- Joined
- Nov 10, 2002
- Messages
- 8,177
- Reaction score
- 2,655
- Points
- 5,376
- Location
- The Academy
- Attending Physician

Members do not see ads. Register today.
UPDATE:
I have just added an addendum to the writeup regarding the book.
(the addendum is in italics to make it stand out for you).
UPDATE:
I have just added an addendum to the writeup regarding the book.
(the addendum is in italics to make it stand out for you).
Think I will go with lynch devyn for now. Seems like a good move. Criminals be goin' all kinds of naughtay now.

How recently, and by whom?Cyndia was recently cleared.
How recently, and by whom?
Last night, by someone I trust.
Also devyn was found to be a criminal earlier on. Lupin is the only one I know no role or character name on.
I have no idea about lupin or devyn, but I definitely don't like the idea of a vigilante with a gun on the loose, whether they are a villager or a wolf. Also, Cyndia would be an excellent target for conversion. So unless we want to check her every night, in the absence of known wolves, we should eliminate the threat.
Then why did you have her in your initial "who do I lynch" post?So you are advocating to lynch a known villager over finding a wolf. Which very well might be a 50/50 shot between devyn and lupin.
This makes me want to lynch you. There is no reason to lynch a known, seered villager.
Torn between Lupin, devyn and cyndia for who to lynch.... going to wait to see if there is any more info.
Then why did you have her in your initial "who do I lynch" post?
Then why did you have her in your initial "who do I lynch" post?
Not over a known wolf, no. But we don't have one of those this round. And unless you want to seer Cyndia every night, last night's clearance will only lull you into a false sense of security. Plus it's still possible she was converted last night, and your investigation results are pre-conversion.So you are advocating to lynch a known villager over finding a wolf. Which very well might be a 50/50 shot between devyn and lupin.
This makes me want to lynch you. There is no reason to lynch a known, seered villager.
Not over a known wolf, no. But we don't have one of those this round. And unless you want to seer Cyndia every night, last night's clearance will only lull you into a false sense of security. Plus it's still possible she was converted last night, and your investigation results are pre-conversion.
That isn't how it usually works. And then this woukd be the case for everyone. We'd have to say this about every player, including you and you weren't seered recently. So by this thought process we should just never trust investigation and lynch people we clear ask game long because they might get converted later. I'm starting to think you were converted and are trying to rid the game of someone that was recently cleared.

I had a rough night last night and am still recovering...
I am not sure what to think, but I can tell you that lynching me you will get just another blue criminal which is not what we want either... DocE knew who I was and only wanted to lynch me as he had it out for criminals... chillbo and cyndia are vouched for... I know nothing about DVM and she has been only around sporadically.... but she does not seem to be on anyone's radar... so that leaves lupin.... or samoa... and I still wonder about the samoa conversion thing - was she ever investigated? I hope so.... I am still wondering if she is the wolf we are looking for....
************
took you down with me FFM!!!!
************
Even if you are still a regular criminal, which I highly doubt since pretty everyone else here has either been spoken up for publicly or behind the scenes, it would be better to loose a known criminal with conversion possibly over a regular villager. Sad to say it, but it is practical. I also find it hard to believe that you would not be deadshot. I also am betting that the hiding wolves are in my lynch vote.
My logic is not faulty. We have had it proven criminals are conversion targets, not regular villagers. Therefore, we have a better chance in your lynch vote than mine in getting a wolf. I have told you all who I am. It would be better to investigate me and lynch a danger than to straight up loose a black type villager.I am a number for the villagers... your logic is faulty which makes me feel better about lynching you....
and you have not been spoken up for, so there is that...
I think you just might be the wolf we are looking for... I am not deadshot... I am Barton Mathis, a criminal, and I have been him all game.....
I am Walter Steele. Regular villager. Like I said, the fact that Doc had no desire to lynch me should indicate that I am in fact who I say I am. One investigates the person you are talking to.
I am a number for the villagers... your logic is faulty which makes me feel better about lynching you....
and you have not been spoken up for, so there is that...
I think you just might be the wolf we are looking for... I am not deadshot... I am Barton Mathis, a criminal, and I have been him all game.....
So...everyone left has been seered except devyn and Lupin? And I don't understand why we are trusting Samoa now. Was she actually investigated?
One more question...is there a seer item out there? I thought FFM ate the book, and I know 2 seers have died. So how did we get the results on Cyndia last night?