I don't really understand why you quoted/dissected my post about why liver transplant itself is not an appropriate surrogate for trauma and instead just talked about all of the other kinds of cases that can prepare you for it.
If you think the point I am trying to make is that you have to have done traumas in training in order to be able to do traumas as an attending, that is not my opinion at all.
My whole point is that liver transplant is a terrible surrogate for trauma training. But, if you don't have tons of training in trauma, residency experiences in other areas should be fine.
No, no... I am at a program with a very high-volume of both. Concepts are similar but situational preparedness and reactiveness are very different in my opinion.