I do think allopathic students debate this sometimes in their discussions, but you are right Zinger09 in that I believe a lot of DO students feel a little insecure, and it is annoying sometimes. Like the campaigns to, "get a DO on house MD" or whatever tv shows are out there. It's a little silly
Back to the OP: the newer schools may not have federal funding availible and that is something to remember. In other words, Standford & Perkins loans are not an option which makes school way more expensive. Not always a problem for every new school so you have to research this for schools you are looking at.
plus you won't be eligible for the National Health Service Corps scholarship until they graduate their first class, if that means anything to you. Otherwise you get the same degree everywhere...it's just a matter of personal preference
This is something you should look at. Fortunately, the "Tennessee school" or LMU-DCOM does have federal funding, so getting loans is not a problem. We do not have the National Health Service Corps scholarship yet, but we will after we graduate.
And for what its worth, LMU-DCOM is very solid, so don't be worried about it being a new school. Yes, it doesn't have the reputation of CCOM, PCOM and the other older schools, but we will. You just have to give us a few years.
As this thread has shown, the "best" school is extremely subjective. The thing is, you have no way of comparing schools except for interview days. While slightly helpful, you never know how a school truly is until going thru the daily grind of the curriculum. Plus, you don't have people going from one school to another, so the only perspective they get is the school they are at. So, one is going to say where they are at is the best, or those who haven't even started are going to say the school they were accepted to is the best.
Perhaps the better judge is how happy are the students and faculty? If you are a technology person, how do schools compare? If location is important, how do schools compare? Is the curriculum lecture-based or PBL, and which do you prefer? These are all MORE important than which is the best b/c if you hate PBL but you hear LECOM-B is the best, well, then you are SOL and won't be happy. So, figure out what is important and go from there and remember that HAPPINESS will get you a lot further than some botched ranking system.