• Bring your 2026 application questions to our open office hours with Emil Chuck, PhD, Director of Advising Services for HPSA, and get them answered live. Personal statements, secondaries, interview prep, school list strategy. Sunday, May 17 at 9 p.m. Eastern.

Help deciding between two different SMPs

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

MedicallyEnthused

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Hello all,

I recently have been accepted to a few SMPs and am having a really hard time deciding between two programs that I am seriously considering. I am waiting on a few others (that I will take over these two), but it's unlikely I will get accepted - they are a lot more competitive - Temple ACMS and Cincinnati.

Anyways the two programs I got into are New York Medical College Interdisciplinary Basic Medical Sciences (2 year track) and Rutgers University (Newark) Medical Scholars Biomedical Science Program. Below are some pros and cons I came up with, but any input assisting in deciding would be very helpful!

New York Medical College:

Pros:

-Conditional Interview to NYMC SOM, as well as 2 associated DO schools (Touro university) - 506 MCAT and 3.4 GPA in the program.
-Master's courses closely mirrors the 1st year of med school curriculum and is taught my faculty from the school of medicine - Program director told me there is about 90% overlap on average (depending on the course).
-Discounted MCAT Kaplan Course (If my retake this summer doesn't work out).
-Very small class size (around 30ish students).
-More structured curriculum.
-Opportunities for research (outside of curriculum) --> I'm going with the more didactic track
-Extremely inclusive (more so than the average medical school)

Cons:
-2 years long (I don't think this will affect my overall timeline, as I intend to apply to medical school after the 1st year).
-Literature review during 2nd year.
-More expensive cost of living.
-Slightly more expensive tuition (over entire program).

Rutgers University (Newark):

Pros:

-Conditional Interview to New Jersey Medical School - 508 MCAT and 3.6 GPA in the program.
-1 year long.
-Option to take actual medical school courses (limited enrollment).
-Some of the master's courses are similar to medical school courses - I don't think the master's courses are taught by SOM faculty though.
-Discounted Uworld subscription (If my retake this summer doesn't work out).
-Some research part of the curriculum.
-Volunteer opportunities available.
-Cheaper tuition (over entire program).
-Cheaper cost of living.

Cons:
-Master's courses are more commonly late in the evenings, only once a week.
-Larger class size.
-More flexible curriculum and part time option (This could be a pro, but I consider a con for what I am looking for).


Any and all help/suggestions would be greatly appreciated, thank you very much!
 
Last edited: