Help: Post-Bacc vs. Off-Shore

well I'm in a similar position with you, you have to decide. If your young (under the age of 25) and determined to get a nice (prestige) residency you should do your best at going to US Allopathic school or DO, if your in a rush, I would say go to the "Big 4" Ross St. George come to mind, I forgot the other 2 Anyways you have to be prepared to work hard under either circumstance, if you go to the carribean be prepared to workd your *** off, because many of these schools have attrition rates, even at the big four, and at most you will get family practie or Internal medicine residency(and to name a other few, go to their website and check their residency appointments!) and you will be in debt. However if you want family practice or IM, you shouldn't have a problem going to the carribean and getting things done. hope this helps

 

While it is an option, it should be your last choice. You should exhaust all other options before settling for the carribean. I vote for the Drexel program.

It would be good to know a bit more about your situation. What is your GPA and MCAT.

The Carribean is notorious for terrible attrition rates, poor board pass rates (after you take into consideration they make you pass an exam before they let you sit for the boards), and poor match rates. Furthermore, those that do match dont exactly get their choice residency. I have heard- "but look at SGUs match list. It is so strong."

So I looked at it and looked at competitive specialties

This years SGU match list includes: 0 derm, 0 optho, 0 uro, 0 vascular surg, 0 neurosurg, 0 plastics and 0 ENT. It only includes 1 rads, 1 rad onc and 3 ortho. It includes about 12 GAS (moderately competitive)

To compare a to a middle of the road Allo program (unranked):
2 uro, 1 optho, 2 neuro surg, 3 plastics, 3 ENT, 14 rads, 1 radonc, 4 ortho, 14 gas.

Side by side that is
0 vs 2 uro
0 vs 1 optho
0 vs 2 neurosurg
0 vs 3 plastics
0 vs 3 ENT
1 vs 14 rads
1 vs 1 radonc
1 vs 4 ortho
12 vs 13 gas

Keep in mind though that SGU graduates over 450 students. Those are pretty crappy match stats when 4/450 are matching into competitive specialties. For reference the allo school listed graduates about 1/3 that many students.

A difference of <1% get competitive residencies at SGU vs almost 20% get the most selective residencies at the US school.

Furthermore, even if you opt for internal medicine (relatively noncompetitive) your choices from the carribean will be much more limited when compared to your choices from a US school. This is impt if you have a specific location in mind.

So the carribean, while it is a pathway to becoming a doctor, is not a good option until you have exhausted all others.

 

I was told by the Residency Director for Psychiatry at at University medical center to, "Never go to a Caribbean medical school."

He went on to explain that it is something that stays with you forever, so don't do it. Now this is just one residency director's opinion, but good to take into account anyways.

Personally I don't see anything wrong with the education, the only problem is the stigma and obstacles you have coming back into the US. So, whose to say whether those obstacles and stigma will always be there. I dunno, tough call. Without knowing your stats, I'd recommend Drexel first and save the Caribbean as a last resort.