Do all neurology subspecialties in academia pay equally (adjusted for location, demand, experience level etc.)?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Aldertonghen

Full Member
2+ Year Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2021
Messages
216
Reaction score
88
I think neuromuscular, epilepsy, movement are fairly similar in terms of pay. I've heard the salaries are usually in the $210-240k for these subspecialties in a non-coastal, non-ivy league place.

What about stroke, neurocritical care, multiple sclerosis (if one does infusions), interventional neuroradiology? Is the compensation in these specialties similar, and if not, could anyone give a ballpark estimate for each of these (relative to the $220k figure I quoted above for the outpatient specialties)? Regarding NCC in particular, I've heard that the number of weeks one is on service decides the compensation. In this case, how many weeks of service (in NCC) would be required to constitute a 1.0 FTE salary equivalent?

Members don't see this ad.
 
This is really too vague and broad to get an answer. In general, your pay is tied to your collections or RVUs. If you are killing it in the infusion center and Botox as a headache doctor, you’re going to pull in more than an icu attending working 12 weeks a year.

If you’re asking, per unit time, what’s more billable, it’s mostly pain, intervention, icu and then everything else. I don’t imagine a huge difference with stroke/Epilepsy/neuromuscular. There’s a huge drop off for cognitive and the like.

So you can extrapolate from there. That said private practice eeg/emg/Botox mills are making much more than plenty of icu/ir folks in academia. There’s too many variables at play to answer more concretely than that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
This is really too vague and broad to get an answer. In general, your pay is tied to your collections or RVUs. If you are killing it in the infusion center and Botox as a headache doctor, you’re going to pull in more than an icu attending working 12 weeks a year.

If you’re asking, per unit time, what’s more billable, it’s mostly pain, intervention, icu and then everything else. I don’t imagine a huge difference with stroke/Epilepsy/neuromuscular. There’s a huge drop off for cognitive and the like.

So you can extrapolate from there. That said private practice eeg/emg/Botox mills are making much more than plenty of icu/ir folks in academia. There’s too many variables at play to answer more concretely than that.
I see. So even in an academic setting, salary is linked to RVUs and the specialties you mentioned above (icu, NIR, pain) have a higher potential income than the other fields, correct?
 
Members don't see this ad :)
I see. So even in an academic setting, salary is linked to RVUs and the specialties you mentioned above (icu, NIR, pain) have a higher potential income than the other fields, correct?
This varies a lot by department. Some departments tend to normalize RVU to the subspecialty, so good clinical care isn't disincentivized in favor of setting up a factory line of procedures. Others will pay a few (usually NCC and NIR) more but most will earn a fairly standard salary by academic rank. Still others are a more "eat what you kill" model, often via bonus structures that heavily incentivize going over an RVU threshold.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
This varies a lot by department. Some departments tend to normalize RVU to the subspecialty, so good clinical care isn't disincentivized in favor of setting up a factory line of procedures. Others will pay a few (usually NCC and NIR) more but most will earn a fairly standard salary by academic rank. Still others are a more "eat what you kill" model, often via bonus structures that heavily incentivize going over an RVU threshold.
I see. That clears it up. So if one is an NCC/NIR attending at the second kind of department you mentioned, then they would earn more than the other subspecialties for a full time job. However, in this case, is it theoretically possible to buy out some protected time for research, so that the net salary of the NCC/NIR attending is more or less like any other neurology specialty, but one has more time for research/education? Practically I think it’ll be tough because no one else would want the extra call burden, but maybe it’s not impossible.
 
NCC and NIR aren't really in the same realm. NIR is probably not even going to be in the neurology department at most institutions and more likely to be under neurosurgery or IR with really terrible call and great pay. Again your thinking here is pretty flawed because the metric that really matters is $ per hour. NCC does not do well on this as it is often 24hr call when one is on service with a lot of outside calls for transfers etc. There is no such thing as a free lunch, in any subspecialty. The outpatient docs doing headache for example can be done at 5 and home with family not taking any call for that $220k. Doing 24 weeks of service a year with 24hr call while on service for that academic NCC job for let's say 250k is not necessarily coming out ahead of the headache doc as you may actually be working or have your time occupied much more aggregate time. I would think it very unlikely you will get anything close to a full salary for 12 weeks of service a year as NCC without having a lot of added clinic time and admin responsibilities on 'off' weeks. Again, there is no such thing as a free lunch just to repeat it one more time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
NCC and NIR aren't really in the same realm. NIR is probably not even going to be in the neurology department at most institutions and more likely to be under neurosurgery or IR with really terrible call and great pay. Again your thinking here is pretty flawed because the metric that really matters is $ per hour. NCC does not do well on this as it is often 24hr call when one is on service with a lot of outside calls for transfers etc. There is no such thing as a free lunch, in any subspecialty. The outpatient docs doing headache for example can be done at 5 and home with family not taking any call for that $220k. Doing 24 weeks of service a year with 24hr call while on service for that academic NCC job for let's say 250k is not necessarily coming out ahead of the headache doc as you may actually be working or have your time occupied much more aggregate time. I would think it very unlikely you will get anything close to a full salary for 12 weeks of service a year as NCC without having a lot of added clinic time and admin responsibilities on 'off' weeks. Again, there is no such thing as a free lunch just to repeat it one more time.
I didn’t think of it that way. Yes $ per hour would be a better way to measure things. In terms of this metric, how would you rank the specialties? Especially because in something like NIR, you work 70-80 hours so the $ per hour might be the same or lower even (like it is with NCC as you mentioned).

I was curious because a higher $ per hour means you can theoretically work for less time and still make that $220k, and then potentially have more time left over for research.
 
I didn’t think of it that way. Yes $ per hour would be a better way to measure things. In terms of this metric, how would you rank the specialties? Especially because in something like NIR, you work 70-80 hours so the $ per hour might be the same or lower even (like it is with NCC as you mentioned).

I was curious because a higher $ per hour means you can theoretically work for less time and still make that $220k, and then potentially have more time left over for research.
there are other factors at play too in determining $/hr. What do you consider work?- you could be NCC or Neurohospitalist "On Call" for 12 hours but really work 5-6 hours and get paid for 12. And if you are in academics with residents, might not even have to work that much. Obviously depends on how busy the institute is and you have to be on "alert" for 12 hours. In outpatient you have to earn your salary- but there is definitely a higher ceiling there for total salary if you work hard.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
The sub-specialties that will do best $ per hour are those with RVU-dense procedures that can be done at volume. Think EEG, sleep studies, Botox for various things. EMG used to be fantastic for this but got cut hard.

For reference, I do a lot of both DBS and botox for dystonia and spasticity. In a full clinic half-day where I'm seeing news and returns, my wRVUs will be around 14-15 assuming I maximize my billing and everyone shows up. Afterwards I'll often need to catch up on notes for a couple of hours if I saw anything challenging. In the half days where I do Botox, I can often inject 12+ people in a half day, each of which varies from about 1.5 wRVUs for a hemifacial spasm, 3 wRVUs for a cervical dystonia to ~8+ wRVUs for a generalized dystonia. Those complex injections take time, but still fit pretty easy within a 20 minute Botox slot and on a full half-day I'll routinely have billed 20-25+ wRVUs and have zero work to take home with me. A DBS case in the OR will bill about 5 wRVUs per hour, and cases typically range from 2-4 hours for awake DBS with MER depending on disease and target. wRVU targets at centers I'm familiar with are typically in the 10-12 per half day range. From that, you can see how efficient outpatient procedures both generate more revenue per hour you're at work, but also tend to generate less overall work for you afterwards.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 users
The sub-specialties that will do best $ per hour are those with RVU-dense procedures that can be done at volume. Think EEG, sleep studies, Botox for various things. EMG used to be fantastic for this but got cut hard.

For reference, I do a lot of both DBS and botox for dystonia and spasticity. In a full clinic half-day where I'm seeing news and returns, my wRVUs will be around 14-15 assuming I maximize my billing and everyone shows up. Afterwards I'll often need to catch up on notes for a couple of hours if I saw anything challenging. In the half days where I do Botox, I can often inject 12+ people in a half day, each of which varies from about 1.5 wRVUs for a hemifacial spasm, 3 wRVUs for a cervical dystonia to ~8+ wRVUs for a generalized dystonia. Those complex injections take time, but still fit pretty easy within a 20 minute Botox slot and on a full half-day I'll routinely have billed 20-25+ wRVUs and have zero work to take home with me. A DBS case in the OR will bill about 5 wRVUs per hour, and cases typically range from 2-4 hours for awake DBS with MER depending on disease and target. wRVU targets at centers I'm familiar with are typically in the 10-12 per half day range. From that, you can see how efficient outpatient procedures both generate more revenue per hour you're at work, but also tend to generate less overall work for you afterwards.
Thank you, this is very insightful.
 
I see. So even in an academic setting, salary is linked to RVUs and the specialties you mentioned above (icu, NIR, pain) have a higher potential income than the other fields, correct?
I'm just graduating movement fellowship at a prestigious academic center so the job advertisement emails have been rolling in for 2 years.

There is SO MUCH variability to neurology salary it is mind boggling. There are basically no rules.

You can work every other week as a neurohospitalist in Alaska and make 500k. You can work every day 9-5 as a cognitive outpatient doc in a big california city at a prestigious academic center and make 160k.

As other people have said, there is so much more to consider than dollars per hour. What stage are you at? You shouldn't even be thinking about this until you're atleast a R2.

I'll try and break down the factors that go in to salary,
Practice type: private, employed, locums. Private, typically you get paid for what you do in RVUs. This is where procedure heavy specialties win out (reading EEG, injections, EMG). Employed- you work for a hospital/clinic, managed care organization, VA, something like that. You get a set salary for whatever %time you work. Often the salary is tied to an RVU goal, especially for outpatient providers. Hospitals aren't dumb and they set an RVU goal based on about what amount of work they think you should do for that time and for what you're doing. The RVU goal therefore requires a certain amount of work for your salary, but also provides bonus opportunity if you get very fast or efficient at what you do. Some places don't have an RVU goal (Kaiser, for example, other community operations) and they're basically paying you to just see people and for your availability. What that salary is that you are working towards is highly variable based on location (more remote == more money), academic or not (academic == less money), and private/public (this can be a mixed bag, with county hospitals in some area paying more than academic public universities, etc). Locums you're basically a free floating neurologist for hire, though often people will stay at one place for potentially longer times. Payment is typically shift or hourly, with some room for bonus/productivity. Per hour, locums probably actually pays the most, because these hospitals are so desperate for any kind of neurology coverage and they need it NOW. It seems like you're perhaps interested in research? Unfortunately, your plan to maximize dollars on a few days a week to "free up" time for research doesn't really work. If you're going to do research in any real way you need to be at an academic institution. You can't really just elect to work 2 days/week at a high paying specialty and like be freewheeling the rest of the time. Basically you sign up for a full time position, lets say it pays $210k, and then you come up with ways to pay that salary. Initially a department might offer 210k for 3 days of clinic and 2 days of research, but those 2 days of research will eventually have to be paid by grant money. It's not like you get paid 210 for 3 days of work and the rest is volunteering. So eventually you get a grant and pay for X% of 210k with that, and if the number is not 100% you and your department negotiate what work you need to do to fill the space.

Work setting: outpatient/inpatient. This primarily determines your work schedule, and less your reimbursement, as alot depends on the factors above. But it is vital to consider in terms of what you're willing to do for the money. Outpatient is typically 3-5 clinic days a week 9-5. Many subspecialty academic practices do 3 days full time clinical work and then 2 days research. Many busy big hospitals might say the "week" is 4 clinic days long with a day for admin. Most inpatient people work 7 days on/then 7 days off, with variability around whether you take night/weekend call.

Location: Anything not in metropolitan California or the east coast big cities will pay about 30-50% more in any situation I'd say.

Specialty or general: Because often specialists work in the more academic centers, specialists do not necessarily make more money than generalists. Quite the opposite sometimes. I guess if you have a private specialty clinic there is opportunity to make people pay out of pocket, and in lots of places there is quite a lot of demand.

Here are some examples:
1. Stroke specialty, fellowship trained. Prestigious academic center in metropolitan CA. Many patients are in the ICU. 10 weeks of service, taking overnight call. 2 clinic half days/week. Teaching responsibilities, manage a neurology resident team. Residents handle all pages. First job out of fellowship. 190k, 10k signing bonus. This compares to the non-academic hospital in the same city, which would have required more like 15-20 weeks of service with you being the first call for strokes,

2. Movement specialty, fellowship trained. Prestigious academic center in metropolitan CA. Outpatient, 3 days of clinic/week. Attainable RVU goal. 2 days of research/week, with expectation to get funding for this portion in 2-3 years. No call. 210k, 25k signing bonus.

3. Neurohospitalist, fellowship trained. Large county hospital in metropolitan CA. On every other week M-F. Consult, working with medicine residents. Often take work home until midnight. On call overnight during those days. All weekends off. The other week, 2 days of clinic. No expectations the other 3 days that week. 306K, 36k built in bonus

4. Neurohospitalist, not fellowship trained. Medium community hospital in urban NM. 7 on/7off. 7-7am. No calls overnight. 330K

5. General neurologist: Outpatient at Kaiser. 4.5 clinic days/week. A little bit of phone call for a few hours here and there. No weekends. $244K.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 10 users
I'm just graduating movement fellowship at a prestigious academic center so the job advertisement emails have been rolling in for 2 years.

Just want to chime in that this is very much in line with what I've seen in my own job searches, targeted emails, and friends who have found jobs within the last several years. You can absolutely make over 300K as an outpatient neurologist or with a reasonable neurohospitalist workload, but when you start getting very much above that (the occasional 500K position in the middle of nowhere), you should be very suspicious that you're going to get abused and not last more than a miserable year. On the low end, at the most prestigious academic centers and substantial protected time for research, you can go as low as ~100-120K until you get your first grants rolling in. The 190-220K academic clinical jobs often provide a sweet spot of reasonable compensation, great benefits, and moderate workload with little to no call, but you can generally make an extra 50-100K in a nearby private job without too much more workload.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4 users
Just want to chime in that this is very much in line with what I've seen in my own job searches, targeted emails, and friends who have found jobs within the last several years. You can absolutely make over 300K as an outpatient neurologist or with a reasonable neurohospitalist workload, but when you start getting very much above that (the occasional 500K position in the middle of nowhere), you should be very suspicious that you're going to get abused and not last more than a miserable year. On the low end, at the most prestigious academic centers and substantial protected time for research, you can go as low as ~100-120K until you get your first grants rolling in. The 190-220K academic clinical jobs often provide a sweet spot of reasonable compensation, great benefits, and moderate workload with little to no call, but you can generally make an extra 50-100K in a nearby private job without too much more workload.
Your main point is absolutely true but academics isn't always better. I'd argue for the average job between M-F you'll be seeing 90-100% of the patient load at a higher average complexity (aka takes longer to write notes, review outside records) in many of those 190k to 220k academic jobs compared to the outpatient job at $300k if you are careful about what private job you take. Many departments are aggressive about chaining attendings to clinic outside of research positions. There are many exceptions to this obviously. Then trying to arrange an outside gig to make up the income difference one is essentially giving up many of their weekends to make this set up work. Meanwhile a locums guy working that many days a month seeing same or fewer patients overall can easily be clearing your $500k figure at 20 days/month at $2200-$2500/day or more- sometimes not even traveling more than 2-3 hours a way for gigs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
Members don't see this ad :)
I'd argue that any non-academic job paying less than 300K for a full time neurologist is bad.

If you're clearing 5000 RVU per year (about average), you should reasonably be in the low to mid 300s.

I work at a community hospital, outpatient only. 4.5 day work week. 10 to 12 patients per day. EMG and headache injections in addition to clinic visits.

No nights. Rare weekend call from home (4 to 5 times per year) covering clinic patients only (emergent med refills, etc). Overall, quality of life is decent.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4 users
I'd argue that any non-academic job paying less than 300K for a full time neurologist is bad.

If you're clearing 5000 RVU per year (about average), you should reasonably be in the low to mid 300s.

I work at a community hospital, outpatient only. 4.5 day work week. 10 to 12 patients per day. EMG and headache injections in addition to clinic visits.

No nights. Rare weekend call from home (4 to 5 times per year) covering clinic patients only (emergent med refills, etc). Overall, quality of life is decent.

What kind of patient volume is needed to produce 5k wRVUs in a outpatient setting? What about inpatient?
 
What kind of patient volume is needed to produce 5k wRVUs in a outpatient setting? What about inpatient?

10 to 12 patients per day, 4.5 clinic days per week will get you there in my experience. But I do EMG as well as Botox and nerve blocks for headache, so if you're doing less procedures then you may need to see more patients per day.

No idea about the inpatient side since I'm 100% outpatient.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
I'm just graduating movement fellowship at a prestigious academic center so the job advertisement emails have been rolling in for 2 years.

There is SO MUCH variability to neurology salary it is mind boggling. There are basically no rules.

You can work every other week as a neurohospitalist in Alaska and make 500k. You can work every day 9-5 as a cognitive outpatient doc in a big california city at a prestigious academic center and make 160k.

As other people have said, there is so much more to consider than dollars per hour. What stage are you at? You shouldn't even be thinking about this until you're atleast a R2.

I'll try and break down the factors that go in to salary,
Practice type: private, employed, locums. Private, typically you get paid for what you do in RVUs. This is where procedure heavy specialties win out (reading EEG, injections, EMG). Employed- you work for a hospital/clinic, managed care organization, VA, something like that. You get a set salary for whatever %time you work. Often the salary is tied to an RVU goal, especially for outpatient providers. Hospitals aren't dumb and they set an RVU goal based on about what amount of work they think you should do for that time and for what you're doing. The RVU goal therefore requires a certain amount of work for your salary, but also provides bonus opportunity if you get very fast or efficient at what you do. Some places don't have an RVU goal (Kaiser, for example, other community operations) and they're basically paying you to just see people and for your availability. What that salary is that you are working towards is highly variable based on location (more remote == more money), academic or not (academic == less money), and private/public (this can be a mixed bag, with county hospitals in some area paying more than academic public universities, etc). Locums you're basically a free floating neurologist for hire, though often people will stay at one place for potentially longer times. Payment is typically shift or hourly, with some room for bonus/productivity. Per hour, locums probably actually pays the most, because these hospitals are so desperate for any kind of neurology coverage and they need it NOW. It seems like you're perhaps interested in research? Unfortunately, your plan to maximize dollars on a few days a week to "free up" time for research doesn't really work. If you're going to do research in any real way you need to be at an academic institution. You can't really just elect to work 2 days/week at a high paying specialty and like be freewheeling the rest of the time. Basically you sign up for a full time position, lets say it pays $210k, and then you come up with ways to pay that salary. Initially a department might offer 210k for 3 days of clinic and 2 days of research, but those 2 days of research will eventually have to be paid by grant money. It's not like you get paid 210 for 3 days of work and the rest is volunteering. So eventually you get a grant and pay for X% of 210k with that, and if the number is not 100% you and your department negotiate what work you need to do to fill the space.

Work setting: outpatient/inpatient. This primarily determines your work schedule, and less your reimbursement, as alot depends on the factors above. But it is vital to consider in terms of what you're willing to do for the money. Outpatient is typically 3-5 clinic days a week 9-5. Many subspecialty academic practices do 3 days full time clinical work and then 2 days research. Many busy big hospitals might say the "week" is 4 clinic days long with a day for admin. Most inpatient people work 7 days on/then 7 days off, with variability around whether you take night/weekend call.

Location: Anything not in metropolitan California or the east coast big cities will pay about 30-50% more in any situation I'd say.

Specialty or general: Because often specialists work in the more academic centers, specialists do not necessarily make more money than generalists. Quite the opposite sometimes. I guess if you have a private specialty clinic there is opportunity to make people pay out of pocket, and in lots of places there is quite a lot of demand.

Here are some examples:
1. Stroke specialty, fellowship trained. Prestigious academic center in metropolitan CA. Many patients are in the ICU. 10 weeks of service, taking overnight call. 2 clinic half days/week. Teaching responsibilities, manage a neurology resident team. Residents handle all pages. First job out of fellowship. 190k, 10k signing bonus. This compares to the non-academic hospital in the same city, which would have required more like 15-20 weeks of service with you being the first call for strokes,

2. Movement specialty, fellowship trained. Prestigious academic center in metropolitan CA. Outpatient, 3 days of clinic/week. Attainable RVU goal. 2 days of research/week, with expectation to get funding for this portion in 2-3 years. No call. 210k, 25k signing bonus.

3. Neurohospitalist, fellowship trained. Large county hospital in metropolitan CA. On every other week M-F. Consult, working with medicine residents. Often take work home until midnight. On call overnight during those days. All weekends off. The other week, 2 days of clinic. No expectations the other 3 days that week. 306K, 36k built in bonus

4. Neurohospitalist, not fellowship trained. Medium community hospital in urban NM. 7 on/7off. 7-7am. No calls overnight. 330K

5. General neurologist: Outpatient at Kaiser. 4.5 clinic days/week. A little bit of phone call for a few hours here and there. No weekends. $244K.
Thank you for such a detailed explanation! I think these examples certainly give us a nice estimate of how much different jobs in different schedules and setting pay.
 
I'd argue that any non-academic job paying less than 300K for a full time neurologist is bad.

If you're clearing 5000 RVU per year (about average), you should reasonably be in the low to mid 300s.

I work at a community hospital, outpatient only. 4.5 day work week. 10 to 12 patients per day. EMG and headache injections in addition to clinic visits.

No nights. Rare weekend call from home (4 to 5 times per year) covering clinic patients only (emergent med refills, etc). Overall, quality of life is decent.
Yes this was my point regarding academics vs PP. 10-12 pt/d is 30 min f/u 1 hr new or better 8-5 which is adequate to do high quality, non-rushed neurology to fairly complicated patients. Plenty of outpatient jobs will do this at >300k for no call to nearly no call, no hospital coverage plus whatever procedures one desires. Desirable metros will be a bit less. Academics will make you do the same volume, same 0.8 to 0.9 FTE for less pay AND sign you up for committees, resident crap, 'research' that will take extra of your time for no compensation. Why accept that racket? Get paid what you are worth- this is why neurology depts nearly everywhere can't retain faculty and take advantage of the faculty that stay.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Yes this was my point regarding academics vs PP. 10-12 pt/d is 30 min f/u 1 hr new or better 8-5 which is adequate to do high quality, non-rushed neurology to fairly complicated patients. Plenty of outpatient jobs will do this at >300k for no call to nearly no call, no hospital coverage plus whatever procedures one desires. Desirable metros will be a bit less. Academics will make you do the same volume, same 0.8 to 0.9 FTE for less pay AND sign you up for committees, resident crap, 'research' that will take extra of your time for no compensation. Why accept that racket? Get paid what you are worth- this is why neurology depts nearly everywhere can't retain faculty and take advantage of the faculty that stay.
In my limited experience this gap is less in desirable metros outside of certain notorious academic institutions. For reference, I currently live in an undesirable metro and the pay gap you describe is pretty accurate, though my friends in PP earning what you mention seem to do a bit more volume per half day than I do and definitely have more call (which isn't buffered by residents). I just accepted a job in a desirable metro, and from the jobs I was weighing and those people contacted me with, plus other similar situations from friends in desirable metro, the gap is more like 30-50K for PP and the workload described is quite a bit more. The benefits between the academic center where I'm going and the nearby PP are also not even in the same universe. This is something that really varies by individual institution, practice, and metro area. There are academic centers that will abuse their faculty and PP setups that will do the same. I personally think the really benign academic centers are an ideal place to avoid burnout, but that's an individual decision as well as some really hate things like resident teaching.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
In my limited experience this gap is less in desirable metros outside of certain notorious academic institutions. For reference, I currently live in an undesirable metro and the pay gap you describe is pretty accurate, though my friends in PP earning what you mention seem to do a bit more volume per half day than I do and definitely have more call (which isn't buffered by residents). I just accepted a job in a desirable metro, and from the jobs I was weighing and those people contacted me with, plus other similar situations from friends in desirable metro, the gap is more like 30-50K for PP and the workload described is quite a bit more. The benefits between the academic center where I'm going and the nearby PP are also not even in the same universe. This is something that really varies by individual institution, practice, and metro area. There are academic centers that will abuse their faculty and PP setups that will do the same. I personally think the really benign academic centers are an ideal place to avoid burnout, but that's an individual decision as well as some really hate things like resident teaching.
Agree, desirable metro changes things pretty significantly, and the majority of PP settings are busier than the majority of academic settings. Key is for one to find the right mix for themselves which often requires carefully scrutinizing potential jobs/contracts and negotiating aggressively/being willing to walk away to avoid being taken advantage of.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Lots of good points!

As another data point, someone threw out 5000 RVU for a +300k private salary- for reference, the academic salaries I'm looking at are 210k but for only 2800 RVU. For other attendings I work with, I have seen this mean 3 days/week of medium busy clinics with anywhere from 8-12 patients a day. Will I still have to work 5 days a week for research/teaching committments, yes, but is that different from 2000 more RVUs and all the messages, notes, etc that come with it? I think so but other people may not.

I want to highlight another comment about the benefits people get or don't get- agree, most universities have way more benefits. For example Kaiser does not have maternity leave and I doubt private practice has it either, but if you're faculty at a university you get like 3 months, depending on the school of course. Both universities I am considering have matching retirement programs, I assume this does not happen in PP. I'm part of a professional facebook organization and just the other day someone was complaining how they are having to argue with their employer about a 5k medical bill for a workplace stick injury- it is so expensive because 1. Occ health was already closed by the time this accident happened and the person had to seek testing through their own insurance and 2. they have such skeletal health insurance that a few blood tests at an urgent care ended up costing them 5k! That's crazy! My current insurance has like a $50 copay for urgent care visits and that's it! And that's because it's real comprehensive health insurance and not disaster coverage.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Lots of good points!

As another data point, someone threw out 5000 RVU for a +300k private salary- for reference, the academic salaries I'm looking at are 210k but for only 2800 RVU. For other attendings I work with, I have seen this mean 3 days/week of medium busy clinics with anywhere from 8-12 patients a day. Will I still have to work 5 days a week for research/teaching committments, yes, but is that different from 2000 more RVUs and all the messages, notes, etc that come with it? I think so but other people may not.

I want to highlight another comment about the benefits people get or don't get- agree, most universities have way more benefits. For example Kaiser does not have maternity leave and I doubt private practice has it either, but if you're faculty at a university you get like 3 months, depending on the school of course. Both universities I am considering have matching retirement programs, I assume this does not happen in PP. I'm part of a professional facebook organization and just the other day someone was complaining how they are having to argue with their employer about a 5k medical bill for a workplace stick injury- it is so expensive because 1. Occ health was already closed by the time this accident happened and the person had to seek testing through their own insurance and 2. they have such skeletal health insurance that a few blood tests at an urgent care ended up costing them 5k! That's crazy! My current insurance has like a $50 copay for urgent care visits and that's it! And that's because it's real comprehensive health insurance and not disaster coverage.
Going to disappoint a lot of people if they think 2800 RVU/3 days a week of clinic is normal in academics. Normal is 4 to 4.5 full days of clinic per week with 10-15 encounters a day from what I have seen, and the departments still manage to lose money on these clinics in some cases. The benefits are typically good though and make up a little of the pay difference- many private practice jobs may be 1099 where you have to fund benefits yourself.
 
Seeing 10-12 patients a day in private practice is a great way to barely pay your overhead (and yourself zero) in many markets

You really don't need an hour for a new and 30 min for a follow up for many common neurology patients, no matter what lazy academic attendings tell you
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Seeing 10-12 patients a day in private practice is a great way to barely pay your overhead (and yourself zero) in many markets

You really don't need an hour for a new and 30 min for a follow up for many common neurology patients, no matter what lazy academic attendings tell you
100% accurate. Most academic attendings only see the complicated stuff sent to them from their *also* academic referral source. how often in residency did you see a simple headache, neuropathy, other case? in PP, thats the normal with the rare complicated case that takes more than 25 mins to complete.

I'm in outpatient pp. Most of my follow ups are 5-8 min visits (yes, that includes interval history, catching up, exam and treatment plan and closure). Then 2-3 mins for the note and on to the next one New patients typically take 15-25 and occasionally longer if they are a talker or I think something complicated might be going on.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 users
100% accurate. Most academic attendings only see the complicated stuff sent to them from their *also* academic referral source. how often in residency did you see a simple headache, neuropathy, other case? in PP, thats the normal with the rare complicated case that takes more than 25 mins to complete.

I'm in outpatient pp. Most of my follow ups are 5-8 min visits (yes, that includes interval history, catching up, exam and treatment plan and closure). Then 2-3 mins for the note and on to the next one New patients typically take 15-25 and occasionally longer if they are a talker or I think something complicated might be going on.

Wow. Residency clinic is nothing like that
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Top