MD Chance me for MD or MD/PhD

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

PsychicPsych

New Member
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Hello, non-trad applicant here. I'm a third time applicant who applied to DO(3+ more potentially), MD (30) and MD/PhD (9) schools this cycle. I originally wanted to do MD/PhD, but I got sick of how competitive admission process was so I only applied to top schools for MD/PhD. The reasoning being that I am not going to put additional 3-4 years in education for something less financially viable unless the MD/PhD I get into gives me an overwhelming advantage over whatever MD school I get into. This may sound a bit arrogant, but I decided to do a blind coin toss with my life and decided that I would be happy to abandon research for the entirety of my career for an MD or DO program if I could get out of my current situation. At this point, I have a very complex relationship with research, where doing full-time research has been one of the happiest moments of my life and it still brings me great joy, but it's the very thing that got me into this miserable situation in the first place. For MD schools, there are few top programs and are mostly low to mid tier medical schools (which I will very much happy to matriculate into).

As for my background, I'm somewhat non-trad in that I became premed at the last year of my undergraduate. I did 3 year undergrad and 1 year masters, both in biology at T-20 university. My gpa for each are 3.45 for undergrad and 3.98 for master's. My MCAT is 516. I'm CA resident, ORM, came from immigrant low SES background.

For research, I have 1 first-author primary research in psychiatry and 1 first-author review paper in psychiatry. Both of these are preclinical work and they were submitted at nature portfolio journals (IF 7.5 & 9.1), I also have 2 third-author preclinical primary research paper at IF 4.5 and 9.0 journals. I also have a first-author clinical research paper coming up in IF 2 journal that integrates two important aspect of my clinical experience (EMS + Psychiatry). This work may be used to support an upcoming practice statement by one of the national physician organization.

My clinical experience comprise of 400 hour autism therapy, 400 hours inpatient psychiatry, 400 hours IFT EMT, 300 hours ER volunteer, and I have just started a paid IFT/911 EMT position that accrued 100 hours so far.

For community service, I did 300 hours doing health education on mental health at homeless shelter, 400 hour and counting mentoring troubled adolescent boys at middle and high school + juvenile halls on mental health and life. I will also start a volunteer EMT in a mobile clinic providing treatment for unhoused populations.

Unfortunately, years of disappointment and disenfranchisement has made me into a bitter and pessimistic person. I recognize this in me, and I am actively fighting against this part of myself because this is not a type of person I want to become. At the same time, I'm considering alternative pathways like lawyer, MBA, nursing, PA, and etc. Please let me know how I might do this cycle.
 
Last edited:
Previously

I have already requested you submit a WAMC template summary. What happened with the other 2 application attempts, and what are the significant improvements?

Why are you NOW deciding that the +PhD is less important than clinical education? I don't understand why you didn't try PhD only, especially as a 3x MD/DO applicant. It's also not clear if you did apply DO previously. Where did you send applications? What type of Master's program did you pursue?
 
Previously

I have already requested you submit a WAMC template summary. What happened with the other 2 application attempts, and what are the significant improvements?

Why are you NOW deciding that the +PhD is less important than clinical education? I don't understand why you didn't try PhD only, especially as a 3x MD/DO applicant. It's also not clear if you did apply DO previously. Where did you send applications? What type of Master's program did you pursue?
Hello, thank you for your thoughtful response.
My previous 2 applications ended with 1 interviews each, but no acceptance. For the first cycle, I applied to all MD-PhD, and I attribute it to negligible amount of clinical experience + poor writing. For the second cycle, I had improved but not enough clinical experience, and my two first author papers weren't published (thus not counted by adcoms) just after my last rejection came.

Also, I am not NOW deciding that PhD is less important than clinical education. I did not mention it in this post, but I am planning to apply to PhD only programs. I made this post to gauge when I should start submitting PhD applications. At this point, I'm leaving everything to chance. If I get into a PhD, I'll go to PhD. If I get into MD/PhD, I'll go to MD/PhD, and so on. I'm just very doubtful whether there will even be some amount of success for MD-only or MD-PhD cycle.

Ideally, I would like both MD and PhD because I want to study the disease I treat. As PhD, I could learn about what a disease is from research papers and mouse models, but I will never really understand what it's like to live with it without direct patient experience. As MD-only, I could better see what my patients need, but would have limited ability to make a meaningful change.

I have not applied to any DO schools until this cycle.

I pursued research master's in general biology at my alma mater.