Emeritus Medical School Prof. willing to mentor me for $$$$$

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

scifiguy13

New Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Dec 10, 2009
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
I recently met an emeritus professor of medicine from the UC school system who offered to become my "mentor" to help me get into medical school. At our first meeting he informed me that he charges for this service, and that total costs for his help would be in excess of $15,000. This would include one on one meetings weekly, interview coaching, help obtaining letters from UCD instructors, and a personal LOR from him. I was shocked, and wondered if anyone here had ever heard of such a thing before. I did some research on him, and he is who he claims to be. I just had no idea that he wanted payment for his mentoring.

Some background: I am a CA resident who graduated from UC Davis in 2008. I have applied twice to medical school since graduation,two interviews total, but not accepted. My stats are as follows:

3.70 GPA cum
3.65 GPA sciences
32M MCAT (13/9/10) [Expiring, will retake this fall]
Hospital volunteer since August 2011 (~150 hrs ongoing)
Plant growth regulator research, unpublished (~500 hrs over 14 months)
Flu shot clinic volunteer (~160 hrs over 3 years)
Shadowed 3 physicians (~ 24 hrs total)
Misc. 1 day health fairs (~16 hrs total)
Martial arts training (~6 hrs/week for 18 years) [extracurricular]

I had several people review my personal statement before I applied, and I feel that it was solid if not spectacular. What I believe hurt me the most were the following aspects of my application: I attended a local community college for my freshman and sophomore years before I transferred to UCD to complete my degree in Biochemistry, and I took several prerequisites at the CC. Also, my Letters of Recommendation were from those teachers and I did not seek out LOR aggressively enough at UCD. Lastly, I had few activities when I initially applied, and almost no volunteering, which I have worked on for the past year.

In the end, would it be worth it to utilize his aid in getting in? Or should I go it alone again, continuing to volunteer while I retake the MCAT and try to apply on my own? Any advice would be appreciated. Thanks.

scifiguy13

Members don't see this ad.
 
I recently met an emeritus professor of medicine from the UC school system who offered to become my "mentor" to help me get into medical school. At our first meeting he informed me that he charges for this service, and that total costs for his help would be in excess of $15,000. This would include one on one meetings weekly, interview coaching, help obtaining letters from UCD instructors, and a personal LOR from him. I was shocked, and wondered if anyone here had ever heard of such a thing before. I did some research on him, and he is who he claims to be. I just had no idea that he wanted payment for his mentoring.

Some background: I am a CA resident who graduated from UC Davis in 2008. I have applied twice to medical school since graduation,two interviews total, but not accepted. My stats are as follows:

3.70 GPA cum
3.65 GPA sciences
32M MCAT (13/9/10) [Expiring, will retake this fall]
Hospital volunteer since August 2011 (~150 hrs ongoing)
Plant growth regulator research, unpublished (~500 hrs over 14 months)
Flu shot clinic volunteer (~160 hrs over 3 years)
Shadowed 3 physicians (~ 24 hrs total)
Misc. 1 day health fairs (~16 hrs total)
Martial arts training (~6 hrs/week for 18 years) [extracurricular]

I had several people review my personal statement before I applied, and I feel that it was solid if not spectacular. What I believe hurt me the most were the following aspects of my application: I attended a local community college for my freshman and sophomore years before I transferred to UCD to complete my degree in Biochemistry, and I took several prerequisites at the CC. Also, my Letters of Recommendation were from those teachers and I did not seek out LOR aggressively enough at UCD. Lastly, I had few activities when I initially applied, and almost no volunteering, which I have worked on for the past year.

In the end, would it be worth it to utilize his aid in getting in? Or should I go it alone again, continuing to volunteer while I retake the MCAT and try to apply on my own? Any advice would be appreciated. Thanks.

scifiguy13

Holy crap 15000 dollars? To pay someone for something like this? I've never heard of this before. I'd say it wasn't worth it.
 
Seriously? He thinks his "services" are worth that much? This dude needs to get a life....

In other words, my answer is "no." It's not like is going to pull a bunch of strings and get you in.... At least not likely. I definitely wouldn't pay that much even if he were going to pull strings for me seeing as I could do a lot more with that money and get in on my own merit. You just need to figure out what happened and go from there. Maybe find a real mentor. Good mentors don't charge. 😉
 
Members don't see this ad :)
That's way too much, definitely not worth it. From the looks of it, the only thing of value you really get is an LOR from him. One on one meetings for, I'm guessing, general med school admissions info and your concerns, all of which can be addressed online through SDN and free raw data. Interview coaching is free at virtually any university (pay like $200 if you want the private stuff). You can get the LORs yourself, like the 40,000 other pre-meds.

Seriously, unless you or your family is really loaded, this seems like the dumbest thing to drop 15K on.
 
I had several people review my personal statement before I applied, and I feel that it was solid if not spectacular. What I believe hurt me the most were the following aspects of my application: I attended a local community college for my freshman and sophomore years before I transferred to UCD to complete my degree in Biochemistry, and I took several prerequisites at the CC. Also, my Letters of Recommendation were from those teachers and I did not seek out LOR aggressively enough at UCD. Lastly, I had few activities when I initially applied, and almost no volunteering, which I have worked on for the past year.

I can assure you that taking prereq at CC is NOT what killed your chances. Plenty people did that and plenty of them got in. I personally have 6 friends who took ALL the prereq at my CC and are all in medical schools. We are all CA residents also.
 
Besides the point people have made above about this being an exorbitant cost for such a service, the fact that part of his service includes writing you a LOR implies some really serious moral ambiguity. However deserving of a letter you may be, you'd essentially be paying him to write you one. Even if this service was reasonably priced I would still steer clear of this guy.
 
Besides the point people have made above about this being an exorbitant cost for such a service, the fact that part of his service includes writing you a LOR implies some really serious moral ambiguity. However deserving of a letter you may be, you'd essentially be paying him to write you one. Even if this service was reasonably priced I would still steer clear of this guy.

Well, unless if this guy is Sanjay Gupta, I probably wouldn't even take a free LOR from him, mainly because non professor/PI LORs aren't worth much at all, unless you've worked with the individual for a long time, and the writer has something truly meaningful to say.
 
I've seen high linkage postbacc/SMPs that are cheaper than $15K.

Does this guy think he can guarantee you entrance to a California school or something? Otherwise I can't imagine why he would charge soo much.
 
I've heard that taking prereqs at a CC really doesn't help your chances...FattySlug did you take your prereqs at a CC in california?
 
Members don't see this ad :)
am i the only one who thinks this way, but this professor should be ashamed...wow...ucd should be ashamed of their faculty...i never heard of mentoring costing money...
 
i bet the reason u r doing so poorly through these cycles was because u graduated from ucd...no offense, but the reputation of the school probably becomes a red flag when an emeritus professor is selling his services for mentoring...
 
Sounds like someone didn't plan for retirement well... don't do it. 1.) Its unethical, 2.) Its two too many zeros on his price, 3.) You don't need him. My short experience with SDN is that you can find all the information you need on here!
 
Well, unless if this guy is Sanjay Gupta, I probably wouldn't even take a free LOR from him, mainly because non professor/PI LORs aren't worth much at all, unless you've worked with the individual for a long time, and the writer has something truly meaningful to say.

Would you be surprised if it was? The guy is a opportunist who shamelessly self promotes.
 
This sounds an awful lot like a scam. Don't do it! You could likely get the same information you are looking for if you search through SDN!

Also, if you are willing to spend some money to increase your chances of getting in, it seems like the best thing to do is improve your app however you see fit and apply to a ton of schools. The application process is a huge expense in itself - if you are going to invest, invest wisely!
 
I see scam!
This isn't even a guaranteed... like he's using connections to buy you a seat or anything.
absurd. If your grades were like 3.2 and 24 or something, then it may be worth it.

Save your money and study your MCAT like a mad person trying to win $15,000 contest if he scored >35.
 
I'm just saying... if someone paid me $15,000, I would definitely be able to score >35... maybe I should have thought about this when I studied for my MCAT.
 
I'll tell you what's wrong with your application: you're from California.

I take cash or check.
 
Last edited:
I'll tell you what's wrong with you're application: you're from California.

I take cash or check.
perhaps that $15k is better well spent on relocating to another state, say Texas?
although that's kinda crazy too.

so you say!

I would like to think so.:laugh: but no way I'm retaking the MCAT...unless someone pays me $15k.
 
This one is a creative one OP... A disguised "What are my chances" with a provocative masking story.

You must be doing it right because I was suckered into reading most of it.

In the two previous cycles that you applied, did you take the time after cycle completion and ask schools how you may improve?
 
I am a CA resident who graduated from UC Davis in 2008. I have applied twice to medical school since graduation,two interviews total, but not accepted. My stats are as follows:

3.70 GPA cum
3.65 GPA sciences
32M MCAT (13/9/10) [Expiring, will retake this fall]
Hospital volunteer since August 2011 (~150 hrs ongoing)
Plant growth regulator research, unpublished (~500 hrs over 14 months)
Flu shot clinic volunteer (~160 hrs over 3 years)
Shadowed 3 physicians (~ 24 hrs total)
Misc. 1 day health fairs (~16 hrs total)
Martial arts training (~6 hrs/week for 18 years) [extracurricular]

I had several people review my personal statement before I applied, and I feel that it was solid if not spectacular. What I believe hurt me the most were the following aspects of my application: I attended a local community college for my freshman and sophomore years before I transferred to UCD to complete my degree in Biochemistry, and I took several prerequisites at the CC. Also, my Letters of Recommendation were from those teachers and I did not seek out LOR aggressively enough at UCD. Lastly, I had few activities when I initially applied, and almost no volunteering, which I have worked on for the past year.

Sounds like you already have things analyzed. Which/how many schools did you apply to. Did you talk to any of them to get their reasons for passing you over?
 
I recently met an emeritus professor of medicine from the UC school system who offered to become my "mentor" to help me get into medical school. At our first meeting he informed me that he charges for this service, and that total costs for his help would be in excess of $15,000.

Guess I now know what I am doing after retirement: Become a "med school coach"
 
15670436.jpg
 
Top