How much better would I have to do to justify retaking if I got a 34 O (12/11/11) on my first attempt?
Not worth it. Chances are very, very good you will do WORSE, not better.
How much better would I have to do to justify retaking if I got a 34 O (12/11/11) on my first attempt?
Well that depends on your GPA. Take a look at the AAMC MCAT/GPA matriculation table: https://www.aamc.org/download/157450/data/table24-mcatgpagridall2008-10.pdf.pdf
If you have a high GPA (3.6+) , your chances of acceptance are increased by about 3.7-5.5% if you score between a 36-45. So probably not worth taking it.
If your GPA is around 3.2-3.59, you can increase your odds of acceptance by 5.7-12.5%. Potentially worth it if you're sure you can score higher and your GPA is so so. Just make sure you don't score lower on your next MCAT.
Personally, I think a 34O is a solid MCAT score and would have been thrilled had I gotten that. But then again, it's your call. Good luck! 🙂
Yeah. My GPA is a 3.27 overall, and I think my math and science GPA is barely above a 3. So as long as I can improve to a 37 or so I would assume it would be worthwhile to retake it. I'm pretty sure I can increase my score- I just wondered if I would have to get in the 40's to make it worth it, because it seems really touch and go with the upper level scores- one question can drop you a whole point, and I might get unlucky.
Truth is -- if you don't get in with a 34, a 36 or even a 40 is likely to make little difference. Keep in mind that it's never one thing that keeps you out. Your GPA is pretty low, so that along w/ another weakness may keep you out, but your MCAT is already high and balanced. Chances are good that you won't improve and may actually do worse. Esp. considering your either poor performance all 4 yrs or your inconsistent academic performance, I'd guess that 34 is on the high side for you. What were your AAMC practice tests like? What does the MCAT Estimator suggest you could get? If 34 is above the average values given by those two resources, I'd suggest not retaking. If, OTOH, your estimation is a good 3-5 points higher than a 34 THEN I would seriously consider a retake.
Fairly consistent poor performance over the four years, a bit of a downward trend- but in general I test well. I didn't really take the AAMC tests- I did a couple of the sections the night of the test and I scored about the same on the BS and PS, a bit higher on the VR. I never took a full practice test though, so I don't know.
Honestly, I feel like I could improve, if I studied. And I know I probably need to get clinical experience or something, since I only really did research in undergrad. But I can't fix my GPA at this point, so I figure that improving my MCAT at least would show dedication?
Work on the Clinical, not the MCAT. Take some classes to get an upward trend. Your weak spots are Clinical and GPA at this point and those WILL keep you out. A 34 on the MCAT will help you but a 40 cannot overcome the weak GPA or clinical. Fix your weak points.