CK-MB VS TroponinI

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

BrooklynDO

Senior Member
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
20+ Year Member
Joined
Jun 5, 2001
Messages
305
Reaction score
0
This bothers me so I thought Id ask:
Troponin one is the earliest and most specific marker for an MI,
yet CK-MB is the marker of choice for the first 24 hrs
both stay very high during the first day with CKmb having a peak a bit after 24 hrs.
so why is skmb the Test of Choice and not TrppI?

Members don't see this ad.
 
Actually, in a real life clincial setting. both tests are ordered for MI rule out. There is no preference for one or the other.

The use of Troponin I was adopted tin 1997
 
OneStrongBro said:
Actually, in a real life clincial setting. both tests are ordered for MI rule out. There is no preference for one or the other.

The use of Troponin I was adopted tin 1997

while I realize this, STEP 1 is not real life... unfortunately id order the right test in the hospital and still not know a step one answer---
anyone?
 
Another reason CK-MB is preferred is because it returns to normal by day 2 to 3. It can then be used to diagnose reinfarction, whereas Troponin hangs around for 7-10 days and can't be used for this purpose.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
AnnaMags said:
Another reason CK-MB is preferred is because it returns to normal by day 2 to 3. It can then be used to diagnose reinfarction, whereas Troponin hangs around for 7-10 days and can't be used for this purpose.

This is correct. If you see a question on the step about what assay to order on a patient who appears to have just had a heart attack, pick the CK-MB. And of course, make sure you understand why because a lot of questions like this expect you to understand the concept behind it, not just "what do you use".
 
Maybe someone could explain this... I was doing a Kaplan qbank question and they essentially said the following

Hour 0-8 --> troponin
Hour 8-24 --> CK-MB
Hour 24-1w --> troponin

I understand that CK-MB only sticks around for 2-3 days while troponin is around for up to 10 days, but why would you use troponin during hours 0-8 rather than CK-MB?
 
babinski bob said:
Maybe someone could explain this... I was doing a Kaplan qbank question and they essentially said the following

Hour 0-8 --> troponin
Hour 8-24 --> CK-MB
Hour 24-1w --> troponin

I understand that CK-MB only sticks around for 2-3 days while troponin is around for up to 10 days, but why would you use troponin during hours 0-8 rather than CK-MB?

if you look somewhere with a graph or a specific timeline, you will see that troponin risis almost immediately while ckmb takes a bit of time (a few hours after) so thats why within the first few hours its trop and within the day in general its ckmb
 
BrooklynDO said:
if you look somewhere with a graph or a specific timeline, you will see that troponin risis almost immediately while ckmb takes a bit of time (a few hours after) so thats why within the first few hours its trop and within the day in general its ckmb


thanks for alleviating the confusion man... much appreciated.. 🙂
 
When admitting a patient to rule out myocardial infarction, just about every ER and hospital in this nation draws a CPK, CK-MB, and troponin-I level every 6-8 hrs (some draw myoglobin levels too). There is no such thing as a "best" enzyme to use, because in the clinical setting, all three enzymes are used, and all are very useful in making clinical decisions about patients. A patient with chest pain and an elevated CPK only may be heparinized and admitted to a higher level of care then a patient with a normal CPK on presentation because of the higher likelihood that he or she is having an acute MI despite the fact that CPK is very non-specific for MI's. They used to use CK-MB levels to formally diagnose MI's for clinical trial purposes, but they have been using troponin-I's more often as the gold standard these days because although CK-MB is very sensitive and fairly specific, skeletal muscles also have a small amount of CK-MB so you can see a small rise in that level (enough to reach the MI "criteria") when you have something like rhabdomyolysis. That's one reason why they also look at the proportion of CK-MB and CPK to one another. Troponin-I levels are the most specific for diagnosing an MI, and very sensitive by 24 hrs; but because they take a while to rise, we still draw CK-MB's and CPK's on all of our patients too. Anyways, for USMLE purposes, I would definitely know the timeline of when the enzymes are released, and I would also know that troponin-I is the most specific test for diagnosing an MI.
 
Top