I haven't taken P Chem. I have only taken Organic, but I have also scored the highest Organic ACS Standardized Test score of any student ever to attend my college (yes, including those Chem majors). I have also had friends take P Chem and get A's, so I know it's doable.
The reason I believe he is overstating the difficulty is simply because I have never run into a test or course (MCAT included) that cannot be beat. I only scored a 31 on my MCAT, so I know I'm not a genius, but a 31 was "beating it" to me. I, do, however hold the belief that no class is ever worth avoiding or telling others how hard it is. Many people told me that Organic would finally be the class that got me, and it was quite possibly the easiest I've had.
While I understand I cannot definitely say P Chem is doable as I haven't taken it, I still hold the belief that I could succeed in the class. This belief is based on the fact that many others have done it before me, and if they can do it, then why not me?
The "But what do I know, I'm just a Bio major" comment was said because I'm tired of people assuming all Bio majors are incapable of critical thinking. My Organic professor constantly drummed on about how we are incapable of anything but memorizing simple facts. Funny how a Bio major beat out every one of his beloved Chem majors to have ever taken that class. Bio people deserve love too 😉
For real, I see where you're coming from with me not being able to give a definite opinion, but I want to 😛