Does Primary Care = Preventive Medicine?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Ibn Rushd

Full Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2007
Messages
373
Reaction score
4
Points
4,551
Location
Los Angeles
  1. Medical Student
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
I'm trying to wrap my head around some of the more common terms I hear every now and then, and thus far, I haven't been able to discern a difference between "primary care" and "preventive medicine." Are the two synonyms? Don't both attempt to prevent disease and encourage lifestyle/diet changes? Don't practitioners in both manage chronic illnesses like hypertension and diabetes?

On a similar note, would it be fair to say that "acute care" is the same as "emergency medicine?" Any help on clearly defining these terms would be appreciated. Thanks in advance! 🙂
 
Primary care is the provision of on-going care and usually includes screening (or referral for screening and interpretation of results), health education, and care of minor illnesses and on-going care for chronic conditions. Primary care providers should be able to handle common acute and chronic conditions. Patients whose disease does not respond to treatment prescribed by the primary care provider can be referred to a specialist or subspecialist.

So, someone may see a primary care provider who treats this person's hypertension, high cholesterol, type 2 diabetes, and mild arthritis (several of the most common chronic conditions in America). The primary care provider may also provide vaccines, annual "check-ups" and lab work, as well as treatment of acute illnesses and minor injuries. The primary care provider may refer the patient to a specialist if a problem does not respond to conservative therapy or if a very serious illness that requires a specialist (e.g. a patient comes in with a complaint of fatigue and bruising and blood work indicates an acute leukemia.)

Acute care means something treatment of something that has come on rather suddenly. I might get a sore throat, ear ache, and swollen glands. I need "acute care" but there is no reason for that care to be delivered in the emergency department. My primary care physician can take a look, order diagnostic tests, if indicated, and prescribe treatment (which might be limited to symptom relief for a virus or antibiotic therapy for a bacterial infection).

Preventive Medicine (as a residency) focuses on education/ advocacy/ administration /public policy and is closely allied with public health. Unless the person is doing a combined preventive medicine/internal medicine residency, those trained in preventive medicine don't provide patient care but focus more on research, health education, and the like.
 
Pediatricians also provide primary care. Gynecologists want to be considered primary care providers (for the most part when HMOs want patients to identify a primary care provider) but in my experience they do not want to handle anything beyond the pelvis and breasts and they will refer out for even the most minor illnesses.
 
Preventative care = having the right foods in your grocery basket at the supermarket, exercising, and having a healthy social life. 👍
 
Thank you guys for the insightful responses. I think I get it now. 🙂

Would it be fair to say that primary care physicians (family medicine, internal medicine, and obstetrics/gynecology doctors mainly) incorporate a lot of preventive medicine in their practice albeit not explicitly doing the same things a preventive medicine specialist would do? Or by extension, do all doctors, to some extent, incorporate preventive medicine (by this I mean things like encouraging lifestyle/exercise/diet management)?
 
Thank you guys for the insightful responses. I think I get it now. 🙂

Would it be fair to say that primary care physicians (family medicine, internal medicine, and obstetrics/gynecology doctors mainly) incorporate a lot of preventive medicine in their practice albeit not explicitly doing the same things a preventive medicine specialist would do? Or by extension, do all doctors, to some extent, incorporate preventive medicine (by this I mean things like encouraging lifestyle/exercise/diet management)?

For many subspecialists, health promotion and disease prevention is too little, too late. By this I mean the neonatalogists, radiation oncologists, reproductive endocrinologists, most of the surgeons, radiologists, pathologists.... Physicians who have long term relationships (over many years) with their patients are more likely to engage in health promotion education with their patients.
 
For many subspecialists, health promotion and disease prevention is too little, too late. By this I mean the neonatalogists, radiation oncologists, reproductive endocrinologists, most of the surgeons, radiologists, pathologists.... Physicians who have long term relationships (over many years) with their patients are more likely to engage in health promotion education with their patients.

Just to clarify . . .
Would it be safe to say that, I want to get into PCP, because I like the aspects of health promotion/disease prevention etc?
 
Just to clarify . . .
Would it be safe to say that, I want to get into PCP, because I like the aspects of health promotion/disease prevention etc?
If you want to provide primary prevention (vaccines, health education aimed at preventing illness and injury) then PCP is a good place to do that. There is quite a bit of secondary and tertiary prevention done by PCPs, screening and early detection of illnesses to improve outcomes, treatment of illnesses to prevent complications.
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Pediatricians also provide primary care. Gynecologists want to be considered primary care providers (for the most part when HMOs want patients to identify a primary care provider) but in my experience they do not want to handle anything beyond the pelvis and breasts and they will refer out for even the most minor illnesses.
I would suggest that most gynecologists consider themselves specialists in the medical and surgical management of adult women, not primary care providers. They are, however the de facto provider of primary care for most of their patients. Because most of the residency training of Gynecologists is surgical, their experience of non-reproductive medical management is usually far less than that of a primary care provider, thus the frequent (appropriate) referral.

Since most of the preventive care needed by the average woman falls into the purview of reproductive health, we have the resultant hybrid "primary care/ surgical specialty that bedevils us. Ob/gyn is considered primary care by the NHSC and has that government designation.

There was a time when the restriction of self referral was an issue for Ob/Gyns, but I have seen little evidence of it in the last decade.
 
Primary care is the provision of on-going care and usually includes screening (or referral for screening and interpretation of results), health education, and care of minor illnesses and on-going care for chronic conditions. Primary care providers should be able to handle common acute and chronic conditions. Patients whose disease does not respond to treatment prescribed by the primary care provider can be referred to a specialist or subspecialist.

Where would an allergist fall in these designations? Just curious.
 
Unless the person is doing a combined preventive medicine/internal medicine residency, those trained in preventive medicine don't provide patient care but focus more on research, health education, and the like.

Thank you for your comments.

I am highly interested in combining PM, IM and health/public policy. I want to ask if you personally know any particular combined residencies you would recommend for students like me.

In addition, do students also pursue the IM residency followed by the PM residency (or vice versa) separately, if they could not enter combined programs for whatever reasons?
 
Thank you for your comments.

I am highly interested in combining PM, IM and health/public policy. I want to ask if you personally know any particular combined residencies you would recommend for students like me.

In addition, do students also pursue the IM residency followed by the PM residency (or vice versa) separately, if they could not enter combined programs for whatever reasons?
I have no idea. My experience with residency is very, very limited.
 
I have no idea. My experience with residency is very, very limited.

Thank you for your reply. I appreciate it. I'll try to look it up somewhere or hopefully someone else could chime in.
 
Thank you for your comments.

I am highly interested in combining PM, IM and health/public policy. I want to ask if you personally know any particular combined residencies you would recommend for students like me.

In addition, do students also pursue the IM residency followed by the PM
residency (or vice versa) separately, if they could not enter combined programs for whatever reasons?
I accidentally stumbled on this while searching for pm&r programs in California.
http://pmr.ucsd.edu
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lya
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
I do believe that most elderly patients receive their care from a family practioner or a internist (specialist in internal medicine).

Geriatrics is a subspecialty open to physicians in family medicine and internal medicine. It tends to focus on the elderly who have multiple chronic conditions or who have new and troublesome symptoms such as memory loss and falls that require a holistic approach to diagnosis and treatment. In some cases, geriatricians provide ongoing care and coordination of services among a variety of providers (e.g. orthopedic surgery and neurology and vascular surgery) and in other settings they provide consultation and send the patient back to their primary care provider for ongoing care.
 
Would geriatrics also be considered primary care? (In reference to pediatrics being primary care).
I am interested in working with the elderly.

Geriatrics is often a one year fellowship after 3 years in Internal Medicine residency.

I also know a doctor who completed a year long residency in preventive medicine after he got his MPH but he was already a specialist. I have no idea what they do though, but he hasn't worked with patients since he completed that training.
 
Thanks for your reply!
I was wondering as far as in my PS/interviews should I just talk about primary care in general or should I specifically mention geriatrics? One of my most meaningful ECs involves working with the elderly.
@gyngyn
Interest in geriatrics or 1' care is definitely a recruitment point in your favor.
 
I do believe that most elderly patients receive their care from a family practioner or a internist (specialist in internal medicine).

Geriatrics is a subspecialty open to physicians in family medicine and internal medicine. It tends to focus on the elderly who have multiple chronic conditions or who have new and troublesome symptoms such as memory loss and falls that require a holistic approach to diagnosis and treatment. In some cases, geriatricians provide ongoing care and coordination of services among a variety of providers (e.g. orthopedic surgery and neurology and vascular surgery) and in other settings they provide consultation and send the patient back to their primary care provider for ongoing care.
The idea ongoing care (especially for those in the later years of life) is what I feel I will enjoy the most.
Building patient/provider relationships can be so powerful (in my experience as an EMT.) Personally I find that easier to do with elderly individuals.
 
I do believe that most elderly patients receive their care from a family practioner or a internist (specialist in internal medicine).

Geriatrics is a subspecialty open to physicians in family medicine and internal medicine. It tends to focus on the elderly who have multiple chronic conditions or who have new and troublesome symptoms such as memory loss and falls that require a holistic approach to diagnosis and treatment. In some cases, geriatricians provide ongoing care and coordination of services among a variety of providers (e.g. orthopedic surgery and neurology and vascular surgery) and in other settings they provide consultation and send the patient back to their primary care provider for ongoing care.
Does palliative care fall under the umbrella of geriatrics?
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Top Bottom