Harriet Lane?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

elr1983

Full Member
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Jun 30, 2008
Messages
171
Reaction score
1
So I recently decided on going into pediatrics, and want to purchase a Harriet Lane Handbook for use 4th year and in residency. (Most of my 4th year is in peds so I think it will be handy to have then, too.) Anyhow, amazon has 2 versions available...the 17th edition (http://www.amazon.com/Harriet-Lane-...bs_sr_2?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1215894753&sr=1-2) and the 18th edition that will be released in a few days (http://www.amazon.com/Harriet-Lane-...bs_sr_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1215894753&sr=1-1). Did most of you new ms4's/interns just purchase the 17th ed or are you waiting for the 18th ed? Do you think you'd use the online "searchable" feature of the 18th ed? Thanks for the help!
 
Don't buy it. Most, if not all, residents in the US will get a free harriet lane from the drug companies during residency.

Ah, those tricky drug companies. I kind of want it for my upcoming rotations, though....plus, I feel a little dirty taking things from drug reps.
 
Your 4th year will be all about interviews and taking some time off. You will likely manage fine without it during your fourth year. And you will likely get a copy from a drug rep pretty early on.
 
Plus there's almost always a Harriet Lane lying around on the Peds Floor that you can use....
But if you insist on buying one, just wait for the new on to come out on July 18th
 
Ah, those tricky drug companies. I kind of want it for my upcoming rotations, though....plus, I feel a little dirty taking things from drug reps.

Just an interesting aside. At my program, we were given Harriet Lane Handbooks by a rep from one of the infant formula companies. Do the people who oppose drug reps consider Carnation Good Start marketing reps and other baby formula reps as "evil" as drug reps? Most of the formulas (milk/soy) seem to have pretty much the same nutrient content with different brand names (not talking about the more specialized formulas), so does it really matter if you take a Harriet Lane from Nestle? I mean, some hospitals have contracts with Coca Cola or Pepsi so you can only get a certain type of soda in the cafeteria. Isn't this kinda the same thing?
 
Just an interesting aside. At my program, we were given Harriet Lane Handbooks by a rep from one of the infant formula companies. Do the people who oppose drug reps consider Carnation Good Start marketing reps and other baby formula reps as "evil" as drug reps? Most of the formulas (milk/soy) seem to have pretty much the same nutrient content with different brand names (not talking about the more specialized formulas), so does it really matter if you take a Harriet Lane from Nestle? I mean, some hospitals have contracts with Coca Cola or Pepsi so you can only get a certain type of soda in the cafeteria. Isn't this kinda the same thing?

Yeah, I'm not really "anti-drug company" or think drug reps are necessarily "evil." I kind of meant "those tricky drug reps" to have a more casual tone...and I definitely get annoyed with people who treat drug reps poorly. So I don't want you to think I'm one of "those" people who think they're better than everyone else. 🙂

That aside, I do sometimes think gifts from drug reps can become excessive and inappropriate. I think that for me, and I would wager just about anyone, would be lying if they said that they absolutely weren't influenced at all, ever, by gifts from drug reps. I guess the problem for me is it's hard for me to draw the line between what's too much....so, I try not to accept anything, if I can possible help it. But, that's just me.

As far as gifts from other sorts of companies, like formula companies, again, I tend not to accept them for similar reasons. I mean, it's something I can buy on my own, so I don't really see the reason to get it from a company trying to get me to sell something for them. True, I probably wouldn't be very influenced, and in fact, would maybe even forget the name of the company. But again, I find it difficult to draw a line between what's OK and what's too much, so I tend to err on the side of accepting nothing.
 
Top