How to explain a W to the Adcom?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

ElectraOnAzalea

Full Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2007
Messages
329
Reaction score
10
I withdrew from organic chemistry I for various reasons.

1.) The structure of the class was such that i was not learning anything. My professor decided to do a PBL type approach to organic chemistry and it was HORRIBLE. We had workbook, would get into groups with peers and try to work through problems. We had no background of organic chemistry and nothing made sense as there was no lecture and the professor would not answer questions. I've determined i am NOT a PBL type learner. I knew this was a very important course and this is one reason why i decided to withdraw. I knew if i could take this as a lecture based class i would build a much more stable foundation.

2.) My school did not offer a lab with Organic Chemistry I. I would have ended up with 7 hours of organic chemstry. 6 lecture hours and one lab hour. We would only have lab with Organic Chemistry II. Most dental schools require 8 semester hours of Organic. How this was supposed to work i have no idea.

3.) I decided to transfer schools during the middle of the year. I transferred to a different university during my sophomore year. I talked to my organic professor and he told me that it was better to take the full year of organic at the same university as subjects that will be covered could vary widely. Also, the school i transferred to required two lab courses (one with each lecture based class.) I would have had to take the lab course for organic one an entire year AFTER i had finished organic one.

Do you think these are legitimate reasons for withdrawing from the course? I know it's important to be able to explain your withdrawls and i'm trying to formulate responses i'll have to that question.
 
In answer to the question in your title...the truth usually works fine.

In your case...those sound like legit answers. PBL isn't for everyone. Understanding that the course wouldn't fulfill requirements is something you probably should have realized before you began the class, but is a legit reason to stop.
 
I'd avoid bringing up your PBL complaint. While it is a legitimate reason, it is far more negative than the other reasons and you don't need it.

If I'm understanding correctly, you took Orgo I. You withdrew and then transferred to another school that same year. If you hadn't withdrawn, you wouldn't have been able to complete the series. I'd guess *most* interviewers would just assume that was the reason (especially if you did well in both classes at the new school) and not even ask about it.

It's good to be prepared just in case, but I wouldn't worry. If you knew you were going to transfer after you started Orgo I but before you withdrew, you have an explanation I doubt anyone would question.
 
don't B.S
don't lie
and NEVER blame the professor, its really unprofessional to blame others when things don't go your way. Eat the blame and explain that you've re-taken the class and did much better (assuming you did retake and obtained a higher mark)
 
I had six or seven W's on my transcript and was never even asked about them.
 
I'm nearing the mark of 30 some-odd W's on my transcript. I had 2 deaths in the family (my mother and my aunt who lived with us) and my dad then had a heart attack the year after. So... if W's TRULY count against you... I'm in some trouble.

But, I hope my M.B.A. and no W's in the last 4 years of college should offset the W's and other various negs my first couple years of community college.

I decided I should complete a master's degree before even THINKING about applying to dental school. So, with an MBA, all As & Bs my last 4 years with no W's, 1000+ hours of shadowing, 500+ hours of volunteer work... I should more than make up for the ungodly amount of W's.
 
I'm nearing the mark of 30 some-odd W's on my transcript. I had 2 deaths in the family (my mother and my aunt who lived with us) and my dad then had a heart attack the year after. So... if W's TRULY count against you... I'm in some trouble.

But, I hope my M.B.A. and no W's in the last 4 years of college should offset the W's and other various negs my first couple years of community college.

I decided I should complete a master's degree before even THINKING about applying to dental school. So, with an MBA, all As & Bs my last 4 years with no W's, 1000+ hours of shadowing, 500+ hours of volunteer work... I should more than make up for the ungodly amount of W's.

That's a lot of adversity you overcame, my friend... I'm glad you came out focused and grounded on the other side. I wish you all the very best, and am sure that adcoms will not penalize you for what happened, as long as they are aware of it. I'm sure you're a remarkable person, and that you'll be a great dentist one day too. 😉
 
it is not uncommon to have to change your schedule every once in a while. Just explain the reasons...no big deal.
 
Top