- Joined
- Jul 3, 2009
- Messages
- 305
- Reaction score
- 90
Last edited:
Someone a few years back did their due diligence and looked at the AMA and ADA salary surveys from 2003 and calculated the hourly wages. You'll find Derm nestled snugly below 6 dental specialties and slightly above general dentistry:
Salary/Hours
1. Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeon 336/36 = $179.5/hr
2. Endodontist 303.9/36 = $162.4/hr
3. Pedodontiac Dentist 294.4/36 = $157.1/hr
4. Orthodontist 279.4/36 = $149.0/hr
5. Orthopedic Surgeon 335.8/54.1 = $119.4/hr
6. Periodontist 216.4/36 = $115.4/hr
7. Pathologist 246.5/41.6 = $114.0/hr
8. Rad (Diag)/Rad Onc 327.7/58.5 = $107.7/hr
9. Prosthodontist 190.9/36 = $102.0/hr
10. Opthalomologist 229.2/43.7 = $100.9/hr
11. Dermatologist 219.5/42 = $100.5/hr
12. EM 220/45 = $94.0/hr
13. General Dentist 173.1/36 = $92.4/hr
14. Neurosurgery / Plastic Surgery 275.2/59.6 = $88.8/hr
15. Urologist 264.5/57.4 = $88.6/hr
16. Surgeon (gen) 263.7/58.2 = $87.1/hr
17. Anesthesiologist 244.7/58.7 = $80.2/hr
18. ENT 214.5/52.1 = $79.2/hr
19. OB/GYN 227/55.7 = $78.4/hr
20. Neurologist 183.1/53.7 = $65.6/hr
21. Psychiatrist 145.7/44 = $63.7/hr
22. IM 164.1/55.6 = $56.8/hr
23. FP 146.5/50.7 = $55.6/hr
24. Pediatrician 137.8/49.4 = $53.6/hr
http://www.ada.org/ada/prod/survey/publications_newreports.asp#income
Survey of Dental Practice. c. 2003 Edition, American Dental Association
http://medicine.wustl.edu/~residenc...pec/byspec.html
Physician Socioeconomic Statistics. c. 2003 Edition, American Medical Association
These numbers must have been computed by a dental student, because they show relative incompetence in math. The units don't add up! Dividing those two numbers doesn't give you dollars per hour.
Someone a few years back did their due diligence and looked at the AMA and ADA salary surveys from 2003 and calculated the hourly wages. You'll find Derm nestled snugly below 6 dental specialties and slightly above general dentistry:
Salary/Hours
1. Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeon 336/36 = $179.5/hr
2. Endodontist 303.9/36 = $162.4/hr
3. Pedodontiac Dentist 294.4/36 = $157.1/hr
4. Orthodontist 279.4/36 = $149.0/hr
5. Orthopedic Surgeon 335.8/54.1 = $119.4/hr
6. Periodontist 216.4/36 = $115.4/hr
7. Pathologist 246.5/41.6 = $114.0/hr
8. Rad (Diag)/Rad Onc 327.7/58.5 = $107.7/hr
9. Prosthodontist 190.9/36 = $102.0/hr
10. Opthalomologist 229.2/43.7 = $100.9/hr
11. Dermatologist 219.5/42 = $100.5/hr
12. EM 220/45 = $94.0/hr
13. General Dentist 173.1/36 = $92.4/hr
14. Neurosurgery / Plastic Surgery 275.2/59.6 = $88.8/hr
15. Urologist 264.5/57.4 = $88.6/hr
16. Surgeon (gen) 263.7/58.2 = $87.1/hr
17. Anesthesiologist 244.7/58.7 = $80.2/hr
18. ENT 214.5/52.1 = $79.2/hr
19. OB/GYN 227/55.7 = $78.4/hr
20. Neurologist 183.1/53.7 = $65.6/hr
21. Psychiatrist 145.7/44 = $63.7/hr
22. IM 164.1/55.6 = $56.8/hr
23. FP 146.5/50.7 = $55.6/hr
24. Pediatrician 137.8/49.4 = $53.6/hr
http://www.ada.org/ada/prod/survey/publications_newreports.asp#income
Survey of Dental Practice. c. 2003 Edition, American Dental Association
http://medicine.wustl.edu/~residenc...pec/byspec.html
Physician Socioeconomic Statistics. c. 2003 Edition, American Medical Association
I think you forgot to multiply the number of hours by the number of weeks in a year.
Take oral surgery for example:
36 hours/week * 52 weeks/year = 1,872 hours worked/year
336,000 annual salary/ 1,872 annual hours = 179.5 dollars/hour
lol Owned!
I don't believe those surveys. There are a lot of other medical/dental-income surveys around, and they all use different sources of info. Many of them ( Bureau of Labor and SalaryWizard ) show physician salaries to be much higher.
And really, how the hell does the average neurosurgeon make less than a GP dentist, or any other dental specialty, on an hourly basis?
I don't believe those surveys. There are a lot of other medical/dental-income surveys around, and they all use different sources of info. Many of them ( Bureau of Labor and SalaryWizard ) show physician salaries to be much higher.
And really, how the hell does the average neurosurgeon make less than a GP dentist, or any other dental specialty, on an hourly basis?
How do the dental specialities (oral surgery, endodontistry and orthodontistry) compare to dermatology in terms of money and lifestyle?
Dear Mr. "Not so Green" Lantern,
Thanks for illustrating exactly the kind of misinformed logic that leads to these repeated questions about the most standard topics.
There's so many flaws in your response, GR doesn't quite know where to begin!
All kidding aside...
1. Bureau of Labor Statistics: Where do they get their info from? Salaried employees and tax returns. How many dentists are salaried employees? Most dentists fall into the category of independent practitioner or partner within a group, neither of whom draw a "salary" in the same sense as a hospital employee, which many physicians are. Most "salaried" dentists are academic employees or work for the state in some other capacity (i.e. not private practitioners). Finally, given that most dentists are small-business owners, their tax returns do not reflect actual income in many instances, as there are obvious tax benefits to stating that, as a business owner, your salary/income is less.
2. Salarywizard - How can you say that the ADA stats are inaccurate because they are a survey and then state that Salarwizard is accurate? It too is a web-based survey. It seems that you have the preconceived notion that physicians on the whole make more the dentists and will provide whatever data, flimsy as it is, to support your specious reasoning.
3. As our Wonderwoman points out above, neurosurgeons and orthopedists likely make more per year even though they make the same per hour as endodontists because THEY WORK MORE HOURS PER WEEK.
Please provide some data to support your claims, along with a critique of the quality of such data and its limitations. Surely as either a medical or dental student (which GR suspects you must be, given your know-it-all attitude with no basis for such confidence), you must have learned, at some point, how to evaluate and assess the quality of data.
GR will even get you started by adding a critique of the ADA data:
1. Represents only private practitioners so there is a selection bias, as they make much more than academics. Though, it can be inferred that the averages are not likely off by as much, as academics represent only about 10% of the dental workforce.
2. It is a survey so it may over-estimate or under-estimate incomes based on individualized patterns of reporting income. It would be foolish to suggest, as you do, that dentists as a whole inflate their income when reporting surveys, where as physicians do not. As a corollary, it would also be foolish to suggest that both groups deflate their income when reporting it. There is simply no way of knowing. The ADA surveys, flawed as they are, are just the best that we have.
Having said all this, GR will certainly grant you the following points:
Neurosurgeons, Cardiac Surgeons, Spine Surgeons all make more than dentists, as they should. The opportunity cost for specializing in these areas and the enormous burden placed on these individuals who are saving lives everyday justifies their income.
Finally, a brief purview of your trusted Salarywizard gives the following income data:
Dermatologist: $253, 178
Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeon: $269,115
Otolaryngologist: $291,265
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgeon: $317,846
Orthopedic Surgeon: $403,084
Cardiac Surgeon: $436,735
Neurosurgeon: $453,689
*Note: No comparison for hours worked and no data provided.
GR thinks that it can be agreed that OMFS, who work about 40 hours a week on average, are most like dermatologists, according to the flawless data on Salary Wizard. Not bad company to keep. Everyone else on that list almost certainly works more than 50 hours/week.
You'll note that the income for cardiac surgeons is listed as $436,735. Do you happen to know any cardiac surgery fellows or junior attendings? If so, tell them how envious you are of their income. They'll think you're a regular Jerry Seinfeld.
Copied from the website: "This basic market pricing report was prepared using our Certified Compensation Professionals' analysis of survey data collected from thousands of HR departments at employers of all sizes, industries and geographies."
GR has one question for you: how many dentists in private practice do you know who have HR departments or work for companies who do?
Though, to make sure you have a happy Friday, GR will concede the following point:
Dentists do not make as much money as most medical specialists. They also work fewer hours, have more time off, fewer stresses related to life and death issues and are generally happy people. Medical specialists who have lifestyles comparable to dental specialists make roughly (within 20k) the same amount of money, but have more liability (mucking up a molar endo vs. missing a diagnosis of melanoma - both bad days for the practitioner, though one much more likely than the other to have a lawyer at the other end). Having gone to both dental school and medical school, GR can tell you that GR only once heard from a pros faculty that dentistry "wasn't worth it". In medical school, GR heard that medicine "wasn't worth it" at least once a day. You do the math.
Gary "Hobo like Lobo" Ruska
Day-am...Now that, kids, is called getting "pwned"...
Kudos to GR for keeping the riff-raff under control...
I think you forgot to multiply the number of hours by the number of weeks in a year.dentstd said:These numbers must have been computed by a dental student, because they show relative incompetence in math. The units don't add up! Dividing those two numbers doesn't give you dollars per hour.
Take oral surgery for example:
36 hours/week * 52 weeks/year = 1,872 hours worked/year
336,000 annual salary/ 1,872 annual hours = 179.5 dollars/hour
Having gone to both dental school and medical school, GR can tell you that GR only once heard from a pros faculty that dentistry "wasn't worth it". In medical school, GR heard that medicine "wasn't worth it" at least once a day. You do the math.
Gary "Hobo like Lobo" Ruska
Having gone to both dental school and medical school, GR can tell you that GR only once heard from a pros faculty that dentistry "wasn't worth it". In medical school, GR heard that medicine "wasn't worth it" at least once a day. You do the math.
In addition, I'm not sure how hard it is to pursue subspecialty training after dental school, but it's worth noting that the lifestyle friendly fields in medicine (especially dermatology) are incredibly difficult to enter. Something to keep in mind if you're deciding between dental school/medical school.
The major difference, of course, being that dentistry *itself* is a lifestyle specialty. 😉The same can be said with dental specialties such as orthodontics and endodontics too. DP
In addition, I'm not sure how hard it is to pursue subspecialty training after dental school, but it's worth noting that the lifestyle friendly fields in medicine (especially dermatology) are incredibly difficult to enter. Something to keep in mind if you're deciding between dental school/medical school.
Some new figures on physician salaries:
http://www.cejkasearch.com/compensation/amga_physician_compensation_survey.htm
It claims Orthopedic Surgeons can make about 600k. They still probably work horrible hours but i believe the hourly rate would nonetheless be higher than OMFS.
Some new figures on physician salaries:
http://www.cejkasearch.com/compensation/amga_physician_compensation_survey.htm
It claims Orthopedic Surgeons can make about 600k. They still probably work horrible hours but i believe the hourly rate would nonetheless be higher than OMFS.
3. From the ADA surveys, the average OMFS works about 40 hours/week.
For anyone who is actually working as a dentist ( and not in dental school, residency ), I can assure you that those salary surveys are out of this world.
I want out of this profession. I still have student loans but I'm thinking of tacking on more debt for opening a Burger King franchise.
But ADA only collects voluntary information among ADA members, just like the way medical, podiatric, etc. associations gather salary info for their own professions.
Like someone mentioned, arguing about average salaries based on surveys is completely worthless. There are probably thousands of salary surveys out there and they all give VERY different salary infos.
And the other issue is personal experience. I'm currently a general dentist. Whether you believe me or not, I'm on track to earn a total of $70,000 for the entire 2009 year. My employers don't offer a cushy clinic environment with dedicated labs and decent patients. My positions are 60hrs/wk total. And there's no 401k, health insurance, paid sick days, etc. I'm being worked to death at clinic and yet I can't meet my employer's quota. As bad as my jobs are, I'm in danger of losing them in a few months. For anyone who is actually working as a dentist ( and not in dental school, residency ), I can assure you that those salary surveys are out of this world.
So why are we arguing as to whether dentists make more than physicians or vice versa? What's the point?
move
move
But ADA only collects voluntary information among ADA members, just like the way medical, podiatric, etc. associations gather salary info for their own professions.
Like someone mentioned, arguing about average salaries based on surveys is completely worthless. There are probably thousands of salary surveys out there and they all give VERY different salary infos.
And the other issue is personal experience. I'm currently a general dentist. Whether you believe me or not, I'm on track to earn a total of $70,000 for the entire 2009 year. My employers don't offer a cushy clinic environment with dedicated labs and decent patients. My positions are 60hrs/wk total. And there's no 401k, health insurance, paid sick days, etc. I'm being worked to death at clinic and yet I can't meet my employer's quota. As bad as my jobs are, I'm in danger of losing them in a few months. For anyone who is actually working as a dentist ( and not in dental school, residency ), I can assure you that those salary surveys are out of this world.
So why are we arguing as to whether dentists make more than physicians or vice versa? What's the point?
i came across this when looking for a certain derm thread. this thread is a joke. salary surveys mean nothing unless you find out where they are getting their info from, what types of docs participate, hours worked of each doc giving salary numbers, whether the doc is in private practice or not, etc etc. you honestly think that any doc who makes good money is going to give their true salary, when the public already thinks that docs get reimbursed way too much? hell no dude. My uncle is a derm, he works 60 hours a week, does general dermatology, works is ass off when he is at work though, but makes close to a million a year. very few general dentists would even come close to the compensation of a smart, hard working dermatologist in private practice. If the two fields were even remotely comparable in potential income, everyone would know, and dental schools would be hard as hell to get into. End of story.
Lead with how we shouldn't trust even the most meticulously constructed salary surveys, finish with a "my uncle" story.
Makes perfect sense...
Well, I am sorry you have trouble understanding something so simple. I am telling you that you can't make conclusions about who makes more per hour based on these salary surveys. There are just way too many variables that go into them. I gave a "my uncle" story not as "fact" or to say that "because my uncle makes this much, this means I am correct", but to give an example (of which I can give many) on how its far more accurate to get salary info straight from people you know. Don't listen to me or people on these boards w/ regard to how much they or people they know make. Get it out of real, live people you know. Then make your conclusions.
If you still can't understand, thats fine. People like you make the world easier for me to succeed in.
i came across this when looking for a certain derm thread. this thread is a joke. salary surveys mean nothing unless you find out where they are getting their info from, what types of docs participate, hours worked of each doc giving salary numbers, whether the doc is in private practice or not, etc etc. you honestly think that any doc who makes good money is going to give their true salary, when the public already thinks that docs get reimbursed way too much? hell no dude. My uncle is a derm, he works 60 hours a week, does general dermatology, works is ass off when he is at work though, but makes close to a million a year. very few general dentists would even come close to the compensation of a smart, hard working dermatologist in private practice. If the two fields were even remotely comparable in potential income, everyone would know, and dental schools would be hard as hell to get into. End of story.
Well, I am sorry you have trouble understanding something so simple. I am telling you that you can't make conclusions about who makes more per hour based on these salary surveys. There are just way too many variables that go into them. I gave a "my uncle" story not as "fact" or to say that "because my uncle makes this much, this means I am correct", but to give an example (of which I can give many) on how its far more accurate to get salary info straight from people you know. Don't listen to me or people on these boards w/ regard to how much they or people they know make. Get it out of real, live people you know. Then make your conclusions.
If you still can't understand, thats fine. People like you make the world easier for me to succeed in.
Mr. Pannusretractor.
Well, I am sorry you have trouble understanding something so simple. I am telling you that you can't make conclusions about who makes more per hour based on these salary surveys. There are just way too many variables that go into them. I gave a "my uncle" story not as "fact" or to say that "because my uncle makes this much, this means I am correct", but to give an example (of which I can give many) on how its far more accurate to get salary info straight from people you know. Don't listen to me or people on these boards w/ regard to how much they or people they know make. Get it out of real, live people you know. Then make your conclusions.
If you still can't understand, thats fine. People like you make the world easier for me to succeed in.
How is he gunning in that nature?did he buy those practices, or start them from scratch? 1.5 mil gross/practice in 5 yrs sounds pretty awesome. I got a classmate gunning for something like that. All I can say, party at his place![]()
How is he gunning in that nature?
Are you heading to academia then?
medicine is a vast ocean and dentistry is just its drop why r u trying to defeat medicinedental specialties
vs dermatology
it should be dental specialties < dermatology
![]()
And for a second I thought he was from Canada.this is one of the stupidest things i have ever read. Great use of meanies though.