Bullcrap salary figures on about.com

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Those numbers seem high even for someone in private practice who works like 70 hours per week.
 
http://healthcareers.about.com/od/compensationinformation/f/TopPayDoctors.htm

Apparently, rad oncs make $528k and hem/oncs make $449k? These numbers are higher than the highest figures found on national surveys (such as cejka) which (according to word of mouth here) tend to overestimate actual salaries. Where did they get these numbers?

i personally know an internationally reknowned pediatric hem/onc and know he does not make that much.....even after adding in how much he makes on sports gambling lol.
 
Those numbers are going to vary widely depending on where in the US one practices, how the practice is set up and a handful of other factors. It's hard if not impossible to find nation-wide numbers that everyone can agree on.
 
I like AMGA/MGMA for salary figures though too much variability still exists in saying "for sure"...
 
I think About.com is like Wikipedia in that articles can be written by anyone, hence the misinformation.
 
i personally know an internationally reknowned pediatric hem/onc and know he does not make that much.....even after adding in how much he makes on sports gambling lol.

This is not surprising.

"Internationally reknowned" physicians are usually in academics, which tend to make significantly less than private practice docs. Unfortunately, respect often doesn't equate to money in medicine.
 
I know a surgeon-turned-radiologist that makes 500k+ a year. This is at one of his part time jobs. I don't know what he makes at his other jobs.
 
I know a surgeon-turned-radiologist that makes 500k+ a year. This is at one of his part time jobs. I don't know what he makes at his other jobs.
:bullcrap:

no wait....

:bullcrap::bullcrap::bullcrap::bullcrap:


seems like we all know that token doctor who does nothing yet makes a mil.
 
Hi,
My name is Andrea and I wrote the article about physician compensation that you are referencing and just wanted to clarify the source for you, because there seems to be some confusion. Thank you so much for visiting my Health Careers site at About.com - I'd like to assure you that I'm not just a random person! I am a professional physician recruiter (at The Medicus Firm) so I can vouch that these numbers are accurate.

I obtained all of the salary data directly from the MGMA (Medical Group Management Association) Annual Physician Salary report which is the benchmark most hospitals use when recruiting physicians and establishing compensation packages. The numbers are from the 2008 report and do need to be updated for 2009, however, the '09 numbers will look similar.

Keep in mind these figures are NOT starting salaries, but include physicians who have built up busy practices. Also, I talk to physicians in all of these specialties each day and can assure you that these MGMA figures are in line with what I'm hearing from physicians, as part of my discussion about their careers always must include their earnings.
As someone mentioned in the thread, academic physicians often make much less because they do not see patients full-time - they are researching and teaching in addition to seeing patients, and often as you mentioned, those are the "world-renowned" highly respected physicians but they are not necessarily earning the most money.

I hope this will help clear up some questions, and also let you know a little more about me, my health careers site, and About.com in general. Unlike many of our competitors, About.com has a very rigorous writer selection process and each writer must be an expert in his or her field. I have worked in the medical field since 1998 and while I'm not a clinician, I have worked closely with them and placed hundreds of medical professionals nationwide, so I have had to learn about a lot of different types of medical careers over the years.

I'd love to hear any other feedback you have, and to have you as visitors on my site! Please keep in touch and best of luck to you all with your future physician careers! You are welcome to email me at healthcareers[dot]guide[at]about[dot]com any time if there are any questions you have, story/article ideas, comments etc! I look forward to hearing from you.

Regards,
Andrea
Guide to Health Careers
 
Hey Andrea,

Are you saying that these figures exclude the academic figures? If not, how much would you say the average private practice physician makes in comparison to academics?
 
LOL Bunch of premed just got owned...Despite how much people cry about the potential for huge cut, currently specialists makes handsome salaries if they run a semi-efficient practice.
 
Hey Andrea,

Are you saying that these figures exclude the academic figures? If not, how much would you say the average private practice physician makes in comparison to academics?

That is an impossibly broad question to answer succinctly. Depending on specialty, style of practice, and location you will obtain wildly different numbers. As a very general rule private practice has higher earning potential, but that comes with higher headache potential as you are essentially part of a small business operation.
 
Good question He2. Academic physicians are not completely excluded from the MGMA salary survey/study, but they make up a very low percentage of the data. The compensation figures are based on averages and median earnings, and therefore the low percentage (1-2%) of academic physicians who are included in the data are outweighed by the higher salaries of the private physicians. There are simply more private practice physicians than there are academic physicians.

In terms of how much academic physicians earn in comparison to private physicians, that's difficult to say with certainty, but if I had to guess, I'd say academic physicians earn anywhere from 25-40% less than private physicians, at least. The discrepancy is higher in specialties with higher earnings, and there is probably less of a difference in primary care or lower-earning specialties. Again, that's just a guess-timate on my part but whenever I interview academic physicians, they are earning considerably less than their private practice counterparts.

That being said, there are many physicians who love academics! They are passionate about research and teaching, and the money doesn't matter to them. But sometimes they get burned out after a while, of working so many hours for less pay - academics is a lot of work, and usually entails long hours, because not only are you providing patient care, you're doing time-consuming research, and teaching, which entails a lot of additional documentation in addition to your professional time.

However, you're making an impact in many different ways as an academic physician, because not only are you providing medical care to patients, you're also helping to develop new therapies and methodologies through your research, and you're impacting future physicians as well! So academics is very intrinsically rewarding for many physicians, which is why they may not be as concerned about the lower financial remuneration.
I hope that answers your question, thanks!
Regards,
Andrea
 
Hi,
My name is Andrea and I wrote the article about physician compensation that you are referencing and just wanted to clarify the source for you, because there seems to be some confusion. Thank you so much for visiting my Health Careers site at About.com - I'd like to assure you that I'm not just a random person! I am a professional physician recruiter (at The Medicus Firm) so I can vouch that these numbers are accurate.

I obtained all of the salary data directly from the MGMA (Medical Group Management Association) Annual Physician Salary report which is the benchmark most hospitals use when recruiting physicians and establishing compensation packages. The numbers are from the 2008 report and do need to be updated for 2009, however, the '09 numbers will look similar.

Keep in mind these figures are NOT starting salaries, but include physicians who have built up busy practices. Also, I talk to physicians in all of these specialties each day and can assure you that these MGMA figures are in line with what I'm hearing from physicians, as part of my discussion about their careers always must include their earnings.
As someone mentioned in the thread, academic physicians often make much less because they do not see patients full-time - they are researching and teaching in addition to seeing patients, and often as you mentioned, those are the "world-renowned" highly respected physicians but they are not necessarily earning the most money.

I hope this will help clear up some questions, and also let you know a little more about me, my health careers site, and About.com in general. Unlike many of our competitors, About.com has a very rigorous writer selection process and each writer must be an expert in his or her field. I have worked in the medical field since 1998 and while I'm not a clinician, I have worked closely with them and placed hundreds of medical professionals nationwide, so I have had to learn about a lot of different types of medical careers over the years.

I'd love to hear any other feedback you have, and to have you as visitors on my site! Please keep in touch and best of luck to you all with your future physician careers! You are welcome to email me at healthcareers[dot]guide[at]about[dot]com any time if there are any questions you have, story/article ideas, comments etc! I look forward to hearing from you.

Regards,
Andrea
Guide to Health Careers


Wow, what a coincidence! This is so cool haha. Thanks for the reply!
 
Do these salaries have malpractice already subtracted out of them?
 
Wow I wonder how the article writer found us. This thread hasn't been up for that long.
 
Hi,
My name is Andrea and I wrote the article about physician compensation that you are referencing and just wanted to clarify the source for you, because there seems to be some confusion. Thank you so much for visiting my Health Careers site at About.com - I'd like to assure you that I'm not just a random person! I am a professional physician recruiter (at The Medicus Firm) so I can vouch that these numbers are accurate.

I obtained all of the salary data directly from the MGMA (Medical Group Management Association) Annual Physician Salary report which is the benchmark most hospitals use when recruiting physicians and establishing compensation packages. The numbers are from the 2008 report and do need to be updated for 2009, however, the '09 numbers will look similar.

Keep in mind these figures are NOT starting salaries, but include physicians who have built up busy practices. Also, I talk to physicians in all of these specialties each day and can assure you that these MGMA figures are in line with what I'm hearing from physicians, as part of my discussion about their careers always must include their earnings.
As someone mentioned in the thread, academic physicians often make much less because they do not see patients full-time - they are researching and teaching in addition to seeing patients, and often as you mentioned, those are the "world-renowned" highly respected physicians but they are not necessarily earning the most money.

I hope this will help clear up some questions, and also let you know a little more about me, my health careers site, and About.com in general. Unlike many of our competitors, About.com has a very rigorous writer selection process and each writer must be an expert in his or her field. I have worked in the medical field since 1998 and while I'm not a clinician, I have worked closely with them and placed hundreds of medical professionals nationwide, so I have had to learn about a lot of different types of medical careers over the years.

I'd love to hear any other feedback you have, and to have you as visitors on my site! Please keep in touch and best of luck to you all with your future physician careers! You are welcome to email me at healthcareers[dot]guide[at]about[dot]com any time if there are any questions you have, story/article ideas, comments etc! I look forward to hearing from you.

Regards,
Andrea
Guide to Health Careers


With all due respect, some of those numbers cannot be correct.

I don't know of a single oncologist (med or rad) who makes close to what you and MGMA have quoted as the average.

Furthermore, the statement that pediatric surgeons are among the highest paid is incorrect. Across the board, pediatric surgeons make far less than their adult counterparts. General pediatric surgeons are among the lowest salaried surgeons.
 
Hi,
My name is Andrea and I wrote the article about physician compensation that you are referencing and just wanted to clarify the source for you, because there seems to be some confusion. Thank you so much for visiting my Health Careers site at About.com - I'd like to assure you that I'm not just a random person! I am a professional physician recruiter (at The Medicus Firm) so I can vouch that these numbers are accurate.

I obtained all of the salary data directly from the MGMA (Medical Group Management Association) Annual Physician Salary report which is the benchmark most hospitals use when recruiting physicians and establishing compensation packages. The numbers are from the 2008 report and do need to be updated for 2009, however, the '09 numbers will look similar.

Keep in mind these figures are NOT starting salaries, but include physicians who have built up busy practices. Also, I talk to physicians in all of these specialties each day and can assure you that these MGMA figures are in line with what I'm hearing from physicians, as part of my discussion about their careers always must include their earnings.
As someone mentioned in the thread, academic physicians often make much less because they do not see patients full-time - they are researching and teaching in addition to seeing patients, and often as you mentioned, those are the "world-renowned" highly respected physicians but they are not necessarily earning the most money.

I hope this will help clear up some questions, and also let you know a little more about me, my health careers site, and About.com in general. Unlike many of our competitors, About.com has a very rigorous writer selection process and each writer must be an expert in his or her field. I have worked in the medical field since 1998 and while I'm not a clinician, I have worked closely with them and placed hundreds of medical professionals nationwide, so I have had to learn about a lot of different types of medical careers over the years.

I'd love to hear any other feedback you have, and to have you as visitors on my site! Please keep in touch and best of luck to you all with your future physician careers! You are welcome to email me at healthcareers[dot]guide[at]about[dot]com any time if there are any questions you have, story/article ideas, comments etc! I look forward to hearing from you.

Regards,
Andrea
Guide to Health Careers

hi

your numbers are incorrect. you need to find different "experts.".....i just spoke with several oncologists, both ones in private practice and those in academic medicine, including my personal close friend, and they said that their salaries are nowhere NEAR your figures.....AND those in private pracice have very well established and busy (unfortunately) practices in large cities (Chicago, Houston, Phoenix, NY) please do more accurate research.

thanks
 
hi

your numbers are incorrect. you need to find different "experts.".....i just spoke with several oncologists, both ones in private practice and those in academic medicine, including my personal close friend, and they said that their salaries are nowhere NEAR your figures.....AND those in private pracice have very well established and busy (unfortunately) practices in large cities (Chicago, Houston, Phoenix, NY) please do more accurate research.

thanks

Hi, anecdotal stories from friends is much more appealing to me than well thought out research. You should do things my way. Thanks.

To add to the anecdotal side I know a intervent rad who makes that easily and is recruiting rads with 2 years left of residency starting at 350K and 16 weeks vacation. This is in a small town....hmm I guess anecdotal is better!
 
Hi, anecdotal stories from friends is much more appealing to me than well thought out research. You should do things my way. Thanks.

To add to the anecdotal side I know a intervent rad who makes that easily and is recruiting rads with 2 years left of residency starting at 350K and 16 weeks vacation. This is in a small town....hmm I guess anecdotal is better!

i'm confused....in the first paragraph of your response, are you being sarcastic? these are actual practicing oncs i know (both as family members and unfortunately through personal experiences with friends/family)
 
Last edited:
i'm confused....in the first paragraph of your response, are you being sarcastic? these are actual practicing oncs i know (both as family members and unfortunately through personal experiences with friends/family)

I'm pretty sure it was sarcasm that pointed out that we all have someone we "know" that can prove the other person wrong.
 
LOL Bunch of premed just got owned...Despite how much people cry about the potential for huge cut, currently specialists makes handsome salaries if they run a semi-efficient practice.

How was anyone owned?
 
LOL Bunch of premed just got owned.

I too am enjoying this thread. H/O seems a high, but I truthfully don't know that much about salaries. I have always been told that a lot of averages are driven down by part time and academic positions.
 
im gonna say these are pre-income tax and pre-malpractice deducted

Malpractice is generally considered part of business expenses, and therefore not included in salary assessments in this country. What you are seeing are pre-income tax earnings.
 
hi

your numbers are incorrect. you need to find different "experts.".....i just spoke with several oncologists, both ones in private practice and those in academic medicine, including my personal close friend, and they said that their salaries are nowhere NEAR your figures.....AND those in private pracice have very well established and busy (unfortunately) practices in large cities (Chicago, Houston, Phoenix, NY) please do more accurate research.

thanks

Large cities are often the most saturated markets for healthcare. Go where there is less supply and more demand and you will be rewarded. My anecdote: friend of a friend in his 1st year of heme/onc practice in the Dakotas: ~500K. Or you can go to a large city, carry 20 complicated patients/day, and make 180K. The choice is yours.
 
Large cities are often the most saturated markets for healthcare. Go where there is less supply and more demand and you will be rewarded. My anecdote: friend of a friend in his 1st year of heme/onc practice in the Dakotas: ~500K. Or you can go to a large city, carry 20 complicated patients/day, and make 180K. The choice is yours.

I choose living in LA!

1) The supply is lower in rural cities, but so is the demand. The actual difference in salaries is not as drastic as you make it out to be
2) A lot of other stuff are cheaper in the city too (ie: haircuts, restaurants, other services) since business are more competitive with each other, so it offsets the lower pay a little (although housing is more expensive, but then again that means your house will be worth more when you sell it).
 
Large cities are often the most saturated markets for healthcare. Go where there is less supply and more demand and you will be rewarded. My anecdote: friend of a friend in his 1st year of heme/onc practice in the Dakotas: ~500K. Or you can go to a large city, carry 20 complicated patients/day, and make 180K. The choice is yours.

Completely agree with this. Just search websites for jobs in any specialty. For example, if you search Ortho, you will find starting salary guarantees at $500-600k (w/ bonuses close to $1mil) in rural areas or smaller cities vs. $250k (w/ $500k bonuses) in larger cities. It's all about supply and demand.

For example:

Job Description

Looking for an orthopedic surgeon who wants to practice within 2 hours of Chicago. This is an employed position with a salary of 800K.

VS.

50 physician multi specialty group in the western Chicago suburbs is looking to add an additional orthopedic surgeon for one of their offices. This office currently has two physicians. They are growing due to patient increases. Work at only two hospitals and share in a 1 in 3 call rotation. They are offering a first year salary guarantee of $300,000 and increases with experience plus productivity bonuses.
 
i personally know a rad onc who makes between 500K and 1M per year. it is possible.
 
It's not that unreasonable to assume that the author may be inflating the averages a bit. She does work for a medical headhunting company so she would want existing doctors to contact her to try to get higher paying positions (because part of her income comes from commissions). So it's not exactly from a nonbiased source.

Just my two cents.
 
i'm confused....in the first paragraph of your response, are you being sarcastic? these are actual practicing oncs i know (both as family members and unfortunately through personal experiences with friends/family)

I'm pretty sure it was sarcasm that pointed out that we all have someone we "know" that can prove the other person wrong.

Thanks chman, sorry jturkel my sarcasm doesn't communicate well via text. Yes, I was saying that everyone can pull some story about someone they know; as I did with the interventional rad who makes well over that amount. The problem is anecdotal evidence is really not that compelling. Salaries vary and there are many circumstances that can contribute to their variability.

The other part of my sarcasm was to point out that your post seemed a little aggressive.
 
Hi there,
Just thought I'd check in again ~ I figured there might be some more questions! Hope this helps:
1) The figures are gross income and are stated before taxes come out. I'm not sure about the malpractice thing, I'll check into that, but I think that the figures in the MGMA report are earnings after malpractice is paid out but I could be wrong.
2) If you think the numbers are high, I don't know what more to say to that, other than talk to the MGMA as they are the ones who obtain the figures, I just report them! 🙂 Again, the MGMA is highly respected as the benchmark for physician pay, and many hospitals use the annual compensation report when establishing physician comp plans - it's not just our firm that uses MGMA figures. I will look again but I think for the "highest paid" doctors article that started this whole thread, I did quote the docs with the highest TOP-end pay - so those figures in the article are not MEAN/AVG or median incomes - those salaries may be in the top 25% (e.g. only about 1/4 of all docs make that in that specialty, as opposed to AVG earnings) - because the article is about the TOP earners. For MEAN/AVG and MEDIAN figures, you can refer to the physician profile for the specialty you're interested in and that will contain the MEDIAN income (50th percentile). Also, one thing that may be causing a discrepancy is the technical fees. Most doctors make the bulk of their income by billing for, and being paid for their time (professional fees). However, if they own equipment (such as a nuclear camera, or an ultrasound machine, MRI, or whatever the case may be) they can increase their income because they can bill for and earn money from what's called a technical fee for the use of that capital equipment. (another reason academic docs earn less - the university owns the equipment, so academic docs can't earn any $ off of the technical fee). When docs own equipment or run an outpatient surgery center etc they can increase their income significantly because they can bill for the technical fees for the use of the equipment. Of course that requires a significant captial investment to buy the equipment, which is not reflected in salary figures for MGMA or any salary survey. For example, Oncologists can earn a lot more if they are owner or part owner in an infusion center for chemotherapy, or a cancer center with lots of imaging or radiation equipment, etc. If an oncologist is working as an employee of a group practice or hospital and has no ownership in any equipment, his/her income will be much lower, if they are "only" able to earn money for professional fees.
3) My commissions and the placement fees are a flat rate, regardless of the salary, because we work on a retained basis (meaning our clients/hospitals pay us on an ongoing basis, not just on the back end after placement is made - it's sort of like outsourcing the recruitment to us), so the placement fee that clients pay is about $16k (plus retainer fees and monthly fees which are also a flat rate fee) whether the physician is offered $200k or $400k, or more.
4) I found the thread via google alerts - gotta love google! 🙂 I highly recommend setting up an alert for your name, to keep track of your online presence, as well as any domain names you own if you ever have your own blog or website. When you begin interviewing for med schools, residencies, and jobs, people will look you up online and you'll want to know what the internet is saying about you! Just a random tip for future reference.
5) Regarding earnings in small towns vs. large cities, I also wrote an article about that too ~ (but these #s are based on MGMA too, just so you know!) It's interesting ~ most physicians (not all) do earn more in small to mid-sized towns, for a number of reasons - one reason is supply and demand, and lack of competition, but also reimbursements are often higher and overhead is lower as well - it's hard to explain but insurance companies have more leverage in big cities, and they can negotiate lower reimbursement rates by pitting multiple physician groups and hospitals against each other, whereas in small towns, the big hospital (usually only 1 or 2) has more leverage to demand higher reimbursements from the insurance companies (within reason).
A lot of this info is stuff they'll never teach you in med school (or residency, or fellowship) so keep doing your research! But as you can see, you can't believe everything you hear, read, see, etc. You guys (and gals) will be ahead of the game, I can tell - it's good to be analytical - I like your style! 🙂 Keep up the great work.
Regards,
Andrea
 
With all due respect, some of those numbers cannot be correct.

I don't know of a single oncologist (med or rad) who makes close to what you and MGMA have quoted as the average.

Furthermore, the statement that pediatric surgeons are among the highest paid is incorrect. Across the board, pediatric surgeons make far less than their adult counterparts. General pediatric surgeons are among the lowest salaried surgeons.

One of my friends mom is a rad onc, she is making over 750K in her practice, it's possible.

I don't see why you would disagree with a person that specializes in placing physicians and has a lot more personal experience with physician salaries than you probably do?
 
[...] I will look again but I think for the "highest paid" doctors article that started this whole thread, I did quote the docs with the highest TOP-end pay - so those figures in the article are not MEAN/AVG or median incomes - those salaries may be in the top 25% (e.g. only about 1/4 of all docs make that in that specialty, as opposed to AVG earnings) - because the article is about the TOP earners.[...]

Quoted for emphasis.
 
4) I found the thread via google alerts - gotta love google! 🙂 I highly recommend setting up an alert for your name, to keep track of your online presence, as well as any domain names you own if you ever have your own blog or website. When you begin interviewing for med schools, residencies, and jobs, people will look you up online and you'll want to know what the internet is saying about you! Just a random tip for future reference.

This is actually a great piece of advice. I concur. 👍
 
I choose living in LA!

1) The supply is lower in rural cities, but so is the demand. The actual difference in salaries is not as drastic as you make it out to be
2) A lot of other stuff are cheaper in the city too (ie: haircuts, restaurants, other services) since business are more competitive with each other, so it offsets the lower pay a little (although housing is more expensive, but then again that means your house will be worth more when you sell it).

LA = :barf:

JK, but not really...😛
 
:bullcrap:

no wait....

:bullcrap::bullcrap::bullcrap::bullcrap:


seems like we all know that token doctor who does nothing yet makes a mil.

I don't know why you think I'm BSing you. I have better things to do than lie on an internet forum. Is it really so outlandish for a radiologist to make 500k at a part time job? Obviously, he worked very hard to get there. In addition, take a look at all of the anecdotes on this thread about radiologists making at least that much.
 
Top