D
deleted6669
ProZackMI said:It's obvious that lawquil is a PA, who despite his lack of a graduate degree, wishes he was some kind of 'doctor'. A PA is an assistant, hence the ASSISTANT part of PA. A PA is not an independent profession and there is no such thing as the profession of physician assisting. A PA is a paraprofessional just like a teacher's aide or legal assistant.
An NP has more autonomy and more skill, IMO. Does that mean I advocate for a doctorate in NP? No, I don't and think it's overkill and somewhat pretentious.
for what it is worth lawguil is a college health careers counselor......
I agree that np's have more autonomy. pa's by design are aligned with physicians to have some degree of oversight to their practice, not because they aren't as good as np's but because they realize that oversight of non-physician/midlevel providers assures quality.
I can't agree that np's have more skill. take a good look at the curriculum of a pa and an np program at the same school. the pa will avg over 2000 hrs of clinical rotations in addition to taking many medschool level courses taught by md's and phd's in their fields.
np programs in the didactic phase offer a watered down preparation to practice medicine with lots of touchy feely classes and very little hard science.many np proigrams have less than 600 hrs of clinical time total. I just had an np student rotate with me who completed her entire er/acute care medicine rotation in 2 weeks. an np program can be done in less than 2 yrs part time while still holding a full time job. it is the rare full time pa student who can work during pa school. the truth of the matter is that an rn who becomes a pa is prepared better to practice medicine than an rn who becomes an np. 30% of all pa's are/were nurses so it is not as uncommon as you might think. there were many in my class at hahnemann and there are many who I interact with daily at work.
do I think there is value in a pa or np getting a doctorate for any other reason than teaching or administration? nope.....
as an aside....a doctorate level np still ends up with less clinical time on rotations than a pa with a certificate, a.s., or b.s........