I totally agree. Someone from the admissions committee at one of the schools I applied to gave me a really good advice: trust your gut. If you are still having problems deciding after having looked at the strengths and weaknesses of each school, just trust your gut. That's it. In which school did you feel most comfortable when you went to your interviews? Could you see yourself excelling in such an environment? The faculty, staff, and students... were they nice? Did they make you feel welcome? How did you like the neighborhood? and so forth... Thinking about these things may help with your decision.
Like SubieGuy mentioned before, you're going to get a great education and become a solid optometrist no matter which school you attend, provided that you have the desire, motivation and initiative. Nevertheless, by choosing a school that feels "right" to you, so to speak, the next four years of your life may be a lot easier. I hope that helps. Good luck with your decision!