I probably came across as overly critical in that post, and I blame it on global warming. Sorrry if my tone was a little off.
I definitely wasn't trying to accuse anyone in particular of anything (sorry if you felt that way gogiants, my post wasn't directed at you personally) and I'm not trying to say the thread is completely without merit. It's true that there is some valuable info to be gained by this discussion (i.e. the Penn State stuff that doesn't seem quite right etc.). I just kinda feel like there's a difference between trying to stratify feedback in order to translate it into potential ranking tiers and just patting yourself on the back for the sake of it. But since this is the only place where people really understand what's going on, I do understand that it can feel good to celebrate positive feedback with people that appreciate what it means.
We're all super stressed about this whole thing I know, especially now that almost everything is out of our hands and our fates are being determined by committe behind closed doors. No fun at all. At least during the interview season we had control over how we did, now there's nothing but thumb twiddling until March 15th. For this control freak, this is gonna be almost unbearabe. I wanna know, and I wanna know NOW.
Sorry if I offended anyone. We're all in this cruddy situation together, and I wish everyone the best of luck on match day.