- Joined
- Oct 19, 2013
- Messages
- 46
- Reaction score
- 2
The military dental commanders and all subordinates treat civilian DOD dentists horrible
I have worked at fort gordan and fort polk... Fort gordan is terrible because everything is referred out to specialties. Amalgam mill is all thats left and exams. I have 2 year gpr and 25 yesrs practice under my belt. I thought this avenue would be a nice way to give back since my retirement and to support our soldiers . I was terribly wrong!!!!! You young docs just graduating bewareThe military dental commanders and all subordinates treat civilian DOD dentists horrible
I have heard the same. It seems like the military is still pretty much all amalgam and while it's proponents advocate for its laid-back style, pension, etc., it doesn't sound like it prepares people for private practice well.I
I have worked at fort gordan and fort polk... Fort gordan is terrible because everything is referred out to specialties. Amalgam mill is all thats left and exams. I have 2 year gpr and 25 yesrs practice under my belt. I thought this avenue would be a nice way to give back since my retirement and to support our soldiers . I was terribly wrong!!!!! You young docs just graduating beware
Appreciate your comment!! Please spread the word. It's a shame how they are treating all civilians.I have heard the same. It seems like the military is still pretty much all amalgam and while it's proponents advocate for its laid-back style, pension, etc., it doesn't sound like it prepares people for private practice well.
I was gs employee army dental... Horrible experience!!!! They are cruel and demeaning in any and every aspect you can imagine. Stay away!!!!!!@Tooth: Thanks for your reply
The military hires civilian dentists as contractors, or sometimes as government service (GS) employees in addition to your regular active duty, uniform wearing dentists. They work along beside us but never deploy. This is because, during times of war, a lot of our active duty dentists get shipped off to Afghanistan or on a ship or whatever but there's still plenty of work that needs to be done while they're away. As you're aware, the war has been coming to an end. The majority of our active duty dentists are now back stateside and many commands across the country are realizing they now have too many dentists. Many commands are now having to let contractors go and not replacing GS dentists if they quit. I'm betting fort polk la was a contractor and just got a pink slip and wants to vent. He/she certainly isn't the only dentist who got a pink slip this month. That's just how it's panning out this time around.
I had a teacher in dental school who was a dentist in the Army back in the 70's. They decided they had too many active duty dentists and offered him an early retirement. He only did 18 years but got a 20 year retirement. So this time around, the contractors are on the chopping block. Sometimes it's active duty that's on the chopping block.
Soon enough, we'll be in a new war and the government will decide they desperately need more dentists immediately and will offer giant bonuses or whatever to lure more dentists in. And they'll come.
. I an not sure what your circumstances are concerning experience, length of time out of school or residency status. I would highly reccomend looking at VA jobs. Very good salary, benefits and RESPECT!!!!!Hi,
I'm a little bit confused.
Who are civilian dentists?Are you guys referring to dentists that are in the reserves or national guard?
I'm in the process of applying to the Air National Guard.
This post is kinda scaring me away! http://forums.studentdoctor.net/threads/working-for-the-armed-forces-as-a-civilian-dentist.565592/
Thanks!
The military hires civilian dentists as contractors, or sometimes as government service (GS) employees in addition to your regular active duty, uniform wearing dentists. They work along beside us but never deploy. This is because, during times of war, a lot of our active duty dentists get shipped off to Afghanistan or on a ship or whatever but there's still plenty of work that needs to be done while they're away. As you're aware, the war has been coming to an end. The majority of our active duty dentists are now back stateside and many commands across the country are realizing they now have too many dentists. Many commands are now having to let contractors go and not replacing GS dentists if they quit. I'm betting fort polk la was a contractor and just got a pink slip and wants to vent. He/she certainly isn't the only dentist who got a pink slip this month. That's just how it's panning out this time around.
I had a teacher in dental school who was a dentist in the Army back in the 70's. They decided they had too many active duty dentists and offered him an early retirement. He only did 18 years but got a 20 year retirement. So this time around, the contractors are on the chopping block. Sometimes it's active duty that's on the chopping block.
Soon enough, we'll be in a new war and the government will decide they desperately need more dentists immediately and will offer giant bonuses or whatever to lure more dentists in. And they'll come.
No pink slips or anything of that nature. Just treated very bad by the military as most other civilians are. Actually, I believe there is a shortage of dentists ( civilian and military for the Army ) I could be wrong? However, Obama has frozen the salaries for government employees and military for several years and that should change soon.
Most army posts are begging for civilian dentists. I would suggest looking at usajobs.gov There are usually numerous posts every week on the site from military bases looking for civilian dentists.
Most army dental officers are young recent graduates looking to get their school loans paid off. Therefore, They are unable to produce a lot of dentistry due to lack of experience, speed etc... Most civilians army dentists pick up the slack. I hired on to perform full scope dentistry. Not to send all my crown and bridge, surgery, etc... to recent grad army officers. ( I guess this is to help them become better trained and efficient). Most civilian army docs end up providing most of the amalgam restorations and exams. Not very appealing !!!! Basically, you end up forgetting or losing any skills concerning specialty work you have learned prior if youremain long enough in this type of working environment. Definitely dealing with the medical problems of elderly people and their meds. This just does not exist in the army because anyone who has major medical problems is booted out. So... the list goes on !!!! It's probably a good choice to enlist straight out of dental school and get your school loans paid off . especially if you have no money or can find no decent job..
Hey fort polk la,. I an not sure what your circumstances are concerning experience, length of time out of school or residency status. I would highly reccomend looking at VA jobs. Very good salary, benefits and RESPECT!!!!!
Do yourself a favor and stay away from army dental, reserves etc... I hope this message will guide you away from the misery that I endured. Good Luck!!!!
No pink slips or anything of that nature. Just treated very bad by the military as most other civilians are. Actually, I believe there is a shortage of dentists ( civilian and military for the Army ) I could be wrong? However, Obama has frozen the salaries for government employees and military for several years and that should change soon.
Most army posts are begging for civilian dentists. I would suggest looking at usajobs.gov There are usually numerous posts every week on the site from military bases looking for civilian dentists.
Most army dental officers are young recent graduates looking to get their school loans paid off. Therefore, They are unable to produce a lot of dentistry due to lack of experience, speed etc... Most civilians army dentists pick up the slack. I hired on to perform full scope dentistry. Not to send all my crown and bridge, surgery, etc... to recent grad army officers. ( I guess this is to help them become better trained and efficient). Most civilian army docs end up providing most of the amalgam restorations and exams. Not very appealing !!!! Basically, you end up forgetting or losing any skills concerning specialty work you have learned prior if youremain long enough in this type of working environment. Definitely dealing with the medical problems of elderly people and their meds. This just does not exist in the army because anyone who has major medical problems is booted out. So... the list goes on !!!! It's probably
Hey fort polk la,
thank you for giving us insight on the situation for military civilian dentists. I always thought it would be cool to give back to my country as well when I retire, but no way would I want to placed in some amalgam mill after a career of full mouth reconstruct cases. Good point on the VA, def would volunteer my time to a VA rather than active duty. I have friends who did the Army scholarhsip route and they're really worried how they're gonna survive once they get out because all they did was exams, amal fillings, and sedative irms. I agree the military doesn't really prepare you. seems like they reward normal comprehensive dentistry to folks who decide to make a career out of it. kinda of lame.
As for your poor treatment, you just gotta understand, the CO's in these places are your typical government employees in dead end jobs. Kinda of like postal workers. Naturally they're gonna be disgruntled. They never got to try more advance techniques in a private practice setting. Just wanna do the least amount, sit on their ass, and collect a paycheck. The concept of "healthy competition" is foreign to them. Don't take it personally, just brush it off and know that atleast you did what they never got to do - practice in the real world.
For the active duty, sometimes they get lucky and can practice comprehensive dentistry or work with the specialists in the departments they want to improve in. Sometimes, there's too much work to do and your stuck doing exams and operative all day because that's what THE MISSION requires.
I have never been told, "No, you can't do that" by a Senior Officer. Most, not all, have been more than willing to allow me to observe, assist, and treat patients beyond my credentials. I spent one day a week for almost a year doing nothing but oral surgery. I've placed implants, restored implants, have done multiple indirect restorations (Lithium Disilicate, Zirconia, PFMS, FGCs, CAD/CAM), and have been able to work in the endodontics department to treat patients I may have otherwise been uncomfortable treating.
However, now that the operational tempo has increased, I'm doing more referrals. Instead of doing indirect restorations, I'm doing more Amalgam WFTs when the situation is appropriate. Instead of treatment planning esthetic cases, I'm deferring most of those treatments.
As an active duty dentist, you have to be highly motivated to do treatments beyond basic restorative and you have to have a command that supports it. If there is time and you make the effort, you can do almost anything. Unfortunately, there isn't a lot of time when you're in an operational billet and if your in a clinic, usually you're very busy turning Class IIIs into Class IIs to make them operationally ready (again, the Mission).
EDITED FOR SPELLING/GRAMMAR[/quote
Your experience in my opinion is very uncommon. I am glad to learn someone has had a good experience. The majority of dentists I know who have worked with the military have had very negative experiences. A good example actually happened last week to my coworker. His assistant of several years was promoted to gs 5. because of this , she was moved to a military doc . The production will fall, an efficient team split up and the relearning process of each docs work methods start again. This makes no sense!!!! This is common place and in my opinion is counterproductive in many aspects. It further serves to cause conflict within an organization. Mission? Dont see that in these common types of mistreatments toward civilians!
The bases that I have been at, for the most part, treated the active duty and civilian contractors and GS well. Maybe your experience is isolated to the Army or that geographical location, I don't know.
With regards to you complaining about not being able to do ENDO, SURGERY, PROS, or whatever, that probably wasn't why you were hired. You were most likely hired TO DO operative and exams. The mission is to make the Marine, Sailor, Soldier, or Airman operationally ready, not necessarily to do ideal/comprehnsive dentistry. If that means you don't get to do a bridge, but that patient is now Class I or II, then you don't get to do the bridge. Instead, you'll be able to see more Class III operatives or patients that are due for their annual exam.
You are right that it does get stagnant and frustrating doing the same thing over and over again. For some people, that's a good thing. If you like having more personal autonomy and the ability to perform a multitude procedures, then a DOD Contract or a GS position probably isn't going to be fulfilling to you. Some commands will rotate you through different departments or even place you in a specialty department if you are competent enough, but for the most part you will be doing exams, sick call, or operative.
Amalgam is still widely used in the military. It has a tremendous track record, it's less tehcnique senistive, and for high caries risk patients, it's a better restorative material than a composite. A well-done amalgam build-up will service the patient well until he/she returns from deployment or they learn which end of the tooth brush to use. Again, make our Warfighters operationally ready.
The bases that I have been at, for the most part, treated the active duty and civilian contractors and GS well. Maybe your experience is isolated to the Army or that geographical location, I don't know.
With regards to you complaining about not being able to do ENDO, SURGERY, PROS, or whatever, that probably wasn't why you were hired. You were most likely hired TO DO operative and exams. The mission is to make the Marine, Sailor, Soldier, or Airman operationally ready, not necessarily to do ideal/comprehnsive dentistry. If that means you don't get to do a bridge, but that patient is now Class I or II, then you don't get to do the bridge. Instead, you'll be able to see more Class III operatives or patients that are due for their annual exam.
You are right that it does get stagnant and frustrating doing the same thing over and over again. For some people, that's a good thing. If you like having more personal autonomy and the ability to perform a multitude procedures, then a DOD Contract or a GS position probably isn't going to be fulfilling to you. Some commands will rotate you through different departments or even place you in a specialty department if you are competent enough, but for the most part you will be doing exams, sick call, or operative.
Amalgam is still widely used in the military. It has a tremendous track record, it's less tehcnique senistive, and for high caries risk patients, it's a better restorative material than a composite. A well-done amalgam build-up will service the patient well until he/she returns from deployment or they learn which end of the tooth brush to use. Again, make our Warfighters operationally ready.
Your experience in my opinion is very uncommon. I am glad to learn someone has had a good experience. The majority of dentists I know who have worked with the military have had very negative experiences. A good example actually happened last week to my coworker. His assistant of several years was promoted to gs 5. because of this , she was moved to a military doc . The production will fall, an efficient team split up and the relearning process of each docs work methods start again. This makes no sense!!!! This is common place and in my opinion is counterproductive in many aspects. It further serves to cause conflict within an organization. Mission? Dont see that in these common types of mistreatments toward civilians!
. I an not sure what your circumstances are concerning experience, length of time out of school or residency status. I would highly reccomend looking at VA jobs. Very good salary, benefits and RESPECT!!!!!
Do yourself a favor and stay away from army dental, reserves etc... I hope this message will guide you away from the misery that I endured. Good Luck!!!!
Hi guys,
Regarding the Air National Guard, if I do sign with them, I already know that all I will be doing is exams to make sure that the soldiers are readily deployable. I was told that I would be doing so once a month and would also have to be at the base 2 weeks out of the year. I was not planning on doing any endo, crowns, or any kind of treatments whatsoever. One of my friends at an AF base in Florida only does exams when she goes there one weekend a month.
I was definitely going to sign with them, but would DEFINITELY have an issue with people disrespecting me! I would either say something back or become frustrated/depressed for not being able to do so.
One more site for loan repaymentSounds like it may be a good move on your part. I would encourage you ! That is if you do not mind 30-40 exams per day. This will not happen everyday , but expect it. Financially it is a smart move concerning school loans. There are other ways! Health care shortage areas in the U.S . Usually will pay school loans off and pay you a salary. You will have to pay taxes on this school loan payoff, but they give you extra money to help offset this. I will look for further info. Best wishes!
I understand ! I cant imagine having that debt hanging over my head! These loan payoff websites are federal goverment sites. Perhaps this will help you and also promote building and developing your skills rather than wasting them doing exams 24/7. either way good luck!!!!!Thank you so much for your replies.
I have about 140K of loans left. I graduated with 220K in 2011.
I will check out the links provided.
I do not mind doing 30-40 exams per day if it's just screening exams and one weekend per month.
The military hires civilian dentists as contractors, or sometimes as government service (GS) employees in addition to your regular active duty, uniform wearing dentists. They work along beside us but never deploy. This is because, during times of war, a lot of our active duty dentists get shipped off to Afghanistan or on a ship or whatever but there's still plenty of work that needs to be done while they're away. As you're aware, the war has been coming to an end. The majority of our active duty dentists are now back stateside and many commands across the country are realizing they now have too many dentists. Many commands are now having to let contractors go and not replacing GS dentists if they quit. I'm betting fort polk la was a contractor and just got a pink slip and wants to vent. He/she certainly isn't the only dentist who got a pink slip this month. That's just how it's panning out this time around.
I had a teacher in dental school who was a dentist in the Army back in the 70's. They decided they had too many active duty dentists and offered him an early retirement. He only did 18 years but got a 20 year retirement. So this time around, the contractors are on the chopping block. Sometimes it's active duty that's on the chopping block.
Soon enough, we'll be in a new war and the government will decide they desperately need more dentists immediately and will offer giant bonuses or whatever to lure more dentists in. And they'll come.
I understand ! I cant imagine having that debt hanging over my head! These loan payoff websites are federal goverment sites. Perhaps this will help you and also promote building and developing your skills rather than wasting them doing exams 24/7. either way good luck!!!!!
I understand ! I cant imagine having that debt hanging over my head! These loan payoff websites are federal goverment sites. Perhaps this will help you and also promote building and developing your skills rather than wasting them doing exams 24/7. either way good luck!!!!!
ANG?? Sorry to learn the news!Hello there!
I got an email from ANG this morning...Dentistry is taken of the list for career fields that can receive student loan repayment...
Thanks again for all your feedback.
I understand what you mean. I endured a lot of community health centers in order to have loan repayment over the years and it's not easy. I don't understand how a dental assistant or dental hygienist can be a Director of clinic and they're telling dentists and physicians what to do. There are so many people who need dental care and after my experiences, I now see why dentists told me years ago that they could never stay in Community Dentistry after their loans were paid. I don't know what it will take to fix a lot of issues with clinics, but this is a common complaint amongst dental providers. It's one thing to have your loans paid back, but a whole other ball game when you're "traumatized" trying to get it done. You definitely "pay" for your debt. Keep searching. There are a number of Loan Repayment programs out there with opportunities.Thanks again for your replies. Much appreciated. I did the loan repayment program through a health center and came out a little bit traumatized and wanted to try another kind of loan repayment program. I am thinking it was just the health center that was going through changes though... It's hard sometimes when your supervisor is not a dentist or a physician.
I understand what you mean. I endured a lot of community health centers in order to have loan repayment over the years and it's not easy. I don't understand how a dental assistant or dental hygienist can be a Director of clinic and they're telling dentists and physicians what to do. There are so many people who need dental care and after my experiences, I now see why dentists told me years ago that they could never stay in Community Dentistry after their loans were paid. I don't know what it will take to fix a lot of issues with clinics, but this is a common complaint amongst dental providers. It's one thing to have your loans paid back, but a whole other ball game when you're "traumatized" trying to get it done. You definitely "pay" for your debt. Keep searching. There are a number of Loan Repayment programs out there with opportunities.