You'll get more and better info on the osteopathic forum.
Anyway, I'm an MSII at LECOM-FL and have lived here in Sarasota my whole life other than college. First off, no offense but to let the prospect of hurricanes effect your decision to live here or not is pretty ridiculous. The media likes to sensationalize them and the occasional big ones like Katrina and Andrew give them great ammo unfortunately. This area has not been hit in 50 years. Besides, Katrina was bad because New Orleans is a bowl.
This school, if you're not aware, is completely a problem-based learning curriculum (PBL). It is the reason I came here. You only have lecture the first semester of first year for anatomy/histology/embryology/neuroanatomy. The rest of your education during the first 2 years takes place through a wonderful process. The class is broken up into groups of 8 and you meet with this group along with a faculty member "facilitator" twice a week. At these meetings you move through clinical cases - starting off with a sheet of paper saying "John Doe presents to your office complaining of swelling in his legs and feet" for example and progressing through a complete history and physical, lab test results, imaging studies etc. As a group you delve into the basic sciences in this clinical context to move through the cases and establish "learning issues" which you study at home from the textbooks. After a group of 8 cases each group has an individualized exam based on their selected learning issues that pertained to the cases. If this all sounds good to you, LECOM-FL is for you.
As for the area - the school is in Lakewood Ranch which is a new development east of Sarasota/Bradenton. A few years ago it was all cow pasture and wetlands - it has been developing at breakneck speed (fastest growing housing market in the country) and is now full of $400k houses, country clubs and restaurants. The school is located on the northern edge of this development. It is about 25 minutes from the beach. I would very highly recommend living in south Lakewood Ranch or Sarasota as opposed to Bradenton (south Lakewood Ranch's mailing address is currently still Bradenton, but will undoubtedly change in the next couple of years).
The student body is laid back and friendly and the faculty are devoted and accessible.