- Joined
- Jul 9, 2009
- Messages
- 366
- Reaction score
- 0
How do 100 hours of clinical experience (volunteering + shadowing) compare to other applicants? Just want to get an idea of where I am at.
How do 100 hours of clinical experience (volunteering + shadowing) compare to other applicants? Just want to get an idea of where I am at.
How do 100 hours of clinical experience (volunteering + shadowing) compare to other applicants? Just want to get an idea of where I am at.
shadowing is separate and in my opinion less important. You will probably want at least a year volunteering weekly (3-4 hours a week).How do 100 hours of clinical experience (volunteering + shadowing) compare to other applicants? Just want to get an idea of where I am at.
shadowing is separate and in my opinion less important. You will probably want at least a year volunteering weekly (3-4 hours a week).
How do 100 hours of clinical experience (volunteering + shadowing) compare to other applicants? Just want to get an idea of where I am at.
Thanks for the input guys. Also, my experiences (w/ both shadowing and volunteering) are all about 20-25 hours each. In other words, I have many activities that I did for a short period of time rather than a few activities for a long period of time. Most of the 20 hour activities involved about 2 months of total time. I have heard some people say that schools want to see continuity in these experiences. Is this true?
Thanks for the input guys. Also, my experiences (w/ both shadowing and volunteering) are all about 20-25 hours each. In other words, I have many activities that I did for a short period of time rather than a few activities for a long period of time. Most of the 20 hour activities involved about 2 months of total time. I have heard some people say that schools want to see continuity in these experiences. Is this true?
I do that in 2 months...
yeesh, thats like 12 hours a week lol.
I had about 15 hours of shadowing, 500+ hours working in a physician's office, and 2000+ hours working in a hospital. Volunteering in a clinical setting... I had about 150 hours, but I volunteered lots outside of a clinical setting.
As others have said, though, it's about quality, not quantity. I could easily throw out half of my working hours as meaningless, because I didn't do much to give me a good idea of the medical field. It was grunge work. I certainly could have had more 'shadowing' hours, but I got a lot of experience working with doctors in the hospital, so that helped out a ton. My volunteering in the clinical setting was almost completely meaningless... the only thing that I got out of it was a desire to work with kids, but I honestly spent most of my time reading.
Why in gods name would you do spend that much time doing that... On another note, it is interesting how times change. I know some very successful doctors in my family, as well as some family friends, who essentially did no volunteering or clinical and easily got into med school back in the day(20 years ago)
Holy crap how can you guys have 2000 hours!? Does that include high school volunteering? Even if that's 3 years of college that's ~13 hours every single week. Do you have jobs? I can't imagine another 13 hours on top of my normal school load.
Holy crap how can you guys have 2000 hours!? Does that include high school volunteering? Even if that's 3 years of college that's ~13 hours every single week. Do you have jobs? I can't imagine another 13 hours on top of my normal school load.
Yea. I think many are beginning to become too obsessed with numbers. After a while I'm sure most ADCOMS just grin at these excessive numbers. The need to express hours instead of years proves so. A learning experience is for learning...not for accumulating stats and boasting. I have no problem with the "enthusiasm" of most posters here but I think most are forgetting that med schools want originals, not duplicates. If you go through 5000 apps and all say 100000+ hours clinical, 6604342+ volunteering/non clinical hours don't you think you would just pick the joe smoe who has been involved in something unique/interesting and has remained diligent over several years as a good student ( with lets say 3.7 & 35R)? Just my take....
Holy crap how can you guys have 2000 hours!? Does that include high school volunteering? Even if that's 3 years of college that's ~13 hours every single week. Do you have jobs? I can't imagine another 13 hours on top of my normal school load.
Seriously? I sometimes worked 30 hours a week during undergrad, and also dedicated 10 additional hours a week to research, and I was a chemistry major.
Apparently your chemistry major was not nearly as time consuming as some people's majors. I literally could not physically fit that much time into my schedule if I tried, I'm sure there are other people like me.
Yea. I think many are beginning to become too obsessed with numbers. After a while I'm sure most ADCOMS just grin at these excessive numbers. The need to express hours instead of years proves so. A learning experience is for learning...not for accumulating stats and boasting. I have no problem with the "enthusiasm" of most posters here but I think most are forgetting that med schools want originals, not duplicates. If you go through 5000 apps and all say 100000+ hours clinical, 6604342+ volunteering/non clinical hours don't you think you would just pick the joe smoe who has been involved in something unique/interesting and has remained diligent over several years as a good student ( with lets say 3.7 & 35R)? Just my take....
Holy crap how can you guys have 2000 hours!? Does that include high school volunteering? Even if that's 3 years of college that's ~13 hours every single week. Do you have jobs? I can't imagine another 13 hours on top of my normal school load.
Haha, I don't think most of us w/ those kids of hours actually count. At least I don't, but if people are asking about hours, I'll give an approximate number. It happens to be large because I work as a healthcare professional while going to school. If you're doing 1000s of hours for an adcom, you're a fool, but as a job, it's great.
We're not talking about volunteering here. This is actually work in a clinical environment (hospital, ambo, clinic, etc.). Working will always get you the highest quality clinical experience (almost without exception), so I highly recommend it if you can get a clinical job. Volunteering, I have a few hundred that have been steadily gained over a few years.
I went to a seriously tough school for undergrads - Jesuit universities don't mess around.
That being said, it's all about how you manage your time, etc. Just because you refuse to make time for a job and/or research doesn't mean it isn't possible.
I agree with this. Like he/she said when you're getting paid by the hour the more the better.Haha, I don't think most of us w/ those amounts of hours actually count. At least I don't, but if people are asking about hours, I'll give an approximate number (i.e., ~2000 hrs/yr*# yrs full-time). It happens to be large because I work as a healthcare professional while going to school. If you're doing 1000s of hours for an adcom, you're a fool, but as a job, it's great.
We're not talking about volunteering here. This is actual work in a clinical environment (hospital, ambo, clinic, etc.). Working will always get you the highest quality clinical experience (almost without exception), so I highly recommend it if you can get a clinical job. Volunteering, I have a few hundred that have been steadily gained over a few years.
I went to a seriously tough school for undergrads - Jesuit universities don't mess around.
That being said, it's all about how you manage your time, etc. Just because you refuse to make time for a job and/or research doesn't mean it isn't possible.
No. It literally isn't possible. Try taking ChemE Thermodynamics, Physical Chem, PChem Lab, Transport Phenomena, and Bioprocess Engineering at the same time. Each class averages 15 hours of homework, outside of class, per week. I mean, sure, you could always not do homework -- that's what my classmates who don't want good grades do so that they can work -- but I don't think this is a forum for that group of people.
This is one of those situations where you really don't know how easy you had it until you've had it hard. I would compare my semester to medical school--it is definitely more time consuming (and conceptually difficult), according to all of the med students I know who came from my program.
No. It literally isn't possible. Try taking ChemE Thermodynamics, Physical Chem, PChem Lab, Transport Phenomena, and Bioprocess Engineering at the same time. Each class averages 15 hours of homework, outside of class, per week. I mean, sure, you could always not do homework -- that's what my classmates who don't want good grades do so that they can work -- but I don't think this is a forum for that group of people.
This is one of those situations where you really don't know how easy you had it until you've had it hard. I would compare my semester to medical school--it is definitely more time consuming (and conceptually difficult), according to all of the med students I know who came from my program.
Agreed on the job part. As a volunteer, especially in a hospital, there's a pretty severe limit on the things you'll be "permitted" to do, since you're not a paid employee. I worked in an Emergency Room throughout undergrad, and when we had a volunteer, I was pretty much in charge of giving them tasks to do, and it was always pretty menial, crappy tasks - like cutting labels or re-arranging my file cabinet. You're way better off getting a part-time job to get serious clinical experience.
How do 100 hours of clinical experience (volunteering + shadowing) compare to other applicants? Just want to get an idea of where I am at.
I understand where you're coming from, but trust me - it's always possible. I took PChem (Quantum mechanics, mind you) and lab, Biochemistry, with lab, and Neuroscience all in one semester. I still found a way to get my homework done, do my research, and pull at least 2 shifts a week at the hospital.
PS: P Chem I is thermodynamics, so explain that to me, please.
I think I get where you are coming from, but you will be surprised by what you can do if you have to. Also, when you need to you get good at scheduling your classes to avoid being overloaded. For example, from the classes you listed it would also be possible to take the hardest one over the summer to ease the load a bit.
I'm sure there is at least 1 nut at your school, in your major that is also working and rocking his classes (there always is). However, I would agree that some majors (chemistry, engineering, physics, math) are harder than others.
I'd say it is noteworthy, though, that outside a hospital (i.e., at a free clinic), volunteers often get great jobs -- sometimes even similar to what an ER Tech or RN/LPN would do in the ED (minus the things requiring a license, such as IVs).
To the PS: PChem I is basic, easy thermodynamics. I'm talking makes-half-the-remaining-class-drop-out CHEMICAL ENGINEERING thermodynamics. Like PChem I on crack x 2.
The PChem I'm talking about in the previous post this semester is Quantum. The Lab is both semesters combined and quantum heavy.
"PChem (Quantum mechanics, mind you) and lab, Biochemistry, with lab, and Neuroscience all in one semester"
While this does sound like your average "difficult" semester, I must be honest that there is no comparison between that semester and what I'm discussing.
I'm not trying to put you down. Chemistry majors are smart people. But when you tell someone that they should be able to fit 40 hours of stuff into their schedule, you really have no clue how time consuming some undergrad majors can be -- you've simply not experienced it. I'm not saying we're better. My life sucks this semester and I envy my Chem friends. Just don't assume that everyone has as much free time as you do/did.
I AM that nut. None of my classes are available over the summer or in other semesters (all are prereq's for next semester).
Why in gods name would you do spend that much time doing that... On another note, it is interesting how times change. I know some very successful doctors in my family, as well as some family friends, who essentially did no volunteering or clinical and easily got into med school back in the day(20 years ago)
We're not talking about volunteering here. This is actual work in a clinical environment (hospital, ambo, clinic, etc.). Working will always get you the highest quality clinical experience (almost without exception), so I highly recommend it if you can get a clinical job. Volunteering, I have a few hundred that have been steadily gained over a few years.
My oldest brother is a chem engineer - he had plenty of time to do things he "wanted" with his friends, etc. He easily could've used that free time to work or volunteer if he so chose to, but he didn't.
There is always time. End of story.
Apparently your chemistry major was not nearly as time consuming as some people's majors. I literally could not physically fit that much time into my schedule if I tried, I'm sure there are other people like me.
Your oldest brother must have had a more reasonable schedule and cared less about grades (unless he's pre-med/phd, he's probably cool with C's like most engineers). I don't know how else to get through to you. There is not always time. It literally is not possible, period.
Yea my dentist said he didn't do any volunteering/shadowing
I tried to get a job at 2 different doctor's offices but didn't get called back. How did you go about getting your jobs?
However, the majority of pre-meds do have the time to do the the types of hours and commitments previously discussed.
This is what I'm wondering. Right now the only people with A's in my chem class are the seven year med program students, me and maybe one other kid. My bio course had a 60% drop out rate! I just don't see how I could possibly have added 15-30 hours of working a job this semester.
Yeah I agree on that point. Maybe not the majority, but there is a good number. I dunno, just kinda ticked off with how much crap I have to do this week lol (finishing my heat exchanger design in between posts plus more pchem to do). I'll be much happier in 2.5 weeks 😀
Honestly? Persistence. I just kept at it. I got certified as EMT-B later and that helped me get a job in the hospital (although the position doesn't require an EMT; they do all their medical training in-house but it made for a nice conversation piece during my interview and probably made the manager feel a bit more comfortable putting me on her unit).
I think the keys to my success in getting positions were 1) having an internship first, 2) getting a degree (yeah...that helps, although it alone won't do it and it's not necessary for some clinical positions, although my current one requires a related BA/BS because I actually write and administer treatment plans), and 3) persistence and a willingness to go outside the box (i.e., my first paid clinical job wasn't at a hospital; it was working w/ long-term care in a residential environment).
lol...too true. I was really tempted to respond "I do that in 2 weeks" but then... nah. 100 hrs is fine over a period of time, though. If you volunteer 4 hrs/wk for 6 mos, you'll end up w/ ~100 hrs and that's a decent enough commitment if your work involves high-quality pt care. Of course, I'd still argue that you don't really know what you're doing in a job for at least the first 200-300 hours (hence why most jobs give a 3-mos full-time "probationary training period"). According to Malcolm Gladwell (I believe...) it takes 10,000 hours of practice before a person typically reaches mastery of a subject area.
Yours and everyone else's. Pre-med courses, especially, are designed to weed out those who can't handle it.
But just because you can't imagine handling that kind of load doesn't mean it's not possible. I find it hard to believe that you don't have any free time on your hands - there's no way that you spend every waking hour on weekends studying, especially since you're probably just a freshman or sophomore (based on the "1991" in your forum name).
Either way, I started working during my second semester as an undergrad, and I kept it up. Every once in a blue moon I would take a vacation or sick day to study, if there was a particularly rough exam coming up, but I pretty much always managed.
I went to a Tier 1 university, not a community college, so the material certainly wasn't "easy," as you seem to imply.
So did you graduate college and then apply to med school later after doing all this work at the hospital?
I called both places bath a couple of times but never really got any calls back, the only things available were like file-storing and whatnot, which I'd be fine with because I could still say I worked in a doctor's office, but they didn't call back. Now I think I might be a waiter over the summer lol