dl9006

10+ Year Member
5+ Year Member
Jul 2, 2008
541
1
Status
Dental Student
Can Haloform reaction(reagents: I2,OH-) occur with methanal?

How about with Acetone?

Or does this reaction exclusively occur with methyl ketones?

thanks!
 

The Anhedonia

Winner Winner Chicken Dinner
10+ Year Member
Feb 18, 2009
999
435
Boston
Status
Resident [Any Field]
the other name for this reaction is the "methyl ketone test", so i don't think you can use other compounds as the chemistry would change.
 
OP
dl9006

dl9006

10+ Year Member
5+ Year Member
Jul 2, 2008
541
1
Status
Dental Student
the other name for this reaction is the "methyl ketone test", so i don't think you can use other compounds as the chemistry would change.
would you happen to know why acetone wouldn't react?

It is a ketone with 2 methyl on its side.
 
May 22, 2009
341
0
Status
Dental Student
Can Haloform reaction(reagents: I2,OH-) occur with methanal?

How about with Acetone?

Or does this reaction exclusively occur with methyl ketones?

thanks!

I was searching threads about haloform. And so I guess I'll answer here what I've found out.

Haloforms will form with any substance as long as it has a methyl attached to a carbonyl (methyl ketones, or ethanal) or any secondary alcohol that can be oxidized to that because the reagents would do that for you (so secondary alcohols that have a methyl group attached to the carbon that has OH attached to it and ethanol)

So Methanal (formaldehyde) doesn't work because there is no CH3 attached to the carbonyl. Acetone should give you a positive result though.