cavaor said:
Ive contacted Janna to try to get more information, especially the number of deferrments given, etc. Still waiting till hear back. When you spoke to PDs, did you specifically discuss your chances, etc? Im in the same position where I will likely spend alot of $$ if there is a civilian possibility..and since things open up soon, time is an issue.
Anyone have any ideas on factors they look at for deferrment determination (other than the special circumstances people)?
I had planned on only applying to categorical surgical programs with the military programs so not sure how the transitional would work. Talk about things to figure out. If anyone has insight, pass it on. Im the only HPSP at my site and my recruiter...well, he is a nice guy but really learning along with me.
Stay on top of the folks at GME, especially if you're communicating by email. I've sent emails there in regards to important stuff and never gotten a reply.
I was lucky in that one of the program directors pretty much told me my chances without really being prompted. From there, it kinda made it easy to ask other PDs because I already had a good idea from a source a trusted.
Regarding internship, if you don't match in one of the categorical surgery positions, I'm not even sure if the Army has preliminary surgery internships. So it's possible, even likely, that you'll get a transitional internship even if you didn't rank one. From there, you'll reapply to surgery as a PGY-1. Keep in mind that you may have to repeat part or all of your surgery internship, because not all of the rotations for a transitional internship will fulfill the requirements for a surgery residency. If that's the case, remember to pick your electives to fulfill as many surgical requirements as possible.
There are no set factors that go into getting a deferment in the Army, per se, or at least none that I know about. Remember that the catch all reasoning is "the needs of the Army", which can be used to justify any decision irrespective of common sense or logic.
Depending on what you want, what will get you a deferment will often lessen your chances of matching with the Army. All other things being equal, a PD will choose the known quantity, i.e. applicants who have rotated at or interviewed with a progrm in person. If you want a deferment, then the typical mechanism is to not do any rotations and don't interview with anyone, not even over the phone. But even then, you still might be picked up for an internship or otherwise.
Unfortunately, the only way to cover all your bases is to go all out for Army surgery AND apply to 40+ civilian programs, which will cost you a cool thousand, at least. Good luck.