- Joined
- May 10, 2005
- Messages
- 29
- Reaction score
- 0
If you were in at both schools, where would you go? And why?
mbadoc said:GWU, doesn't have the same stigma that NYMC has on SDN.
cl24000 said:If you were in at both schools, where would you go? And why?
medstylee said:hey guys. i wanted to revisit this issue.
i may be in the same position as cl2400 in the near future - currently accepted to nymc and i've just been notified that i am at the top of gw's alternate list (and they will def be accepting alternates this year, i'm told).
i know a lot about both schools and i've met a lot of students at both as well (i was a student in georgetown's smp program, so that'll explain it). i was wondering what people thought of the student bodies and the social scenes.
from what i gather, nymc students seem to be very social and like to party. it almost seemed kind of like a college social scene, drinking in dorms, etc. on the other hand, students at gw seemed a little more adult (note: i'm not saying nymc students are immature). i guess that has a lot to do with the fact that they are more spread out around d.c. & nova while nymc students are mostly grouped together in the dorms. (note: i know nymc students disperse to nyc after 2nd year, but i'm focusing on 1st/2nd year here).
anyway, that's my take on things. anyone else care to chime in? it'd be great to hear from current students. thanks.
medstylee said:hey guys. i wanted to revisit this issue.
i may be in the same position as cl2400 in the near future - currently accepted to nymc and i've just been notified that i am at the top of gw's alternate list (and they will def be accepting alternates this year, i'm told).
i know a lot about both schools and i've met a lot of students at both as well (i was a student in georgetown's smp program, so that'll explain it). i was wondering what people thought of the student bodies and the social scenes.
from what i gather, nymc students seem to be very social and like to party. it almost seemed kind of like a college social scene, drinking in dorms, etc. on the other hand, students at gw seemed a little more adult (note: i'm not saying nymc students are immature). i guess that has a lot to do with the fact that they are more spread out around d.c. & nova while nymc students are mostly grouped together in the dorms. (note: i know nymc students disperse to nyc after 2nd year, but i'm focusing on 1st/2nd year here).
anyway, that's my take on things. anyone else care to chime in? it'd be great to hear from current students. thanks.
idq1i said:Chime in on what? Got any specific q's? I didn't apply to GW, but I'm an MIII @NYMC
Pros:
Great board prep + excellent prep for clinical years. It's all about your board scores when you apply to residencies
Excellent match list. Our new one should be posted soon. PM me if you have specific q's
Great, sociable bunch of students (with few exceptions, of course)
Hospital associations that give you plenty of opportunities no matter what you like
Good teaching faculty with some truly phenomenal instructors
On-campus housing
Cons:
$$$$$$$
I don't care much for our academic support administration. You can get what you need out of them, but you'll hate to WORK HARD AT IT
Bigger research push wouldn't hurt
I won't dignify the "stigma" comments with a response
BOBODR said:How do you feel about your rotations?
Are you learning what you need to,
do you like having to go to many different hospitals,
do you have adequate patient responsibility?
Are you learning from good mentors?
Any complaints about them?>
idq1i said:Chime in on what? Got any specific q's? I didn't apply to GW, but I'm an MIII @NYMC
Pros:
Great board prep + excellent prep for clinical years. It's all about your board scores when you apply to residencies
Excellent match list. Our new one should be posted soon. PM me if you have specific q's
Great, sociable bunch of students (with few exceptions, of course)
Hospital associations that give you plenty of opportunities no matter what you like
Good teaching faculty with some truly phenomenal instructors
On-campus housing
Cons:
$$$$$$$
I don't care much for our academic support administration. You can get what you need out of them, but you'll hate to WORK HARD AT IT
Bigger research push wouldn't hurt
I won't dignify the "stigma" comments with a response
medstylee said:hey, thanks for the input, idq. i'm curious about how you felt about the workload at nymc. talking to my friends who currently attend, it seems like you guys are absolutely bombarded with exams. obviously that has a lot to do with the school's great success on the boards. but, it just seems like my nymc friends are way more stressed about med school than my friends who attend other schools.
also, what's the deal with the social fraternity that was just formed by students? i was in a fraternity in college and had a great time, but i'm older now and not really looking for that in medical school. maybe i'm just being an old fart, but i'm curious as to how that fits into the social scene at nymc.
where i'm at right now, i feel like i might very well get better board preparation and better scores at nymc. but, i have a feeling i'll fit in a lot better as a student at gw. it also seems that gw has a lot more opportunities for students outside of just the core med curriculum. anyway, i'm getting ahead of myself since i haven't even gotten into gw. ha. let's keep this discussion rolling. thanks again for the input.