Embryology: disruption vs deformation

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

ChessMaster3000

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Mar 7, 2010
Messages
866
Reaction score
295
I can't remember if this is a new section in FA14 but anyway, they say that deformation is "extrinsic disruption; occurs after the embryonic period" and disruption is "secondary breakdown of a previously normal tissue or structure (amniotic band syndrome)". But amniotic band syndrome is related to fibrous bands that cause amputate digits, which sounds like an extrinsic disruption to me. I know it is a small point, but is there any more distinctions to be made between these two?

Members don't see this ad.
 
The embryonic period is only weeks 3-8 or so. After that is the fetal period, then birth. Besides the limbs and heart, almost everything else is pretty susceptible to deformation in the fetal period. From what we were taught, "deformation" is when a teratogen takes something off its normal developmental course (in the fetal period) and "disruption" occurs only to something that was finished developing.
 
The embryonic period is only weeks 3-8 or so. After that is the fetal period, then birth. Besides the limbs and heart, almost everything else is pretty susceptible to deformation in the fetal period. From what we were taught, "deformation" is when a teratogen takes something off its normal developmental course (in the fetal period) and "disruption" occurs only to something that was finished developing.
Are you sure you arent talking about malformation with teratogens?
 
I can't remember if this is a new section in FA14 but anyway, they say that deformation is "extrinsic disruption; occurs after the embryonic period" and disruption is "secondary breakdown of a previously normal tissue or structure (amniotic band syndrome)". But amniotic band syndrome is related to fibrous bands that cause amputate digits, which sounds like an extrinsic disruption to me. I know it is a small point, but is there any more distinctions to be made between these two?

Robbins Basic Pathology, 9th Ed., Chapter 6, p. 247: "Disruptions result from secondary destruction of an organ or body region that was previously normal in development; thus, in contrast with malformations, disruptions arise from an extrinsic disturbance in morphogenesis. Amniotic bands, denoting rupture of amnion with resultant formation of "bands" that encircle, compress, or attach to parts of the developing fetus, constitute the classic example of a disruption. A variety of environmental agents may cause disruptions. Disruptions are not heritable, of course, and thus are not associated with risk of recurrence in subsequent pregnancies.
Deformations, like disruptions, also represent an extrinsic disturbance of development rather than an intrinsic error of morphogenesis. Deformations are common problems, affecting approximately 2% of newborn infants to various degrees. Fundamental to the pathogenesis of deformations is localized or generalized compression of the growing fetus by abnormal biomechanical forces, leading eventually to a variety of structural abnormalities. The most common cause of such deformations is uterine constraint. Between weeks 35 and 38 of gestation, rapid increase in the size of the fetus outpaces the growth of the uterus, and the relative amount of amniotic fluid (which normally acts as a cushion) also decreases. Thus, even the normal fetus is subjected to some degree of uterine constraint. However, several variables increase the likelihood of excessive compression of the fetus, including maternal conditions such as first pregnancy, small uterus, malformed (bicornuate) uterus, and leiomyomas. Causes relating to the fetus, such as presence of multiple fetuses, oligohydramnios, and abnormal fetal presentation, also may be involved."

Disruptions are also due to extrinsic disturbances, so the way FA formulates them leads to a bit of a misunderstanding. Deformation is the alteration of shape due to an extrinsic cause, like a misshapen bone. Disturbance is the destruction of a previously normally formed organ, due to an extrinsic cause again. Amniotic bands is the big example.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
Robbins Basic Pathology, 9th Ed., Chapter 6, p. 247: "Disruptions result from secondary destruction of an organ or body region that was previously normal in development; thus, in contrast with malformations, disruptions arise from an extrinsic disturbance in morphogenesis. Amniotic bands, denoting rupture of amnion with resultant formation of "bands" that encircle, compress, or attach to parts of the developing fetus, constitute the classic example of a disruption. A variety of environmental agents may cause disruptions. Disruptions are not heritable, of course, and thus are not associated with risk of recurrence in subsequent pregnancies.
Deformations, like disruptions, also represent an extrinsic disturbance of development rather than an intrinsic error of morphogenesis. Deformations are common problems, affecting approximately 2% of newborn infants to various degrees. Fundamental to the pathogenesis of deformations is localized or generalized compression of the growing fetus by abnormal biomechanical forces, leading eventually to a variety of structural abnormalities. The most common cause of such deformations is uterine constraint. Between weeks 35 and 38 of gestation, rapid increase in the size of the fetus outpaces the growth of the uterus, and the relative amount of amniotic fluid (which normally acts as a cushion) also decreases. Thus, even the normal fetus is subjected to some degree of uterine constraint. However, several variables increase the likelihood of excessive compression of the fetus, including maternal conditions such as first pregnancy, small uterus, malformed (bicornuate) uterus, and leiomyomas. Causes relating to the fetus, such as presence of multiple fetuses, oligohydramnios, and abnormal fetal presentation, also may be involved."

Disruptions are also due to extrinsic disturbances, so the way FA formulates them leads to a bit of a misunderstanding. Deformation is the alteration of shape due to an extrinsic cause, like a misshapen bone. Disturbance is the destruction of a previously normally formed organ, due to an extrinsic cause again. Amniotic bands is the big example.

Okay, so in the case of deformation, the tissue is not previously normal? It sounds like normal tissue is being compressed.
 
Are you sure you arent talking about malformation with teratogens?

Malformation is an intrinsic disruption (e.g. non-migrating neural crest) during the embryonic period. Deformation is an extrinsic disruption (teratogen) during the fetal period. Disruption is breakdown of a normal tissue. Neither malformation nor deformation are "normal" tissues. And the difference between malformation and deformation is the time period in which they occur.
 
Malformation is an intrinsic disruption (e.g. non-migrating neural crest) during the embryonic period. Deformation is an extrinsic disruption (teratogen) during the fetal period. Disruption is breakdown of a normal tissue. Neither malformation nor deformation are "normal" tissues. And the difference between malformation and deformation is the time period in which they occur.
okay thanks!
 
Bump.
So whats the difference between deformation vs disruption vs distrubance?

Disruption = normal tissue -> abnormal tissue
Deformation = disruption after the embryonic period (extrinsic)
Malformation = disruption during the embryonic period (intrinsic)

Disturbance just the word they use for "something going wrong".
 
Top