EM docs in Michigan justifying replacing their anesthesiologist colleagues

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
These are the oddest statements ever.

We make it look easy because of our physician training and skill. If it looks hard then we aren't doing it right.

When good surgeons take out an appendix in 15 min they make it look easy too - and it's not because it's easy, it's because they they're skilled.

Every high level job is easy till it isn't.
I agree with this. I’ve seen some awful locum docs and equally horrid crnas. You think it’s easy cause you’re well trained and professional. There are many different ways to eff up and have a bad outcome.

Edit: to clarify I am locums doc.
 
Last edited:
I agree with this. I’ve seen some awful locum docs and equally horrid crnas. You think it’s easy cause you’re well trained and professional. There are many different ways to eff up and have a bad outcome.
I dunno. These days some of the locums docs and locums crnas are often times better than the regular employed w2 staff.

Locums quality isn’t like it was in the past where those on the outskirts of the profession struggled to find full time w2 job. But ur quality will vary.
 
I dunno. These days some of the locums docs and locums crnas are often times better than the regular employed w2 staff.

Locums quality isn’t like it was in the past where those on the outskirts of the profession struggled to find full time w2 job. But ur quality will vary.
Definitely agree; there used to be a stigma there, but there are more and more very capable anesthesiologists who have discovered the locums world, where you can earn closer to what you deserve, without working alongside some of the game playing, scheming W2 colleagues that always seem to be able to manipulate the schedule to benefit them, where everyone is making the same.
 
I dunno. These days some of the locums docs and locums crnas are often times better than the regular employed w2 staff.

Locums quality isn’t like it was in the past where those on the outskirts of the profession struggled to find full time w2 job. But ur quality will vary.
I should have clarified that I am a locums doc. I didn’t mean any disrespect to any kind of physician locums or otherwise
 
Locums is like a box of chocolates… you never know what you’re going to get. Two of the weakest anesthesiologists I know do Locums exclusively- also one of the strongest. Same for crnas - one of the strongest and a few of the weakest
Don't you think it's the same for any employed anesthesiologist in any setting (PP, employed, academic)? The best clinicians, the hardest working ones that are the most skilled, most able/willing and able to give 4 morning breaks and 4 lunch breaks (wow what a ****ty job LOL) are paid the same as the laziest, least competent folks that hide in a corner at 2:30/4:30 when relief is most needed? Locums/Perm doesn't matter, nor did it ever, because the folks in academics are always in the race to do the least clinically while having the most free time off doing *mostly* nothing while their clinician educators do all the revenue generating work.
 
Don't you think it's the same for any employed anesthesiologist in any setting (PP, employed, academic)? The best clinicians, the hardest working ones that are the most skilled, most able/willing and able to give 4 morning breaks and 4 lunch breaks (wow what a ****ty job LOL) are paid the same as the laziest, least competent folks that hide in a corner at 2:30/4:30 when relief is most needed? Locums/Perm doesn't matter, nor did it ever, because the folks in academics are always in the race to do the least clinically while having the most free time off doing *mostly* nothing while their clinician educators do all the revenue generating work.
This is why everyone should be on production. Everything you do should be reimbursed. So if you wanna be lazy, your pay will reflect it. Breed the commie right out of you.
 
This is why everyone should be on production. Everything you do should be reimbursed. So if you wanna be lazy, your pay will reflect it. Breed the commie right out of you.
Unworkable system. We have no control over our productivity. I don’t want to be penalized because I’m assigned to a slow surgeon or some offsite location where efficiency is not a priority
 
Unworkable system. We have no control over our productivity. I don’t want to be penalized because I’m assigned to a slow surgeon or some offsite location where efficiency is not a priority
True. This also leads to manipulation of the case assignments and hostility among group members because there will always be the "haves" and the have nots" and the case assignments will be used to play favorites. There does not appear to be a perfect system where a slacker cannot hide. It is why hiring the right person is so important. You must be able to trust your colleagues to do the right thing and work hard, but there will certainly be instances where a slacker gets shielded.
It must also be remembered that, human nature is to see 100% of the times that you worked harder than someone else and far less of the times that someone else worked way harder than you. It is natural to feel like you frequently come up on the short end of the workload or case assignments. We rarely get to see first hand what our colleagues are doing. But we certainly see it and talk about it when they are noted to be slacking. I think it is important to be open minded and recognize that, in most cases, everyone is working hard and trying to do the right thing. It is the uncommon person who actively tries to manipulate colleagues. In those cases, a group leader should identify and call out the behavior in a private conversation to try to get a behavioral change. Often, they do not have insight into how their actions are perceived by others and many will try to recover their reputation. Those who do not can eventually be weeded out.
What I have found over my career is that everyone brings something different to the table. Not everyone is good at everything or has the likeable personality that we all wish for. I make my best attempt to recognize the good that those suboptimal individuals bring to the table and it helps me like them better. I had a colleague who was far less likeable than most due to a gruff personality. But, he was willing to work many major holidays that others did not wish to work. I focused on that with the group and talked it up. He was appreciative of the kind words and it also seemed to help others appreciate him and look past some of his less desirable characteristics.
 
Yea no way I would be paid on production unless I had control of the schedule. A few anesthesiologist have a preference already for the block rooms or OB or GI and no one really cares if they get their favorites because we all make the same $.
We don’t have a hiding problem where I am now… but it’s a small pp group paid on salary. No one hides or tries to get out of work…. We all pick up 4 rooms as needed to get people out - there’s a well defined relief list based on proximity to call…. It’s the same for everyone and works out in the end.
Theres only like 10 of us working per day so maybe that’s why there’s no where to hide
 
True. This also leads to manipulation of the case assignments and hostility among group members because there will always be the "haves" and the have nots" and the case assignments will be used to play favorites. There does not appear to be a perfect system where a slacker cannot hide. It is why hiring the right person is so important. You must be able to trust your colleagues to do the right thing and work hard, but there will certainly be instances where a slacker gets shielded.
It must also be remembered that, human nature is to see 100% of the times that you worked harder than someone else and far less of the times that someone else worked way harder than you. It is natural to feel like you frequently come up on the short end of the workload or case assignments. We rarely get to see first hand what our colleagues are doing. But we certainly see it and talk about it when they are noted to be slacking. I think it is important to be open minded and recognize that, in most cases, everyone is working hard and trying to do the right thing. It is the uncommon person who actively tries to manipulate colleagues. In those cases, a group leader should identify and call out the behavior in a private conversation to try to get a behavioral change. Often, they do not have insight into how their actions are perceived by others and many will try to recover their reputation. Those who do not can eventually be weeded out.
What I have found over my career is that everyone brings something different to the table. Not everyone is good at everything or has the likeable personality that we all wish for. I make my best attempt to recognize the good that those suboptimal individuals bring to the table and it helps me like them better. I had a colleague who was far less likeable than most due to a gruff personality. But, he was willing to work many major holidays that others did not wish to work. I focused on that with the group and talked it up. He was appreciative of the kind words and it also seemed to help others appreciate him and look past some of his less desirable characteristics.
What exactly does this mean you have slackers hiding. Your job is to either sign CRNA charts or sit an a comfortable chair yourself while the surgeon works. Cancelling cases? That usually take more work than just doing them.
 
I love this. They can't hack their own ****ty job so think they can replace us. **** the bed the second they got a real case without a million back up ppl...

I just cant wait for the 1st court case and then we really find out how brave they are...

Theyve literally never done an elective case. That's some shakey ground right there to assume insurance will cover their ass
Uh, I’d never want to do anesthesia work but the idea of an experienced ER doc pooping their pants because of, what, a crashing patient? Bad airway? A million backup ppl not around? Who do you think is the only doc in the hospital after hours in most non-tertiary hospitals? Come on man, get over yourself. It’s not the ER docs you should be worried about…
 
Yea no way I would be paid on production unless I had control of the schedule. A few anesthesiologist have a preference already for the block rooms or OB or GI and no one really cares if they get their favorites because we all make the same $.
We don’t have a hiding problem where I am now… but it’s a small pp group paid on salary. No one hides or tries to get out of work…. We all pick up 4 rooms as needed to get people out - there’s a well defined relief list based on proximity to call…. It’s the same for everyone and works out in the end.
Theres only like 10 of us working per day so maybe that’s why there’s no where to hide
Work Hours matters more Production is a thing of the past with lower reimbursements.

People can hide all they want. But they can’t leave and I think that drives people crazy more.

The old days of the senior partners leaving by 12pm and the jr stuck to 5pm routinely are pretty much dead with the hourly model
 
Yea if I’m at work I’d rather work…. I think most of us feel this way and that’s why it works and we all try to get each other out so the same happens when it’s our turn. If anyone didn’t think like this I think they’d get a talking too…. We all get along pretty well - I think they’d cut someone who didn’t fit in to the vibe
 
What exactly does this mean you have slackers hiding. Your job is to either sign CRNA charts or sit an a comfortable chair yourself while the surgeon works. Cancelling cases? That usually take more work than just doing them.
I think the discussion was surrounding people who do not contribute to the overall mission of getting the work done, such as showing up late, delaying starts due to consent or preop issues, difficult to find when time to be present for induction (causing others to have to show up to keep the train moving), or not helping with breaks (if that is the culture). Additionally, when it is time to work the order off list, they may be late to respond when asked to take over a room, but quick to respond when it is their room to be taken over. Each noted instance may be only 5 to 10 minutes each, but there are multiple opportunities in a day and if someone is frequently unavailable or unresponsive to calls, it really can add a lot of frustration (and time) to a team's day. That is my take on it. Others may have other things to add.
 
I think the discussion was surrounding people who do not contribute to the overall mission of getting the work done, such as showing up late, delaying starts due to consent or preop issues, difficult to find when time to be present for induction (causing others to have to show up to keep the train moving), or not helping with breaks (if that is the culture). Additionally, when it is time to work the order off list, they may be late to respond when asked to take over a room, but quick to respond when it is their room to be taken over. Each noted instance may be only 5 to 10 minutes each, but there are multiple opportunities in a day and if someone is frequently unavailable or unresponsive to calls, it really can add a lot of frustration (and time) to a team's day. That is my take on it. Others may have other things to add.
That's it in a nutshell; the perfect description of a non team player.
 
Work Hours matters more Production is a thing of the past with lower reimbursements.

People can hide all they want. But they can’t leave and I think that drives people crazy more.

The old days of the senior partners leaving by 12pm and the jr stuck to 5pm routinely are pretty much dead with the hourly model
Noted. but there is a difference between being present to see a preop every 15 mins or so and being present chilling in your office covering rooms. The slacker will always have a list with 2 patients vs 6 patients. Multiply that by 3 or 4 rooms.
 
Uh, I’d never want to do anesthesia work but the idea of an experienced ER doc pooping their pants because of, what, a crashing patient? Bad airway? A million backup ppl not around? Who do you think is the only doc in the hospital after hours in most non-tertiary hospitals? Come on man, get over yourself. It’s not the ER docs you should be worried about…
Dont come after me until you start with your own colleagues trying to replace us...

We never enter your domain unless asked. You can surely see why there bad blood and where it originated from?

Im not worried about ER docs taking my job, im concerned for them they dont want to do their own.
 
Uh, I’d never want to do anesthesia work but the idea of an experienced ER doc pooping their pants because of, what, a crashing patient? Bad airway? A million backup ppl not around? Who do you think is the only doc in the hospital after hours in most non-tertiary hospitals? Come on man, get over yourself. It’s not the ER docs you should be worried about…
You want a case? Here's one... the anesthesia machine has a leak. Pls fix it. You have 3 minutes... there is no one to call...

Can you?
 
You want a case? Here's one... the anesthesia machine has a leak. Pls fix it. You have 3 minutes... there is no one to call...

Can you?
I'm not sure how this devolved into an "Anesthesiology vs. Emergency Medicine" attending squabble, but I'm pretty sure the hospital admins love it. From my understanding, this was limited to endo, and while that is a bit outside of their scope for something like covering 4 endo rooms with 20 procedures each, I don't believe anyone was asking the ER to staff the OPERATING ROOM.

Folks, focus your attention on the fact that this hospital system (like ALL others), didn't compensate physicians' time appropriately, and we should not be fighting amongst each other.
 
I don't believe anyone was asking the ER to staff the OPERATING ROOM.
Few points.
1.
Emerg are trying to replace us in elective sedatio procedures. Elective implies an entirely different standard of care and knowledge. Remember you guys are entering anesthesia domain, it doesn't have to be your rule book anymore.


2. Are you sure employers aren't also thinking to.cross this line?

3. Don't you think prosecutors would exploit this knowledge gap if it comes to it?

4. Our endo guys ask for ga every few weeks. We wheel down an anesthesia machine and carry on. Are you not going to do that case?

5. Its rare but there are a small number of complications that can end up in a trip to OR. Perf, ercp complications, ever do a POEM case? They consent them for 1 in 1000 rate of complications or trip to the OR. How can you sedate for something but not be capable of doing the rare complications?

6. Are you aware that there is @ least some evidence and opinion all ercp should be Ga with a tube? I dont agree or do it, but im aware of it. Sounds like you dont

Some hospital attached endo suites run @ the weekends. Its rare but possible there's some place that anesthesia are @ home while all this is going on...
 
Last edited:
The fact that they are performing in a specialty they are not trained or certified in is all you have to say. The medical board will have a field day with this.
They do not practice within ASA guidelines and the endoscopy suite is one of the most dangerous places in the hospital. It won’t take long before the deaths happen. Probably already have.
 
The fact that they are performing in a specialty they are not trained or certified in is all you have to say. The medical board will have a field day with this.
They do not practice within ASA guidelines and the endoscopy suite is one of the most dangerous places in the hospital. It won’t take long before the deaths happen. Probably already have.
How is this different than docs practicing plastics or aesthetics? I’m in Florida. I walk by a lot of bs aesthetics places. They push the limit on the plastics portion. We all who will start doing breast implants etc who aren’t plastics trained. First it’s starts with Botox which anyone can do. Than it keeps expanding till they start doing real procedures. Most get away with it until there is a major complication.
 
Few points.
1.
Emerg are trying to replace us in elective sedatio procedures. Elective implies an entirely different standard of care and knowledge. Remember you guys are entering anesthesia domain, it doesn't have to be your rule book anymore.


2. Are you sure employers aren't also thinking to.cross this line?

3. Don't you think prosecutors would exploit this knowledge gap if it comes to it?

4. Our endo guys ask for ga every few weeks. We wheel down an anesthesia machine and carry on. Are you not going to do that case?

5. Its rare but there are a small number of complications that can end up in a trip to OR. Perf, ercp complications, ever do a POEM case? They consent them for 1 in 1000 rate of complications or trip to the OR. How can you sedate for something but not be capable of doing the rare complications?

6. Are you aware that there is @ least some evidence and opinion all ercp should be Ga with a tube? I dont agree or do it, but im aware of it. Sounds like you dont

Some hospital attached endo suites run @ the weekends. Its rare but possible there's some place that anesthesia are @ home while all this is going on...
All valid points, why are you being so hostile? I'm a board certified anesthesiologist and proud of our specialty.

I don't have personal experience in Grand Rapids, but it all sounds terrible to me either way. I would love for someone working there to shed light on it. None of this is happening on the pediatric side, but I have no idea what circus the adult sites are at this moment.
 
Few points.
1.
Emerg are trying to replace us in elective sedatio procedures. Elective implies an entirely different standard of care and knowledge. Remember you guys are entering anesthesia domain, it doesn't have to be your rule book anymore.


2. Are you sure employers aren't also thinking to.cross this line?

3. Don't you think prosecutors would exploit this knowledge gap if it comes to it?

4. Our endo guys ask for ga every few weeks. We wheel down an anesthesia machine and carry on. Are you not going to do that case?

5. Its rare but there are a small number of complications that can end up in a trip to OR. Perf, ercp complications, ever do a POEM case? They consent them for 1 in 1000 rate of complications or trip to the OR. How can you sedate for something but not be capable of doing the rare complications?

6. Are you aware that there is @ least some evidence and opinion all ercp should be Ga with a tube? I dont agree or do it, but im aware of it. Sounds like you dont

Some hospital attached endo suites run @ the weekends. Its rare but possible there's some place that anesthesia are @ home while all this is going on...
I am very opposed to the ER docs doing this, but I think some of your arguments are flawed. Namely numbers 4-6.

Considering out west nearly all of general Endo cases are just done with nursing sedation, none of these points matter. When/if they need GA, they'll ask for it and likely schedule it as such. If there's an emergency perf, they'll consult surgery and it'll get posted emergently to the OR.
 
I am very opposed to the ER docs doing this, but I think some of your arguments are flawed. Namely numbers 4-6.

Considering out west nearly all of general Endo cases are just done with nursing sedation, none of these points matter. When/if they need GA, they'll ask for it and likely schedule it as such. If there's an emergency perf, they'll consult surgery and it'll get posted emergently to the OR.
I dont disagree, these things are very rare and often dont go right to the OR but these aren't nurses apeing us. These are attending "sedation" physicians and billing for it. I dont really see why they should be allowed do the easy part of a procedure but then expect someone to do the hard part. They're not good Samaritans why spare them the hard side of our job?
 
Em docs only did Propofol sedation as the old group was leaving. They are not doing any GI cases with em doc there now in Grand Rapids.
 
Anyways. Waterloo Iowa is the next big 1099 gig to attack. Grand Rapids is so yesterday. Waterloo way better. Big money. $650/hr for calls. $450-hr daytime. $550/hr overtime. Who knows how long that will last.

These jobs are a dime a dozen folks. They are all over USA. I’d rather take another gig for $500/hr in a much bigger city in the Midwest with professional sports like mlb baseball nfl football nhl hockey. lol.
 
Last edited:
Anyways. Waterloo Iowa is the next big 1099 gig to attack. Grand Rapids is so yesterday. Waterloo way better. Big money. $650/hr for calls. $450-hr daytime. $550/hr overtime. Who knows how long that will last.

These jobs are a dime a dozen folks. They are all over USA. I’d rather take another gig for $500/hr in a much bigger city in the Midwest with professional sports like mlb baseball nfl football nhl hockey. lol.
The problem with your theory is whoever is paying the 600 dollars an hour is acutely aware of the pain it is to pay one doc this much money so they will make your stay there as short as possible. They will get rid of you as soon as they have a solution. I dont need to make 600 an hour for 1-2 weeks. I need to make 600 an hour for YEARS. Look at Grand Rapids. Sounds like they righted the ship real quick and the mercenaries are out on the phone dealing with those scummy locum recruiters.
 
The problem with your theory is whoever is paying the 600 dollars an hour is acutely aware of the pain it is to pay one doc this much money so they will make your stay there as short as possible. They will get rid of you as soon as they have a solution. I dont need to make 600 an hour for 1-2 weeks. I need to make 600 an hour for YEARS. Look at Grand Rapids. Sounds like they righted the ship real quick and the mercenaries are out on the phone dealing with those scummy locum recruiters.
That’s why u have mutiple gigs going at a time.

I never commit to more than 2 weeks at a time. See ya bros if u wanna to mess with me.
 
That’s why u have mutiple gigs going at a time.

I never commit to more than 2 weeks at a time. See ya bros if u wanna to mess with me.
Agreed.

Hard to live life that way. Believe me I did locums for 10 years and made a lot of money. Most people are not built that way. Even me, now, it would have to be a pretty sweet gig with some serious guarantees for me to be back to that locums nonsense where EVERYONE is lying to you and exploiting you and when you get there they look at you like you are robbing them.
 
Agreed.

Hard to live life that way. Believe me I did locums for 10 years and made a lot of money. Most people are not built that way. Even me, now, it would have to be a pretty sweet gig with some serious guarantees for me to be back to that locums nonsense where EVERYONE is lying to you and exploiting you and when you get there they look at you like you are robbing them.
Yeah. Does nobody have a wife and kids. Don’t think iowa one month then onto Michigan the next and who knows after that would work for me.
 
Agreed.

Hard to live life that way. Believe me I did locums for 10 years and made a lot of money. Most people are not built that way. Even me, now, it would have to be a pretty sweet gig with some serious guarantees for me to be back to that locums nonsense where EVERYONE is lying to you and exploiting you and when you get there they look at you like you are robbing them.
Yes. I trust no one in the locums world.

There are so many different ways to make money in anesthesia these days. Full 1099 travel is not for me

But if u are young and single and no kids. It’s still the best option.
 
You think im the hostile one here?

Interesting how you spin that?

"Are you aware that there is @ least some evidence and opinion all ercp should be Ga with a tube? I dont agree or do it, but im aware of it. Sounds like you don't" - just pointing out your assumptions on my knowledge/skill level.

I'm not on board with EM doing any of this; I want hard facts and to know what is actually going on. If you personally work there and have seen these shenanigans, agreed it's terrible!

I'm peds and this isn't happening at DeVos.
 
M
That’s why u have mutiple gigs going at a time.

I never commit to more than 2 weeks at a time. See ya bros if u wanna to mess with me.
are you credentialed with a bunch of different Locums companies? And then you see a job you like and ask to get credentialed at the specific hospital?
 
Top