Can someone please read my Personal Statement-Application Time

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Miss155

Senior Member
15+ Year Member
20+ Year Member
Joined
Jul 13, 2003
Messages
323
Reaction score
1
Hi

Please can someone give me some feedback on my essay. I also need some help cutting down the essay. Thank you.


“Benefit not from the illness of mankind.”
Throughout my life I have been wrestling with this complex conflict, which was a personal cultural proverb of mine as I was growing up, surrounded by traditional medicinal healers. My resolution to this paradox was revealed, as I became the patient and not the observer, which is when the answer to my dilemma began to slowly unravel. “Benefit not from the illness of man” was a premise upon which my grandfather based his practice of traditional medicine. Never charging anyone a dime for his services, he believed that the herbs (roots, leaves, tree-barks and stems) are God’s free gift to humanity and the knowledge of his traditional medicine was a divine favor. A farmer by trade, medicine was his calling – a sort of “hobby”. I became interested in medicine since childhood from a series of unfortunate events and it dawned upon me that in their profession, Western or traditional, physicians meet most people as “patients”. Patients, sick, injured, unhappy and vulnerable people in need of help. It also concerned me that physicians in the western hemisphere are immeasurably rich compared to their traditional counterparts and hence a conflict with my grandfather’s syllogism. Being born and raised in Houston, I have always asked how one practices medicine here, in the States, without “benefiting from man’s illness”.
This was my predicament until about four and half years ago I fell sick with uterine bleeding. The pain, the intense, agonizing and excruciating pain radiating through my body from by abdomen was unbearable. I ended up in a local hospital’s emergency room and in an instant; I became a ‘patient’ – a sick, injured, unhappy and vulnerable person in dire need of help. I was no longer an observer, an outsider-looking –in. I was an insider and the reason for action. I was made comfortable, scoped and cured. My stay at the hospital and the wonderful care of the healthcare professionals enlightened me about the wonderful world of medicine especially the field of obstetrics and gynecology. When I was able to feel well again I immediately started to research about ovarian cyst, which was the cause of my condition and its various causes and symptoms. My research and personal experience motivated me to want to further pursue the field of women’s healthcare. I was able to experience the same feeling people feel when they are at their weakest moment, that is why I would like to become a doctor so that their weakest moment will not be their last.
My initial mission was to mentor and guide lower classmen in their journey to an amazing and fulfilling college experience. I greatly loved my experience guiding impressionable freshman for example, by helping them select their school schedules and soften any rough spots encountered while attending the university that I later chose to mentor for Big Brother and Big Sister program. As I loved working with high school and college students, my time spent volunteering for my local hospital was also very gratifying. I volunteered in various places within the hospital every week, but later found my calling in the Labor/Delivery unit. I witnessed very strong women experience agonizing ailments at all hours of the day.
Observing the strength and vitality of these awe-inspiring women became a parallel depiction later in my life as I also became a mother. I distinctly remember being in my daughter’s pediatrician waiting room while I brought out my large Princeton Review science workbook to work out physics problems as I was preparing for the upcoming April 2005 MCAT without any hesitation toward what other parents might think. During this time I was studying for the April 2005 MCAT, taking full-time classes including Organic Chemistry II, attending Princeton Review classes four times a week, and caring for my child who was still under the age of one. The Spring 2005 semester was one of the most difficult and time consuming but I was determined, driven, and passionate to make a high GPA and do equally well on the MCAT. This instance is another example among many, indicating how I desperately tried to utilize my time efficiently even if I only had 15 minutes to spare to study. During the entire semester from the beginning to the end I kept thinking and fantasizing how I will get through this tough ordeal and my dream would be finally fulfilled. Due to my organized time planning and stamina I was able to manage my time well even with my new life and still achieve a high GPA and engage in extracurricular activities, which indicates that I can overcome obstacles and deal with stress which may present itself as I journey the bumpy, narrow road to become a medical doctor. I am not like other applicants therefore I feel that my life experiences has enabled me to become well rounded and realize that life is not simple and rosy posy which is a valuable trait to encapsulate as I enter a world where residents work 60 or more hours a week.
In my personal experience and several others I witnessed while volunteering at the hospital, I was profoundly touched and impressed by the passion of these decent sages by their intense commitment to saving lives irrespective of the situation. I was struck deeply by their dedication to such intricate detail as the restoration of “fine motor movement” through physical therapy and their near omniscient nature in the scientific art of medicine. That is noble, and that evoked my utmost veneration for the profession. My experience at the hospital led me to even further want to help women. I decided to volunteer for a center in my area, which catered to battered and sexually abused women. I met women and children who went through terrible ordeals and had no safe haven to go. These experiences really solidify my desire to want to work with women in need that I shortly began to shadow a local doctor in my area. I was humbled by the selfless and indiscriminate efforts of the physician to treat the homeless, poor immigrants and citizens without health insurance coverage. This physician risked his life to treat his patients (some with H.I.V and other communicable diseases) knowing that any mistake may cause him his life.
Through my various encounters, both as an insider and outsider, I was able to answer my original dilemma, which I was initially battling before actually becoming the ‘patient’ – a sick, injured, unhappy and vulnerable. I resolved my conflict by realizing that physicians, whether traditional or western, could never really “benefit from the illness of mankind” because one can never place a monetary value on man’s life. Everyday as physicians attempt to treat patients, they indirectly place their life in danger by exposing themselves to various transmissible diseases, thus physicians are not able to benefit from the illness of mankind nor can legal tender replace the selfless acts exemplified by physicians.
 
Ok. First off, great essay! You definitely stand out from the crowd. Here are my suggestions

1) I feel that you can cut your essay down a bit. EX: "Due to my organized time planning and stamina I was able to manage my time well even with my new life and still achieve a high GPA and engage in extracurricular activities, which indicates that I can overcome obstacles and deal with stress which may present itself as I journey the bumpy, narrow road to become a medical doctor." Too long of a sentence.

2) Too much details. Not that details aren't good (little details put a personal touch on the essay) but I think one or two is plenty. Chop down some and it'll be perfect!

3) Conclusion could be a bit more workout...I know you resolved your cleverly put paradox, however I think you should sum up why you want to pursue medicine and support it with the your personal qualities which you highlighted in the essay.

Great read.

Best wishes.
 
This essay has potential, but it is hard on the reader to get through. Your sentences tend to run on quite a bit. Say what you need to by including pertinent details only. Saying things like "The pain, the intense, agonizing and excruciating pain " is redundant. You may also want to be careful because you do not want your essay to come across as a plea for sympathy. It is obvious you have overcome hardship, but realize that many pre-meds have to balance ECs, classwork, and studying for the MCAT. So what makes you different? Having a child to raise? Yes, definitely so you might want to focus on that instead. Anyways, PM me if you need more help! 🙂
 
i'm also applying this cycle and so don't have much experience, but your essay raised a couple of questions for me which you might want to think about in case your interviewer (i'm sure you'll have many 😉 ) also wonders the same thing....

so first, how do you plan to manage medical school and being a mother? what difficulties (emotional, financial, grade-wise, etc) do you expect to enounter and how have you prepared to deal with them?

and second, your quote is definitely interesting and attention-grabbing. And your conclusion offers a strong (and well-put!) justification. But I for one am interested in endocrinology, and Type II diabetes in particular, which does not put my life in danger at all. And yes, I will still charge my patients :laugh: how would you justify that?

--again, i hope you don't take this the wrong way and get defensive, and i'm not saying that you should necessarily add these considerations to the essay, but its just something that you might want to think about: imagine getting an endocrinologist for an interviewer, which is def possible. 👍
 
Your essay is WAY too long. You need to remove 1,634 characters.
 
Miss155 said:
Please can someone give me some feedback on my essay. I also need some help cutting down the essay. Thank you.
Nice essay. You obviously put a lot of thought and heart into it.

You might want to have a hack at it to try to get your actual voice to shine through a bit more. We all have a habit of writing in a voice far more formal and contrived than how we actually communicate. If you can get your writing to reflect how you actually talk (on a good day), the essay will shine. I think that that's particularly important for an essay as personal as your own.

One technique I've taught students is what I call the drooler test. Read your essay aloud and imagine how you'd reword it verbally if someone didn't understand. The second version is almost always better than the first. This is similar to Hemmingway's "bullsh*t detector".
 
Be prepared that a lot of potential ADCOM's may disagree with your quote and may be turned off because of this. If you do get interviewed I would seriously be able to defend it vigorously.

Most importantly, half of the participants in double blind studies are getting a placebo. We are truly benefitting from these people's illnesses getting worse or an increased death rate. Do you not believe in this? This is how some people (including many of the PhD's who have the time to interview) make a living.

If people didn't get sick, we would be out of jobs.

Shouldn't doctors be compensated for the time and effort they have put into their degree? While no one should be in it for the money, you don't want to insult the person reading your application or the one interviewing you.
 
Hi

Thank you all for reading my PS and giving good comments. For, Lady, I tried to show through my paper that I have established skills within my self to handle coursework and my family, which I will later use if I get accepted into medical school. In addition, I have my husband, husband's mother, my mother and extended family and friends to help out. I will also try to make my sentences less wordy to shorten the essay. Thanks a lot.
 
Top