my issue with ACB is how do you assess a successful block? the anatomy of the saphenous nerve is variable, i like asking the patient to lift their leg after the fem block and ensure motor block prior to fileting the knee open. The pessimist in me thinks the ACB has become popular for two reasons, one is early ambulation (which is stupid, does 24h really make a difference?, if it was me id take the femoral with the ensured success of analgesia as confirmed by motor block, xaralto, and chill the rest of the day rather than walking for what an hour or less?) and secondly because there actually is no way to assess a successful block and people who suck at blocks can get away with high frequency of failed blocks because no way to tell. they all get narcotic anyway in addition to blocks and how much is variable.
And yes I do also do pop-scis for posterior pain with the same mindset, let them rest for the day, give them anticoagulation for DVT, , no big deal. I have done hundreds of knees this way. General with these blocks with LMA or ETT after. is there any actual data that shows ambulating DOS for a few mins is superior to POD1 in terms of long term outcomes? not that im aware of.
I feel the same way about epidurals. Will they be able to ambulate early? No. Give them AC and let them chill for a DOS and POD1. That big belly case patient is not going to be running around the halls anyhow. I pull it on POD 2 AM or sooner if issues. Again is there data about early ambulation after abd surg on DOS vs POD1 effecting long term outcomes?
Id do the guy above in the knee case the same way he had the left TKA done, or if any issues, with a fem and popsci block and ett.