Changes to Step 3?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

FazaUSF

New Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Jul 31, 2004
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
I read on the FSMB website that there will be changes to the Step 3 exam starting in mid-February, and the changes will delay score reporting. The practice materials have two separate versions; one for exams prior to mid-Feb, one for exams after mid-March, and a combo of both if taken in between. I'll be taking the exam in May, but cannot seem to find any information on exactly WHAT is changing. I'm not worried about score delays, but am concerned about whether I will be correctly prepared for the new exam (will study tools such as books, USMLEWorld, etc still be relevant, or now incomplete?). Does anyone know what the changes are, or where that information can be obtained? Thank you!
 
I believe the changes will be a full day of MCQ (compared to 1.5 days) and a full day of CCS (up from one half day).

When I took it (end of jan) it was a day of MCQ, and then a few more blocks of MCQ the next day with I think 7 or 9 CCS at the end.
 
I read on the FSMB website that there will be changes to the Step 3 exam starting in mid-February, and the changes will delay score reporting. The practice materials have two separate versions; one for exams prior to mid-Feb, one for exams after mid-March, and a combo of both if taken in between. I'll be taking the exam in May, but cannot seem to find any information on exactly WHAT is changing. I'm not worried about score delays, but am concerned about whether I will be correctly prepared for the new exam (will study tools such as books, USMLEWorld, etc still be relevant, or now incomplete?). Does anyone know what the changes are, or where that information can be obtained? Thank you!

http://www.usmle.org/announcements/default.aspx?ContentId=85

Basically drug ads and abstracts included in the MCQ, and as a result the total # of q's in that block will be reduced. USMLE World has already started building these changes into their question bank.

CCS will increase from 9 --> 12 cases. Full details can be found on that website.
 
The first day is 7 x 60min blocks x 48 questions. Some will have 1-2 fewer questions to give more time for the "drug ad" item sets.

The second day still has 4 x45 min blocks of 36 questions. Then an additional 9-12 cases.

http://www.usmle.org/pdfs/step-3/2012content_step3.pdf page 2 & 3

I take the test at the end of the month. Does anyone know if this change is a gradual implementation or if all testing centers will have this format of the test? Has anyone had this new format yet?
 
The first day is 7 x 60min blocks x 48 questions. Some will have 1-2 fewer questions to give more time for the "drug ad" item sets.

The second day still has 4 x45 min blocks of 36 questions. Then an additional 9-12 cases.

http://www.usmle.org/pdfs/step-3/2012content_step3.pdf page 2 & 3

I take the test at the end of the month. Does anyone know if this change is a gradual implementation or if all testing centers will have this format of the test? Has anyone had this new format yet?
I took step three this past Friday and Saturday (yesterday and the day before). The change was in full effect on my test. It was quite shocking as I had no idea it was going to happen.

The first day was 7 blocks of sections ranging from 46 to 48 questions each (one hour per section) and there were two drug ads. The second day was four more MCQ sections, each with 36 questions (I think) and you had 45 minutes each section. There was one abstract question (actually 3 questions) on the test.

The big...no, HUGE change was in the CCS section. There were 12 cases. For 10 of the twelve you were given 22 minutes and for the remaining two you had 11 minutes per case. This included the wrap-up time at the end of the case, so the amount of time you had to actually manage each case was shorter. The cases were pretty straight forward, but it didn't seem as if the amount of time needed per case changed based on whether it was a "short" (11 minute) case or "long" one. In other words, the 11 minutes cases didn't seem "simpler."

Although I feel I didn't do anything horrible, as in I got to the root diagnosis and treatment of the cases, I routinely ran out of time and wasn't able to schedule follow-up, or tidy-up things in the end and in order to get all of the miscellaneous teaching/counseling in, there were probably 3-4 where I wasn't able to put in a final diagnosis (not that it matters). I did all the USMLEWorld CSS simulations, and although you wouldn't think it, there was a HUGE difference in the pacing you need to take now. It's now very much a rapid-fire approach in order to get all the diagnostic tests that may possibly be needed for the case in as soon as possible so that you'll actually see the results. If you take a more practical approach, of ruling in/out diseases based on pre-test probability and then testing, you'll run out of time. There were probably two cases where the time ran out before all the test results were back.

In summary, the MCQ section really wasn't all that different. A couple of drug ads and one abstract...no big deal. I personally felt that the CCS had a completely different feel, however. In preparing (using the 25 minute format) there was much more time to think things through and proceed accordingly. Now, it feels as if it is a matter of pouncing on a diagnosis and throwing every test or treatment in as soon as you can. I'll be the first to admit that it might have played out a little differently if I wasn't so surprised, but even being as efficient as possible, there were quite a few cases where getting everything done in the time allotted was difficult. But seriously, doing a history, physical, diagnostic testing, floor orders, treatment, monitoring treatment, ruling out other co-morbid conditions, with education and follow-up in as little as 9 minutes (for the 11 minutes cases) is tough!
 
Last edited:
Thanks!

I take it UWorld didn't have the 10 minute cases when you went through them? I have a few 10-minute practice ones on mine. Definitely had to go through a few more than once to squeeze in everything on time.

I guess we don't get our scores until June, though, because of this new change.
 
what are the "drug ads" and abstracts that you guys mention? are there pictures of "singulair" or "nexium" on the corner of the computer screen somewhere??
 
what are the "drug ads" and abstracts that you guys mention? are there pictures of "singulair" or "nexium" on the corner of the computer screen somewhere??

They're generic-looking drug ads for fake drugs. The fake drug says that it does something then it's up to you to look at the information provided and decide what's real or not. They could ask you why the results are important (or not), what do the results tell you, and are they reported in an appropriate way. For the most part it's a lot less doing any sort of math to get to an answer but using the statistics and study method provided to answer questions about it.

And to the previous poster, no I did not have the 10 minute CCS cases from USMLEWorld. I must have finished the old cases before they started throwing them in (several weeks ago). Oh well, at least people know now (I hope) and hopefully the reason for the longer scoring period is so they can figure out how exactly this is going to need to be scored in a fair manner as compared to the old format.
 
I ended up having the new format of the test. The drug ads and abstracts were much easier in the real thing than on UW. The CCS cases were much harder in the real thing and a little more realistic than with UW. Quite a few of my cases were not as bread/butter as I thought they would be. I think those might have been "experimental" (I hope). UW did just a so-so job of prepping me for them to the point where I'm glad I actually studied. Maybe bring more than a #2 pencil. But that was just my experience. Overall, I think the exam is still very passable with light studying. Then again, I won't get my score until JUNE.
 
I ended up having the new format of the test. The drug ads and abstracts were much easier in the real thing than on UW. The CCS cases were much harder in the real thing and a little more realistic than with UW. Quite a few of my cases were not as bread/butter as I thought they would be. I think those might have been "experimental" (I hope). UW did just a so-so job of prepping me for them to the point where I'm glad I actually studied. Maybe bring more than a #2 pencil. But that was just my experience. Overall, I think the exam is still very passable with light studying. Then again, I won't get my score until JUNE.

Not only UW does so-so job preparing you but doing cases on that poorly designed software that ignores simulated time and monitoring principles can be dangerous. If it under-prepares you it is acceptable but it prepares you in way to cause you to lose score on exam if you followed what you learned from UW software. Everyone knows monitoring, 2 min screen management, importance of simulated time , sequencing of orders are so very very important to get good score on Step 3 CCS - UW neglects all these and gives dangerous simulated approach errors by reporting test results after passing the target simulated time, by not following evidence based treatment strategies on CCS, by not scheduling emergency surgeries and ignoring monitoring parameters of therapy and sequencing of orders
 
Top