Career-related Question

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Aree

Full Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2016
Messages
40
Reaction score
66
This is going to be a long one so I apologize to, as well as thank, those that take the time to read it and provide constructive feedback.

I am starting medical school at a top 5 institution. However, at the same time, I am still in the process of figuring out “what I want to do when I grow up.” Now before y’all lash out at me and tell me I’m going into this for the wrong reasons, please allow me to explain myself.

I’ve been a fan of the sciences and enjoyed my coursework in most science courses (except maybe Ochem lol). Additionally, neither money nor prestige has ever been a top priority for me. Obviously, I’d be lying if I said they don’t matter to me because who doesn’t like a solid income and societal respect in their professional life. However, having a real impact on people’s lives is something of tremendous value to me. Growing up with physician parents and throughout my experiences as a premed, I’ve always been inspired by the level of impact physicians have on their individual patients. However, I have recently come to the realization that I’m also interested in expanding that impact beyond the individual level. I know that research is the traditional way of accomplishing that but I have so far been exposed to wet lab research and have found that I’m not much interested in it. But I am interested in technology and feel that the intersection of technology and medicine, such as applications of AI in medicine, is something I would like to explore further. I considered a career in computer science at some point but felt that it would be too removed for me from the people I would like to have an impact on/ the level of impact wouldn’t be as much as saving someone’s life. That’s no offense to CS folks as many of my dear friends are CS majors. That’s just how I thought about it and I could very well be wrong lol.

Now that I’ve explained myself to the best of my ability here, here’s my question to you: should I be feeling guilty for thinking this way? Am I on the wrong track for wanting to accomplish all of that? I definitely see myself seeing patients in a traditional clinical setting in my career but I also want to be involved in the world of startups/tech where I can maximize my impact as I previously mentioned. A way that I have considered approaching this is to also get an MBA from my institution, which also happens to have a top 5 MBA program.

It might be worth mentioning that i generally lack a lot of self-confidence and tend to question myself and my decisions quite frequently. The issues I’ve brought up here have bothered me for a long time and very extensively too, so I thought to reach out to members of this community, especially the senior members with a lot of experience, for some guidance in terms of what I should be doing/how I should be thinking as I make progress in my career. If you’ve read this far thank you so very much for your time and I look forward to hearing your opinion.
 
Your ambitions are strong, and doable, but a top 5 institution for your MD will not give you the research or technical qualifications to be at the forefront of AI in medicine, even in a translational capacity because you can’t “speak the language” of the AI developers. So you’ll need some additional training in my view.
 
Your ambitions are strong, and doable, but a top 5 institution for your MD will not give you the research or technical qualifications to be at the forefront of AI in medicine, even in a translational capacity because you can’t “speak the language” of the AI developers. So you’ll need some additional training in my view.

Thank you very much for your comment. That’s exactly the kind of response I need.

So one unique aspect about my program is that it allows for what would be similar to a “minor” in undergrad in general ‘big data’-related work in medicine. This ‘minor’ constitutes of certain classes designed for this type of work, many of which are CS courses, in addition to a research project under a faculty member that works in that area. And these are faculty members with MDs/MDPHDs who to me seem to be leading huge labs and big projects in the specific intersection of AI and medicine (would that be considered the forefront?) Additionally, they offer a Bootcamp for AI in healthcare which allows for further research after the completion of some clinical rotations. What do you think about that in terms of “additional training”? Did you have a specific type of program in mind that would be viable for me in order to gain those necessary technical skills? Of course there’s the option of masters/PhD in data science/bioinformatics which my school also offers. But I’m not sure if that’s what you meant when you mentioned additional training. Thanks again for your helpful feedback.
 
Last edited:
Disclaimer: I skimmed most of the text.

I agree with the other commentor. I graduated with a CS degree and then went to medical school. The simple fact of the matter is that you will need to learn how to program + you need to learn the basics of computing systems (i.e operating systems, data mining, etc) before you can be a player in AI.

I think at the minimum you need the following courses to have meaningful discourse with an AI programmer: Intro programming + data structures + operating systems + algorithms + data mining + databases. Only after all that knowledge could you start learning AI and be able to contribute to the field.

Now with that being said, it all depends on your role. if you want to be the kind of guy who just advises the programmer, you dont need much more than that. However if you want to really be someone who can contribute to a meaningful extent, you are going to need formal training.

Check out these guys for reference:


 
Disclaimer: I skimmed most of the text.

I agree with the other commentor. I graduated with a CS degree and then went to medical school. The simple fact of the matter is that you will need to learn how to program + you need to learn the basics of computing systems (i.e operating systems, data mining, etc) before you can be a player in AI.

I think at the minimum you need the following courses to have meaningful discourse with an AI programmer: Intro programming + data structures + operating systems + algorithms + data mining + databases. Only after all that knowledge could you start learning AI and be able to contribute to the field.

Now with that being said, it all depends on your role. if you want to be the kind of guy who just advises the programmer, you dont need much more than that. However if you want to really be someone who can contribute to a meaningful extent, you are going to need formal training.

Check out these guys for reference:



Thank you for your comments. What do you think would be a viable option for me to gain those skills?
 
Thank you for your comments. What do you think would be a viable option for me to gain those skills?

If you really are at a top 5 institution, there are probably guys on faculty there that are geniuses in the exact sub-field you are asking about. You should talk to them.
 
If you really are at a top 5 institution, there are probably guys on faculty there that are geniuses in the exact sub-field you are asking about. You should talk to them.

There are! I'm not sure if you got a chance to read my other response but there are many MDs/MDPHDs doing research on that kind of stuff which to me seems pretty cutting edge. And I doubt all of them have engineering backgrounds though they are all now CS faculty members as well due to their work. I was just wondering if you had any specific suggestions in mind since you mentioned formal training.
 
There are! I'm not sure if you got a chance to read my other response but there are many MDs/MDPHDs doing research on that kind of stuff which to me seems pretty cutting edge. And I doubt all of them have engineering backgrounds though they are all now CS faculty members as well due to their work. I was just wondering if you had any specific suggestions in mind since you mentioned formal training.

They may have picked up their knowledge along the way. My main point was that you need to know enough to speak the language.
 
Top