Columbia vs. Northwestern

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Cheese_man

New Member
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Columbia vs. Northwestern

Financial aid is equal
I would feel more supported at Northwestern
Columbia is higher ranked
I want to eventually end up on the Northeast
 
You shouldn't have problems matching in the northeast from either school, but Columbia will have an edge due to its location and the connections you can make there. When you say you'd feel more supported at Northwestern, is that because your support system is nearby or because something about the school itself seems more supported?
 
You shouldn't have problems matching in the northeast from either school, but Columbia will have an edge due to its location and the connections you can make there. When you say you'd feel more supported at Northwestern, is that because your support system is nearby or because something about the school itself seems more supported?
Support system is in Chicago - thanks for the help
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Based only on this, I think any prestige difference between Columbia and Northwestern is negligible/irrelevant to getting you to match competitively in the northeast (or anywhere you want), so I say Northwestern is the way to go.
 
I'm going to slightly disagree with riv. Chicago is the second largest city in the country and the center of lots of efforts on social medicine/justice. I don't know what connections you are looking at, but I don't think anyone will not recognize Northwestern as a solid program. I also can't believe any desirable Northwestern or UChicago residency candidate (if we're trying to compare with Columbia and other Ivies) would have problems getting into residencies along the I-95 corridor.

Your affinity to the campus politics surrounding Columbia University vs. Northwestern University...that's a price of prestige and up to you how much you want to be around it tangentially.