Great thread. This topic is a nerdy interest of mine- as with most things, there's a lot more subtlety than meets the eye...
1) Surgery below the umbilicus does NOT guarantee freedom from EMI, especially for ICDs (the sensitivity on the ICD can be set higher (lower threshold) than the sensitivity on pacing leads in order to detect fine VF, and there is inter-patient variability on this. There are PLENTY of case reports now where ICDs were not de-activated, and surgery below the umbilicus resulted in unintentional ICD shocks. Even more of a concern if your institution uses Megadyne return pads. See this example of ICD discharge during a total knee replacement:
Unintended Discharge of an ICD in a Patient Undergoing Total Knee Replacement
2) If the patient is truly PPM dependent (which isn't totally clear from the above info, as @DrN20 correctly pointed out) then the device should be re-programmed to an asynchronous mode. Magnet obviously won't do anything for this. If you don't reprogram. the risk is inappropriate device inhibition and bradycardia during long bursts of electrocautery
3) This patient probably should have a CRT-D if they don't already. Easy to figure out by looking at a CXR (look for a coronary sinus lead). If they don't have one, why not? If they do, you want to make sure that they stay V-paced as much as possible (bi-V paced beats at least in theory will have a greater stroke volume than native QRS beats in someone with a bundle branch block and low EF- sometimes this difference can be quite dramatic)
4) Device interrogation and reprogramming doesn't take more than 5 minutes. If you communicate with the device rep ahead of time, don't schedule these patients as first case starts, and have them come in a little bit earlier, adding this to the workflow should not cause any delays... And if it does delay things for five minutes, big deal. These patients are sick and there are certain things we shouldn't rush
TL
😀R: I'd get a rep to come in and reprogram to asynchronous mode. Since they're re-programming anyway, have them de-activate the ICD and you should put pads on. Then don't let them leave PACU until the rep has restored initial device settings. This is hands down the safest way to handle the scenario presented IMO... Less preferable second option would be use a magnet, and when they start using bovie, watch carefully to make sure it's not inhibiting the pacer