Formalin

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Gran Turismo

Junior Member
10+ Year Member
5+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Mar 28, 2005
Messages
15
Reaction score
0
I am just curious about this. How effective is formalin at inactivating HIV, HCV, HBV, TB, etc? Like does formalin kill HIV and HCV immediately or does it take like 24 hours etc? I really can't find anything on Pubmed. I think this is kinda interesting and important since we come into contact with this stuff so frequently. Also I was told that formalin doesn't do anything against prions, which makes total sense.
 
I don't think it has immediate effects. I haven't seen any studies but have heard people talk about the best way to do hep C autopsies is to leave everything in formalin for a day or two. So apparently, 24 hrs is reasonable. HIV is probably less. TB is pretty much wiped out in terms of contagion within a few hours unless it is buried within a cavity where formalin is not penetrating.
 
Gran Turismo said:
I am just curious about this. How effective is formalin at inactivating HIV, HCV, HBV, TB, etc? Like does formalin kill HIV and HCV immediately or does it take like 24 hours etc? I really can't find anything on Pubmed. I think this is kinda interesting and important since we come into contact with this stuff so frequently. Also I was told that formalin doesn't do anything against prions, which makes total sense.

Well I had an attending tell me that formalin fixes the HIV virus pretty much immediately. This is one reason alot of institutions won't gross their specimens in fresh. TB and HBV take a little longer I would think, but HCV (since RNA virus) would probably be similar to HIV. And yes, formalin won't do anything against CJD. I looked on pubmed too and couldn't find anything.
 
Zoloft said:
Well I had an attending tell me that formalin fixes the HIV virus pretty much immediately. This is one reason alot of institutions won't gross their specimens in fresh. TB and HBV take a little longer I would think, but HCV (since RNA virus) would probably be similar to HIV. And yes, formalin won't do anything against CJD. I looked on pubmed too and couldn't find anything.
Hypothetically, if you were to cut yourself on a completely fixed specimen are the risks dramatically decreased?
 
bananaface said:
Quick prion disease trivia question:

Which two animal species were infected by a variant of BSE by sharing a common watershed with cattle being used in a US government research project?
Where was this project located?
 
bananaface said:
It's been awhile since I read the report (which was removed from circulation, BTW). I want to say that it was in Nevada.
What sort of animals live in Nevada? 😕

Lemme guess. Prairie dogs. And lemmiwinks.
 
oh i hate it when i'm prairie doggin' or turtlin'. one of the worst feelings in life...usually signifies "go time"...you're a ticking time bomb and either you're going in your pants or somehow, miraculously you'll find a toilet (or a water fountain).
 
I have never heard this referred to as prairie doggin' or turtlin'. I wonder why it is called that. Or is this an AndyM original? :laugh:
 
deschutes said:
What is this "this"? Is it "it"? 😕

:laugh: Sorry, guess I got a little carried away with my pronouns.

Why is desperately having to poo called prairie doggin'?

Maybe I don't want to know. :laugh:
 
beary said:
:laugh: Sorry, guess I got a little carried away with my pronouns.

Why is desperately having to poo called prairie doggin'?

Maybe I don't want to know. :laugh:
no. deep down inside you DO wanna know. and thanks to me, you will be enlightened.

think about it...when you really gotta go and your rectal vault has reached maximum capacity, of course a portion of poo is gonna poke out and say "hello, how are you doing today? it's time to free willy...let's go!" this is similar to how a prairie dog pokes his/her head out of the ground or how turtle's head pokes out from the shell to greet you.
 
AndyMilonakis said:
no. deep down inside you DO wanna know. and thanks to me, you will be enlightened.

think about it...when you really gotta go and your rectal vault has reached maximum capacity, of course a portion of poo is gonna poke out and say "hello, how are you doing today? it's time to free willy...let's go!" this is similar to how a prairie dog pokes his/her head out of the ground or how turtle's head pokes out from the shell to greet you.

Ahh, I see. Thanks. :laugh: That makes sense I guess.
 
beary said:
Ahh, I see. Thanks. :laugh: That makes sense I guess.
see, that was a good laugh. now you must share this information with your labmates and bring joy and laughter into their day tomorrow.
 
AndyMilonakis said:
think about it...when you really gotta go and your rectal vault has reached maximum capacity, of course a portion of poo is gonna poke out
I got to this part and thought you were talking about a prairie dog pup presenting breech.
 
AndyMilonakis said:
see, that was a good laugh. now you must share this information with your labmates and bring joy and laughter into their day tomorrow.

I will! Tomorrow is my last official day in the lab. 🙁

I am determined to hang on to my desk and bench space though because I continue to live under the delusion that I am going to get all kinds of experiments done and manuscripts written in the next year!
 
deschutes said:
I got to this part and thought you were talking about a prairie dog pup presenting breech.
you really do have to stop sticking prairie dogs up your ass. please, spare your o-ring some grief.
 
beary said:
I will! Tomorrow is my last official day in the lab. 🙁

I am determined to hang on to my desk and bench space though because I continue to live under the delusion that I am going to get all kinds of experiments done and manuscripts written in the next year!
I will go to bed - and when I wake the sun will have risen on my Last Day Ever as a IM clerk.

Issues:
No discharges, no admissions.

Plan:
Leave at 5:30pm.
 
beary said:
I will! Tomorrow is my last official day in the lab. 🙁

I am determined to hang on to my desk and bench space though because I continue to live under the delusion that I am going to get all kinds of experiments done and manuscripts written in the next year!
yeah keep dreamin'...when you're on call admitting some kid with rotavirus-induced mudbutt, you ain't gonna have time for that.
 
deschutes said:
I will go to bed - and when I wake the sun will have risen on my Last Day Ever as a IM clerk.

Congrats deschutes!! :clap:

A bright pathology future lies ahead!
 
deschutes said:
I will go to bed - and when I wake the sun will have risen on my Last Day Ever as a IM clerk.

Issues:
No discharges, no admissions.

Plan:
Leave at 5:30pm.
and then you will go out, party, get trashed, etc. this will probably be one of your best weekends.
 
AndyMilonakis said:
yeah keep dreamin'...when you're on call admitting some kid with rotavirus-induced mudbutt, you ain't gonna have time for that.

Ugh... Hopefully I do not acquire rotavirus-induced mudbutt myself!
 
deschutes said:
Horses.... and zebras.

buffalo.... and wildebeest.

When I was little, I loved wildebeest because I thought their name was pronounced "wild beasties."
 
beary said:
Ugh... Hopefully I do not acquire rotavirus-induced mudbutt myself!
yeah...cuz then you'll be wishing that you could be prairie doggin'
 
deschutes said:
Wash. Hands. Always.

Thankfully I already practically have OCD about washing my hands. I bet that on peds this habit will become even more pronounced. 🙄
 
deschutes said:
Bison... and camels?

judging by the tests we run at work (state veterinary diagnostic lab)

I'd say deer/elk (chronic wasting disease) and sheep (scrapie)
 
njac said:
judging by the tests we run at work (state veterinary diagnostic lab)

I'd say deer/elk (chronic wasting disease) and sheep (scrapie)
You win with deer and elk/chronic wasting disease. Scrapie has been around for centuries. We seem to have created CWD. We suck! There are 2 suspected cases of transmission to humans.
 
bananaface said:
You win with deer and elk/chronic wasting disease. Scrapie has been around for centuries. We seem to have created CWD. We suck! There are 2 suspected cases of transmission to humans.

wow - we have CWD in New Mexico. Mostly southern part of the state it seems.

But I love my job! Our last neurological steer actually had a fresh skull fracture and an old cervical compression. Poor little cow.
 
Yeah supposedly it was picked up by the native deer and elk like 2 years after some BSE infected cattle being used for experiments had peed in the water supply. That does not make me want to live anywhere near a cattle farm, given the lack of a species barrier. Hooray for urban sprawl!
 
makes sense - but gross.

wow.
 
Yeah I read some papers on it in an infections disease class on it last year. Those papers disappeared from the CDC database and the agencies involved are no longer releasing related information. You know the public would freak the hell out about it if the media got wind of it.
 
bananaface said:
Yeah I read some papers on it in an infections disease class on it last year. Those papers disappeared from the CDC database and the agencies involved are no longer releasing related information. You know the public would freak the hell out about it if the media got wind of it.

yeah we used to ship out our CWD samples but we've just gotten the stuff to test it ourselves - I totally want to ask our head pathologist about this. Then again, he is an old cwoboy who gives me **** for buying anything organic. Particularly organic meat products, but stuff like this makes me even more sure of farmers who know where their cows have been and what they eat.
 
njac said:
yeah we used to ship out our CWD samples but we've just gotten the stuff to test it ourselves - I totally want to ask our head pathologist about this. Then again, he is an old cwoboy who gives me **** for buying anything organic. Particularly organic meat products, but stuff like this makes me even more sure of farmers who know where their cows have been and what they eat.
Well, for a long time "organic" was an unregulated phrase. I can see why some people have stayed pessimistic. You are probably ok with beef as long as you don't eat any brain, spinal tissue, or marrow (ie: avoid ground stuff) We have no clue where our beef cattle have been in this country, organic or non. No one gave a rip about record keeping before the Mabton case, as BSE was viewed as entirely a European problem. If you are really worried, eat more chicken. There is a species barrier that prevents us from getting prion diseases that affect chicken and sheep. But, who the **** eats mutton in the US?

I heard talk of ~1/4 of "alzheimer's" patients really having prion related disorders. Anyone else hear about that?
 
bananaface said:
I heard talk of ~1/4 of "alzheimer's" patients really having prion related disorders. Anyone else hear about that?
Alzheimer's is a diagnosis of exclusion, so the Dx is only as good as the efforts taken to exclude everything else. Prion disease is possible (though I am guessing not probable) - many things can mimic Alzheimer's. 1/4 seems a little high to me, but then again I am not a pathologist... yet.
 
It seems like some clinicians are trigger happy to jump on Alzheimer's as a diagnosis, even though it is a dx of exclusion. I mean, think about it. There are many things that can make you go "dehhhhhh" and Alzheimer's is only one of them.
 
Top