Dentist vs. CRNA

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

JPevzner

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Apr 6, 2009
Messages
169
Reaction score
0
I was looking through the med forums and stumbled upon this career called Certified Registered Nurse Anesthetist (CRNA). Apparently, the starting salary is about $140,000 with potential to reach $500,000. Supposedly, a $300,000 salary is not uncommon for this field. The education is similar in length to a dentist's(BS, 1 yr job experience, 2-3 yrs additional schooling). The career is expected to be in high demand in the near future. I'm all for dentistry and was really set on it before i read some info about these nurses. Don't flame me because "I'm just conserned about the money, bla..bla". Im just curious wheteher you guys have heard about his career and its insanse compensation potential. Some additional benefits include: not having to own a practice (although i think they might be able to), managable hours, less debt, etc. Please dont preach about the ethics and how these careers are completely different. If you decide to comment, please base it on factors such as: compensation, autonomy, lifestyle, workweek, etc. Thanks for reading.
-Jon
 
Jon, I don't honestly believe the top pay of a CRNA is anything near 500k. For an MD, yes. Through the grapevine, I've heard of salaries starting from 120k and topping off around 200k, with the 200k being very rare. I'm aware you probably don't want to hear this and not attacking the OP, but do something that would really make you happy for the next 30 or so years, and not so much the length of education or salary. I had originally thought CRNA would be a good career, but the thought of putting people to sleep (I know there is more to it, such as pain management) just didn't do it for me. I'm very social, and I like to interact with people, that's one big reason I chose dentistry (plus I can do all the talking, while they can only listen-hard to talk when your mouth is gaped wide open). But it's good you're searching out all the possible fields. I admire that. Good luck with your career decisions.
 
I was looking through the med forums and stumbled upon this career called Certified Registered Nurse Anesthetist (CRNA). Apparently, the starting salary is about $140,000 with potential to reach $500,000. Supposedly, a $300,000 salary is not uncommon for this field.
Listen, I value SDN, a lot, but some of the information you come across just simply is not correct. This is a medical forum, dominated by physicians and pre-med students….and while they may not admit to it, or like it, they simply do not know the truth regarding nursing, what it takes to be a nurse, nursing pay, advance practice nursing, etc. (they just think they know because they read it somewhere on this forum once or heard someone say something along similar lines once, or because they looked it up once and think they know everything know, they are MDs or wanna be MDs and think they are Gods gift to the world (cough, cough, Taurus, cough, cough). 300K as a CNRA is unheard of. It is not a common salary for this field and I would be hard pressed to believe you could find someone, or more than one person, working in this field, making 300K. It just doesn’t happen. 140K is more along the lines of reality, and for someone that has a few years experience. Starting salary is closer to 100K and I would say max is generally around 160K. Of course you will have your exceptions, those who work in government and in certain prestigious private sectors will probably make a little more…but still not anywhere close to 300K.
The education is similar in length to a dentist's(BS, 1 yr job experience, 2-3 yrs additional schooling). The career is expected to be in high demand in the near future. I'm all for dentistry and was really set on it before i read some info about these nurses. Don't flame me because "I'm just concerned about the money, bla..bla". Im just curious whether you guys have heard about his career and its insane compensation potential.
Depends. Education can be 50K a year for at least two years, and in most cases, 3 years. I should note that to be considered for CRNA school, you must hold a bachelors in Nursing. Minimum requirements are at least a 3.0 GPA (but you wont be competitive unless it’s significantly higher) and also a GRE score > 1000 (again, you will have to do much better than the minimum to be competitive). You have to have LORs, specifically from the CRNAs that you shadowed as well as the personal statements and in some schools, you have to interview (not true for all schools). And in general, most schools require a mandatory minimum of one year critical care experience. Most require CCRN certification which requires a continuous amount of patient care contact in a specific field for a specific duration and the sitting (and passing) of a board exam. Furthermore, by the year 2015, all advance practice nurses (which included CRNA’s) will be required to have their DNP (Doctor of Nursing Practice) which will be at least another year of schooling (and a thousand or so more clinical hours to add to your already 2K hour pile – DO NOT BELIEVE THAT THE 700HR ONLINE BS THAT SOME SDN POSTERS WOULD LIKE YOU TO BELIEVE EXSITS. IT. SIMPLY. DOES. NOT. END. OF. STORY.). So unless you are planning on applying, and soon, you will not only have to get your Masters in Anesthesiology, you will also have to obtain your DNP in order to practice as a CRNA. I should also mention how incredibly competitive this field is. Heck, regular nursing school is now really competitive. I was waitlisted at my state school over 4 years ago with a 3.2 cGPA! And in some states, the wait list is first come first serve, rather than GPA dependent…Such is the case in Colorado where the waitlist on average is 5 years!! And this is just for a regular BSN or even an associates degree. Add to the fact that just about every nurse and new nurse graduate wants to be a CRNA. You’ll have to dig deep to make an admissions committee believe you want to be a CRNA for the right reasons and not just because it was a lucrative alternative to your dental plan. 😉
Some additional benefits include: not having to own a practice (although i think they might be able to)
CRNAs cannot practice on their own, let alone own their own practice. They might be able to own a group of CRNA’s, but they would ultimately have to contract out and practice under a licensed Anesthesiologist (either MD or DO). CRNAs are obligated to practice under the supervision of a Anesthesiologist. Usually the state and/or facility you work in, will dictate the ratio or CRNAs to Drs. In my state, there can be 4 CRNAs for every 1 Anesthesiologist. Usually the CRNAs work independently, performing epi’s, air placement, etc., but that’s not to say that I don’t see them directly supervised by either the Anesthesiologist or the resident (usually a 2nd year or higher).
manageable hours, less debt, etc. Please don’t preach about the ethics and how these careers are completely different. If you decide to comment, please base it on factors such as: compensation, autonomy, lifestyle, workweek, etc. Thanks for reading.
Jon, the careers are totally different….sorry, but they are!! Autonomy is obviously limited for the reasons listed above. You are not completely autonomous in this field. And the other major drawback is that once you choose this field, you are stuck with it….as in, there isn’t much lateral movement across fields for CRNA’s (in comparison to other NP’s and PA’s). Oh, and CRNAs do call and rotating shifts the same as MDs/DOs so expect to be working long, late hours, especially while you are at the bottom of the totem pole.

Hopefully I answered a few of your questions. You should check out the ANA (American Nurses Association) website on CRNA’s. And as you mentioned, there might be some threads in this forum, somewhere, that have relative information from posters who have actually been through the process themselves. Whatever you do, don’t listen to Taurus…this is one SDN poster who hasn’t got a clue when it comes to the world of NPs and DNPs, but sure likes to voice their opinion otherwise (Trust me, Taurus don't know BULL and any NP will back this up, and I'd bet everything I have that more than a fair share of HONEST MDs/DOs would back me up on this statement as well. You'll be far better informed going to other *professional* websites and talking to already practicing CRNAs and MDs/DOs that work alongside CRNAs then reading one sentence of what Taurus has to say on this subject. In fact if Taurus enters this conversation, or any other conversations you may be involved with, your far better gouging your eyes out with a rusty sport than listening to ANYTHING this poster has to say in regards to anything nursing related...and probably most things in general). Keep in mind that the working relationship between NPs and MDs/DOs is a lot better than what many would portray around here. The majority, if not all, MDs/DOs I work with are extremely grateful of NPs/PA’s, understand their role and respect them highly. If you have other questions, feel free to PM me. CRNA is not a bad idea, but don’t be fooled by people around here that it’s an easy idea. 🙂



That was a lot. wow. 😳
 
WOW! thanks a lot for the helpful feedback guys! I really appreciate it.
 
dentistry all day, every day. lol. Thanks for the insight
 
Where I live, the cost of living is extremely cheap. With that said, there are several CRNA that make well above the $300k mark.
Huge difference between projected income and actual income. Several as in one or two in the country? Maybe. Several in each town, nope, sorry, doesn't happen, despite what your father would like you to believe. In fact, I challenge you to find one job listing, or one CRNA that makes "well above the 300K mark" or even close.
They do work like crazy and have hard hours but I've spoken to at least two and worked with one for a summer internship that absolutely love their job. A CRNA lives in the neighborhood my parents do and has a larger house than one of the new surgeons.
Size of house really has nothing to do with salary. You never know where the money came from....as in it could be a two income household, the money could have come from trusts/parents/inheritance, etc.
Would I ever do it? No thanks I didn't want anything to do with hospitals after the summer internship program. I spoke with my father about dentistry after shadowing some and he gave me the scoop on income from around town. Associate dentists don't make much on the dental totem pole, but they are way beyond the average American income. The key is to move to a place that isn't saturated with dentists. Many dentists here that own their own practice net 500-750k. Most work 4 days a week and have long vacations.
Keep dreaming, much nicer there than it is here, in reality.... 🙂

It all depends on where you work, how much you work, etc. Many CRNAs work in the hospital setting and have regular, rotating shifts, just like the MDs/DOs. I'm sure you can pick up OT, but generally these positions are SALARIED and therefore not eligible for OT anyway. You cant go to a hospital and say, "Hi, I want to make a lot of money, so I'm going to work XXX amount of hours each week on top of what my regular shifts are." This does NOT happen. You are hired at XXX amount of dollars a year and are required to take rotating shifts and call. Welcome to reality. If the pay was really 300K and the degree oh so easy to obtain with hours that are kosher delight, don't you think we would all know by now?? don't you think more people would pursuing this occupation and that it would be even more competitive than it already is? Come on, use your brain. 😛

You're best bet? Try and find out where you want to live after you graduate. Contact both CRNAs and dentists in that area. Make sure you inquire about starting salary, OT regulations, median salary, max salary, etc. Bottom line, CRNAs DO NOT make 300K a year, not on average, not a median, not anything, they just don't. Like one poster stated before, there may be one or two exceptions to this, but these are generally your CRNA's whom have worked as such for many (read 15/20+ years) and have expanded roles beyond what the traditional CRNA would occupy.
 
Last edited:
Wow really stirred up the hornets nest on this one! Cripes! Who knew you could offend so many people by bringing up the profession of a CRNA.
 
Wow really stirred up the hornets nest on this one! Cripes! Who knew you could offend so many people by bringing up the profession of a CRNA.
Was it really necessary for you to post this comment? I mean its in NO way insightful or helpful. And for the record, no one here is offended. Just trying to clear up the facts and set the record straight. Giving honest, insightful information from someone who has experience rather than second hand hearsay. Our conversation, as it exists, is sorta the intention of an internet forum....no? 🙄
Believe what you want.
I will. I will believe what someone in the actual profession tells me they make over what a CPA tells me a CRNA makes. 😉

Be misinformed if you want. 🙂
 
Yikes. Go back to pre-allo.
 
Last edited:
Yikes. Go back to pre-allo.
Really? You really would have second hand information that is INCORRECT just because its presented in a more aesthetic and pleasing (yet still false) manner? Wow. Go back to elementary school. Or try posting something of worthy content.
 
Really? You really would have second hand information that is INCORRECT just because its presented in a more aesthetic and pleasing (yet still false) manner? Wow. Go back to elementary school. Or try posting something of worthy content.

:laugh:

I'm not gonna waste any of my time on a pissing contest with you. Learn how to respect other people's opinions, then come back little one.
 
:laugh:

I'm not gonna waste any of my time on a pissing contest with you. Learn how to respect other people's opinions, then come back little one.
Not sure where I disrespected anyone's opinions, I simply said they are false, which they are. Someone is asking for advice on a certain profession, and I am giving it, while correcting other posters OPINIONS (as they are only opinions) which he/she represents as facts (which they are not).

Again, more worthy posting from people have little to no insight on the topic at hand. Call me shocked. Listen OP, you can listen to these pre-dental and dental students about the pro's and con's about being a CRNA or you can go straight to the source and find out yourself the truth and the reality of the profession and make your own lists of pro's/con's. In the meantime, I'll direct all my CRNA buddies to this forum as I'm sure they are all highly interested in theses existing 300K positions in which none of us have a CLUE about. 😎
 
Not sure where I disrespected anyone's opinions, I simply said they are false, which they are. Someone is asking for advice on a certain profession, and I am giving it, while correcting other posters OPINIONS (as they are only opinions) which he/she represents as facts (which they are not).

Again, more worthy posting from people have little to no insight on the topic at hand. Call me shocked. Listen OP, you can listen to these pre-dental and dental students about the pro's and con's about being a CRNA or you can go straight to the source and find out yourself the truth and the reality of the profession and make your own lists of pro's/con's. In the meantime, I'll direct all my CRNA buddies to this forum as I'm sure they are all highly interested in theses existing 300K positions in which none of us have a CLUE about. 😎

This is why I hate pre-meds. They think they are god's gift to the world and know everything. I am ALL for providing real and useful information. However, you do not know for a FACT whether what the other poster is saying is true or not. You posted your opinion and he posted his. Their are always outliers. So stop preaching, and being so arrogant - you sound like a tool.
 
I think Hoody needs to chill out, my comment wasn't meant to be insightful and every comment on a forum doesn't need to be insightful and it wasnt even directed at you or to get anyone upset, so chill out dude! Have a corona or something!
 
Hoody might be a little hotheaded but he's right. Its absurd to suggest CRNAs make 300k. Anesthesiologists make that much. Why would anyone pay a CRNA that much? Some dentist however make the same as CRNAs. Most make more. A few make WAY more. So do go and see what the life of the two careers is like and make YOUR decision from there.
 
This is why I hate pre-meds. They think they are god's gift to the world and know everything. I am ALL for providing real and useful information. However, you do not know for a FACT whether what the other poster is saying is true or not. You posted your opinion and he posted his. Their are always outliers. So stop preaching, and being so arrogant - you sound like a tool.
Someone in the nursing field with first hand CRNA experience has far more knowledge about being a CRNA than someone who is a pre dental student listening to their Dad who is a CPA. Not really difficult to grasp. Furthermore, my statements weren't opinions, they are facts, that are well supported beyond the SDN community (and thier fathers for that matter). Go do some research, then comment. You wouldn't tell a pre vet student whats up in the vet world if you didn't know, so don't be a pre dentist studnet telling CRNAs how it is in the CRNA world. Cowboy17 clearly presented his statements as facts; "There are several CRNAs who make well above the 300 mark." That does not sound like an opinion to me, it sounds like a fact, and the truth is, they DON'T so that fact (opinion, whatever it is) is false. How dare I try to stear the OP in the diretion of correct and useful information (in fact, I told him to cocntact both dentists and CRNAs mutiple times as well as going to the ANA CRNA webiste - full of more INCORRECT info and opinions, Im sure. What other insightful info do you have to add to help the OP with his questionsn? None? Didnt think so. Who's the tool now?? 🙂
I think Hoody needs to chill out, my comment wasn't meant to be insightful and every comment on a forum doesn't need to be insightful and it wasnt even directed at you or to get anyone upset, so chill out dude! Have a corona or something!
Who was it directed at and what was the point then? Dudes asking for some serious insight. Whats to joke about that? 😕



And for the record, this he is a SHE! Also, I'm a nurse, working for doctors, so I've been completely broken for some time now. No more ass-umptions, please! 😉
 
Hoody might be a little hotheaded but he's right. Its absurd to suggest CRNAs make 300k. Anesthesiologists make that much. Why would anyone pay a CRNA that much? Some dentist however make the same as CRNAs. Most make more. A few make WAY more. So do go and see what the life of the two careers is like and make YOUR decision from there.
For real....its just really annoying that there are people, who have no association with your profession, are telling other people interested in your profession that you make a certain amount and that its easier to do than other professional health care positions. Bottom line, CRNAs do not make more than dentists, unless dentists typically make less than 140K or so a year. Furthermore, getting into CRNA school isn't easier than getting into dental school or med school. You still have to meet a bunch of pre-req's, spend a huge amount of time on the application process, and quite a few years studying. All I am saying is that I don't think it would be any easier or that you would make anymore money being a CRNA than you would a dentist. Being a CRNA is great, don't get me wrong, but its not the gold pot at the end of the rainbow that a few in here want to make it seem. Trust me, I wish it was.. 😳
 
You still are, don't worry.

Take a chill pill.
I'll let you eat your own words when it comes to "respecting other posters." 🙂

And I'll chill when you pre dents stop acting like you know more than a nurse about being a CRNA. Deal? 😕
 
Yeah im pretty much done talking on this thread, its pointless. Im getting attacked by hoody after posting a comment on peoples reaction to the topic and you would swear I just said something absolutely blasphemous! So, Im done because we are literally bantering about nothing hoody!
 
Yeah im pretty much done talking on this thread, its pointless. Im getting attacked by hoody after posting a comment on peoples reaction to the topic and you would swear I just said something absolutely blasphemous! So, Im done because we are literally bantering about nothing hoody!
Peace out!! three posts too late... 👍
Hey, you started it, so don't even go there 🙂
Now, is that your opinion, or is that fact?? 😕


just kidding 😀
 
Hoody, "cowboy country" speaks for itself. We'll disregard anything you attempted to say.
 
Hoody,

Here is a pat on the back.
 
CRNAs cannot practice on their own, let alone own their own practice. They might be able to own a group of CRNA’s, but they would ultimately have to contract out and practice under a licensed Anesthesiologist (either MD or DO). CRNAs are obligated to practice under the supervision of a Anesthesiologist

I skimmed your post and I wanted to clarify one thing.

What is quoted above is NOT TRUE in many states. There might be some states that have this as law (I don't know all state laws) but many states CRNA's can be the only anesthesia provider and work independently. My dad is a CRNA so I have first hand knowledge of this. Working under MD supervision happens in most urban/suburban places is the norm and usually happens as Hoody described above. CRNA's do the grunge work Anesthesiologists supervise...analogous to the Dentist and Assoc. dentist. If you want autonomy as a CRNA you must go to the rural/semi rural areas. My dad has not practiced with an CRNA run group in a major suburban area since late 90s.

So if you work in the city under an MD then salary range 100-130k likely. Work in smaller towns with no MD 150-200. Really remote places you can pull upper 100k only working HALF time. Usually if you are willing to go anywhere you can roll 200-230. The higher the salary the less benefits from hospital/group though.
 
lol, if crnas made that much then why would you ever become an anesthesiologist?

great pay, normal hours and no liability. sounds like a dream job huh. lol they don't make 300k. maybe in pesos.
 
CRNAs in my state can work independent of an anesthesiologist. In fact, my OMFS employed a CRNA. I talked to him about DDS vs. CRNA. He said that "I wouldn't recommend the medical field thesedays." Both his children are in dental school now.

Also, some CRNAs will have to do nights. If you're the new guy, that might be you!
 
I'm wondering if an AA will make about the same as a CRNA?
 
Last edited:
AA = anesthesiologist assistant
 
I should note that to be considered for CRNA school, you must hold a bachelors in Nursing.

This is not entirely correct. About half of the CRNA programs out there require a BS in Nursing. The other half simply require an RN with a bachelor degree in a science field. Thousands of CRNA's work independently of MD/DO's and deliver anesthesia in rural areas. It is in these rural areas where CRNA's can pull in the most money. I recently saw four job listings on gaswork.com (in OK, OH, NM, CA) that started at 300K. Except for the ones in Ohio and Cali, these are very rural locations where most people would not desire to live. That is why they pay so much. One can find many listings between 200K and 250K for NEW GRADS with full benefits and retirement in desireable areas.These jobs are out there. Look in the website and see for yourself. I'm a nursing major (who is thinking now of med school), so I'm neither pro- or anti-crna. I just want to correct much of the misinformation that is present on this thread.
 
Last edited:
AA = anesthesiologist assistant

In metropolitan areas, where most AA's work since they have to be supervised, the pay is roughly the same as CRNA's. You won't find many AA's in rural areas because they, unlike CRNA's, have to be supervised. It is generally in the rural areas where CRNA's make more.
 
so to be a nurse require the same education as a dentist. I do not want to hate on nurse but i met some nurse students thinking that dental school is so much easier than nurse. I hate to become a nurse.
 
That just mean (s)he is ******ed and ignorance or maybe (s)he is pissed cause the scores aren't high enough to get in a DS!
 
That just mean (s)he is ******ed and ignorance or maybe (s)he is pissed cause the scores aren't high enough to get in a DS!

It wouldn't be a student doc website without someone taking a pot shot at nurses, would it? Just shows exactly who is ******ed and ignorant. For the record, you can't be an academic slouch to get into nursing, either. Most schools require at least a 3.0, with the mid to upper 3's to be competitive.

As for getting into a CRNA program, you definitely have to be on your stuff. You need a BSN (which is actually 5 and 1/2 years worth of school instead of the usual 4 for most Bachelor's programs. 1 and 1/2 years of pre-reqs, 2 years for the RN, and 2 years to complete the BSN). You then need to work in the ICU for at least 2-3 years to be competitive. And a lot of times, you can't simply go straight into ICU as an RN grad, you have to work your way up into it through med/surg, progressive care and then into ICU. So you're looking at around 7-8 years before you can really be a decent candidate to go into CRNA school. Then you're looking at 2-3 years to finish. And most schools are requiring GPA's in the upper 3's to even be considered.

I realize that nurses aren't doctors, and they shouldn't try to be. But I'm sick of snide docs, residents and wanna-be docs online making swipes at nurses. You may have a great treatment plan set up, but nurses have a huge part in the care of your patients. They make sure your plan is administered correctly, catch errors, evaluate response to medication and therapy, make suggestions and observations to modify care, care for the patient's overall needs in addition to their physiological ones, and ensure that all areas of the multidisciplinary team work in harmony. It takes more than an average monkey to do this efficiently, so give credit where credit is due.

To respond to the original posting, I don't know if CRNA's make $300k a month. Seems a little high to me. I agree, why would a hospital pay a CRNA the same amount as an MDA (Anesthesiologist)?

That said, some CRNA salaries come awfully close. Check out gaswork.com and search all CRNA jobs to see what I mean. There are jobs for experienced CRNA's in Texas, Oklahoma and Kansas starting around $200k.

Either way, dentistry and nurse anesthesia are both great gigs. There are a lot of variables, but the one of greatest influence would be where your passion lies. Is it in dentistry or anesthesia? They're completely different. Both require a lot of time dedication, hard work, academic competence and patience.

And if you're going the CRNA route, you'd better hope you enjoy non-CRNA nursing, because you're going to be doing it for awhile before you get in.
 
As for getting into a CRNA program, you definitely have to be on your stuff. You need a BSN (which is actually 5 and 1/2 years worth of school instead of the usual 4 for most Bachelor's programs. 1 and 1/2 years of pre-reqs, 2 years for the RN, and 2 years to complete the BSN).

Incorrect. In a BSN program, the entire length is 4 years. 2 years prereqs and 2 years of nursing courses. That mixture varies some but the norm is 4 years. You graduate with a BSN. You only get the RN when you sit for the exam.
 
Top