financial and emotional dependence (I was once in the same boat myself). But at some point you either need to mature into the person YOU want to become, or default into the person your parents want you to become and thus you are not truly living YOUR life but rather are a younger extention of your parents life
LOL that reminds me of what my uncle did...my family is japanese and he married a mexican....my grandma didnt speak to him for about 10 years lol. Gotta love fobs and their old traditions and racist ways.
Yeah my mother was born into a family that was Mormon. She left the church when she was 13 and when she was in her early 20's and met my father, they lived together before they were married and my mothers entire family did not speak to her for 3 years (both because he was not mormon and because they were not married while they were living together). The point is my mother was not willing to perpetuate outdated ideals just to please her parents.
I'm indian as you can figure from my username if you know your Indian states, from the state of Gujarat.
I have many muslim friends so I understand how it goes. Myself, I'm hindu and we have similar beliefs to some extent when it comes to marrying within culture.
I understand what drives children to not go against their parents. In a religions as strict as Islam where culture is deeply intertwined with religion, it is truly taboo to marry out of religion esp. for a girl because that means her children will be raised with her husband's religion and not hers. So its a huge deal. I understand why they don't want to go against their parents.. there are actually quite a few places where muslims and even some hindus and sikhs kill their daughters in honor killings over such issues.
For us, we are raised so freely that we just don't get it. But for many this is a lack of honor to their family, it goes against their relgion, against their values and belief system. So yes its a big deal. It has nothing to do with the financial dependence or emotional dependence. it has to do with traditions that are long standing based on religious and cultural beliefs.
same with the financial dependence. Traditionally, indians and Pakistanis and Bengalis, regardless of religion, are taught that boys will live with parents in adulthood and take care of their parents and family because our culture does not believe in nursing homes. It again is a matter of honor. And likewise we are taught that we are to support our children to the best of our ability so that they take care of us when they are older if they are sons, and so that we can protect our daughters until they are married.
that is the mindset that I grew up with and that is Indian culture traditionally speaking and same with the other desi cultures. I'm sure this is true in many muslim countries too.
Wow you sound like an arrogant SOB. You really don't get it do you??? have you ever had good muslim friends beynd your girlfriend?? First of all, ou say you were only with her for her looks, so why is she the bad guy for breaking it off?? Secondly, you call her a dumb witch with a b, so perhaps she did right in leaving you.
Thirdly, you don't get it. Islamic culture is not so permissive. her parents might not just have been accepting no matter what time has passed. Wake up and look at the news. see what happens at the most extreme. i.e. honor killings, harsh sharia laws, etc. Regardless of whether you are at the most extreme or a somewhat liberal muslim it is against religious beliefs, against cultural beliefs, and against the honor of a family according to those beliefs to marry against religion. Not everyone is very liberal to agree with it. Not everyone is willing to go against their parents to marry someone who their parent won't approve of. It is the same thing in hindu culture and sikh culture. She did the right thing for her family and judging by the nasty things you say on here she did the right thing and her parents did her a favor as yours did you a favor by not letting you be with someone who was not right for you. But that doesn't mean you have to insult her by calling her racist or dumb.
First: she is racist. She broke up with me for the sole reason that I was not the right skin color or born into a certain area of the world.
Second: my parents did not and will not influence those girls I choose to date. They loved my ex...they just mentioned how we may not have been very intellectually compatible (and that was only after we broke up..and probably to help me get over it)
Third: addressing the bold statement. IMO because they do not stand up for what they think is right, they are perpetuating ignorance and intolerance of another culture. For example if I did not want to associate with you because you were Indian, then I think you could say that was a little racist (even if I was only doing it to please my parents).
4th: This is how racism and intolerance gets passed along to new generations. At some point people are going to take a stand for what they believe in, even if it may disappoint their parents.
5th: Uhh... I live with my best friend who was born in India. My other good friend is an American born person with parents who were born in Sri Lanka And I have 2 other very good friends who were born in the middle east (one in Saudi Arabia and the other in Iraq). So I think I understand the "cultural pressures". On the other hand, my friends are willing to look beyond race or religion (even if it upsets their parents) they understand that if they did otherwise they would be propagating the xenophobic and racist attitudes (some of) their parents have towards other races or religions.
If it were the other way around I doubt you would give a caucasian slack. If a person had parents that were in the KKK and they decided to break up with a person of another race (even though they loved him/her) just to please their parents, I would have absolutely no respect for that person and I believe you would feel the same way. This is esentially what happend to me.