Best Resources?

  • Thread starter Thread starter manning18
  • Start date Start date
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
M

manning18

Is there a consensus as to what the best resources are for Step 3? I was thinking of First Aid for content and QBank for Q's, as I like QBank more than UW overall. How many weeks would one need to study to score around 210/85 ? I can probably devote 10-30 hours/week depending on the week. I have not started Residency yet. Thanks.
 
Hi, i just finished my first medicine rotation as an intern and doing a lighter elective now and wanted to purchase the First Aid Step 3, which was published in 2004, but I heard that a newer edition will be published this October 2007.

I was planning to take my Step 3 in the spring during my vacation from ER, after I have finished my Outpatient, Surgery, Peds, Psych, OB, and ICU rotations.

What should I do? Should I just buy the old edition and study from that or study from something else for now:
- Crush Step 3?
- USMLE Help Step 3 CCS by Praetzel (published in 2007), saw it on amazon, with two 5/5 reviews, but not sure if that's a good source
- board and wards, ayala

was planing to read something, while doing questions from an online source like usmleworld and/or usmlestep123

help please! thanks.
 
I've read a few chapters in Strong Medicine and have done about 50 questions in the NMS book. I've read +/- reviews of Strong and mostly + reviews of the NMS book. Both of these books seem to be helpful so far👍
 
dunno.

I signed up for step 3 but I was told by fellow residents that I gotta sit for the exam within 90 days now ...

so I'm kinda rushing to figure out what to do to study for it.

Just finished a month of medicine. I got ER next, then heme/onc then cards. I got a week of vacation in cards and then path. So my goal is to extend my test period so I can look to take it at teh end of noveber (when I'm in path).

Not sure how to go about studying though. Read some washing manual. then switchign to crush or first aid and read through those twice.while doing uw?
 
There is no "best" resource for this exam. The exam tests heavily on stuff that is not covered in review books. Majority of the exam is outpatient medicine and ER visits. Most of the Step 3 review books use the same information as Step 2 i.e inpatient stuff.

Only 1/3 of the exam is Step 2 CK material...

My best advice is to know the risk factors and prognosis for the major CV, GI, RENAL, MSK, Neuro, Pulmonary diseases. Do Qbook, Qbank, or USMLEWORLD. Doing Questions is the key.

Most of the time they give you the Dx and ask you for risk factors, initial workup, or prognosis for the disease.
 
There is no "best" resource for this exam. The exam tests heavily on stuff that is not covered in review books. Majority of the exam is outpatient medicine and ER visits. Most of the Step 3 review books use the same information as Step 2 i.e inpatient stuff.

Only 1/3 of the exam is Step 2 CK material...

My best advice is to know the risk factors and prognosis for the major CV, GI, RENAL, MSK, Neuro, Pulmonary diseases. Do Qbook, Qbank, or USMLEWORLD. Doing Questions is the key.

Most of the time they give you the Dx and ask you for risk factors, initial workup, or prognosis for the disease.

I agree. Inpatient treatment of common diseases as well as emergency/ambulatory "what would you do next" is key.
 
recommend usmlesteps123.com for understanding case scenarios and how to be efficient.
 
Got a 246/99, which was a (pleasant) surprise, as I was expecting my score to be much lower. Although, I think I have good test-taking genes, which makes up for my friggin' dark cloud I've had during intern year.

If you have the luxury, like I did of being able to study for 3-4 weeks (I studied 3-4hrs a day during an outpatient month), I recommend the following resources:

1. USMLE CD with MCQ and CCS cases - the highest yield review source; the concepts tested on the MCQ section of the practice CD were very similar to those on the real thing; a few questions were virtually identical
2. Boards and Wards (I like the format of this book; the organization makes it easier to read than say FA)
3. USMLE World - I did about 1000 questions and was averaging in the high 50s. I thought it was a helpful resource to get my mind back into some specialties I hadn't thought about in years (OB, Peds) but the concepts tested on the actual exam were not reflected by the USMLE World questions
4. High Yield OB - I LOVE this book. OB/GYN is a beast in and of itself with its own language, and there was no chance I was going to be able to remember from my med school rotation or intuit my way around dysfunctional uterine bleeding, failure to progress, third trimester bleeding, ASCUS on a Pap, etc. I used this both for my shelf and for Step 2, and I think it's such a hidden gem.
5. Crush Step 3 - Literally skimmed this in a day or so a few days before my test. I didn't want to use this is a primary review source because I find the material to be somewhat general and disorganized. BUT it was great for consolidating in my head everything I had reviewed between Boards and Wards and USMLE World.
6. USMLESteps123.com - agree with dre. i LOVED this for my CCS cases. It is expensive. I basically paid $60 to use it for a day. The interactive format is different than the actual exam, but the real value is in the ANSWER KEY they provide for each case. There are 100 cases I think, and I did about 40 of them. The trouble I had with just the cases on the practice CD was knowing what and how they expected to do things in terms of priority and sequence. I was confused on whether I should check results as "next available" or set a time to check in a few hours. What things do i need to before a physical if a pt arrives in the ED? (ie, continuous cardiac monitor, continuous bp monitor, O2, IV access) All of these things get sorted out in the ANSWER KEY for the case by telling you what should have been done, how it should have been done, and in what sequence, which are all part of the scoring rubric for CCS. The explanations of the cases seemed pretty helpful, too, but I was short on time and didn't really read them. I didn't bother working through entire cases to the end to get them scored.

I personally think the CCS cases bumped by score significantly. It was clearly my strongest area on my performance profile, and overall, I had felt really good about them. I had taken the NBME practice test a week before the exam (after about 2.5 weeks of studying) and it predicted a score of 590, which is ~228 calclulated based on the mean and SD. I felt worse about the MCQs on the real thing than the NBME, so I don't think the jump in my real score was from MCQs, but I think instead the cases were a boost.
 
I recommend the following:

1 First AID Step 3 and Crush
2. NMS (Format not the same, but excellend content. Go thru twice)
3. MKSAP (Read thru twice)
4 USMLE 123 for CCS
 
I took this exam after my intern year

i recommend

1. Do the CD they send you at least 5 times
2. FA or crush, doesn't matter which one, as long as you read it.
3. Usmle world questions and cases.

I flipped through the book over four months, and did questions..an hour here, an hour there kind of thing. by the time my exam date came around i was confident.

Most of you will study for two weeks and do fine.

Kind regards,
Many thanks,
Yours sincerely
 
Top