ER doc here. For the record, I can’t think of a single colleague that thinks this is a good idea. This has to be an isolated thing in that area, because I have literally never even conceived of this. As an aggregate, ER docs have nooooo inclination to play anesthesiologist. I promise.
As far as someone being called as “backup” - I agree that’s insulting and just weird. I’ve only called anesthesiology to the bedside twice in my career. The first was a 400lb 38wk seizing pregnant lady, that I had initially failed to successfully intubate, and was BVM-ing and thought she needed the OR. I ended up getting the tube as they walked in the ER room. The second was a super bad angioedema at a place that didn’t have anesthesiology or surgery in-house. I was mucking around with the glide and the bronch, and I was afraid I was going to have to cric him, and felt better with anesthiology and GS at least on the way to the hospital.
In each case it wasn’t me asking somebody to be a “backup.” It was more “Hey, I need help here. Can we either do this together in the ED, or send them to the OR if you prefer?” It always been very collegial.
I think most of my ED fellow ER docs are super respectful of our anesthesiology colleagues, and that most of the incidents described in this thread are fairly isolated.
Just my 2 cents!