Include Interest in Alternative Medicine in Personal Statement?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Dayzed00

Full Member
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Jul 18, 2008
Messages
18
Reaction score
0
Hello,

As I'm writing my personal statement for post bacc programs, I want to write about series of alternative medicine (Chinese fire cupping and acupuncture) that partially contributed to my decision to study medicine. Eventually, I want to be a doctor with the ability to suggest alternative medicine (not really focused on it). Should I state that in my personal statement since some alternative medicine (e.g., acupuncture) is still controversial and has not fully been accepted here in the US?

Also, what kind of doctor is able to suggest alternative medicine? I haven't encountered one here yet. Does that mean they are limited or doesn't exist?

Thank you for your insights.

Members don't see this ad.
 
You walk a fine line IMO. Keep in mind that people that will be reviewing your app are in academics; they are very scientific method-based, and they want to see data for things. I'm not saying that mentioning this is going to get you rejected, but it might raise a couple eyebrows (in a bad way), and you don't want that.
 
Hello,

As I'm writing my personal statement for post bacc programs, I want to write about series of alternative medicine (Chinese fire cupping and acupuncture) that partially contributed to my decision to study medicine. Eventually, I want to be a doctor with the ability to suggest alternative medicine (not really focused on it). Should I state that in my personal statement since some alternative medicine (e.g., acupuncture) is still controversial and has not fully been accepted here in the US?

Also, what kind of doctor is able to suggest alternative medicine? I haven't encountered one here yet. Does that mean they are limited or doesn't exist?

Thank you for your insights.


No, I dont think you should include it... Especially if you are going to waste space on telling them the controversies of it! The point of a PS is only to give your motivation, dedication and preparedness for medicine. There is only one page to do it in, so including a discussion on alternative medicine will not allow you to fully express your desire for medicine and why they should allow you to become a physician...

I guess any doctor could suggest alternative medicine. If you have your own practice you can even have acupuncturists in your clinic. Just because no one does it doesn’t mean that no one can do it.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
You'd be ok to talk about how you'd like to do clinical research to study the efficacy of it and incorporate it into practice on an evidence basis. That's honestly a neglected topic.

If you intend to practice it regardless of evidence basis, I'd still like you to include it in your essays to ensure rejection and prevent the possibility of your quackery down the line.
 
You'd be ok to talk about how you'd like to do clinical research to study the efficacy of it and incorporate it into practice on an evidence basis. That's honestly a neglected topic.

If you intend to practice it regardless of evidence basis, I'd still like you to include it in your essays to ensure rejection and prevent the possibility of your quackery down the line.

Good point. :laugh:

Hello,

As I'm writing my personal statement for post bacc programs, I want to write about series of alternative medicine (Chinese fire cupping and acupuncture) that partially contributed to my decision to study medicine. Eventually, I want to be a doctor with the ability to suggest alternative medicine (not really focused on it). Should I state that in my personal statement since some alternative medicine (e.g., acupuncture) is still controversial and has not fully been accepted here in the US?

Also, what kind of doctor is able to suggest alternative medicine? I haven't encountered one here yet. Does that mean they are limited or doesn't exist?

Thank you for your insights.

I figured I would add some opposing views. It would be something out of the ordinary for adcoms to read, would allow you to attribute to the diversity of the class, and I think it is also important that you are being honest. If you chose to do so, I feel that TarHeelEMT gave you some frank, but great advice!

Best of luck with your PS
 
"Do you know what they call alternative medicine that has been proved to work? Medicine" -Tim Minchin
 
Nah, don't write it in your PS that much, maybe focus on the part where you really enjoy the patient interaction.

i come from a TCM family background and worked a lot at my family clinic. Schools are very interested in the patient interaction and curious about TCM, but i chose not to write it as part of my PS because it wasn't a significant factor that drove my motivation, but mostly like an academic interest.

I was just like you a year and a half ago, where TCM played a much more important role, but as I worked more extensively in a clinical care setting, the general concept of healing became much more prominent in my mind and thus my narrative. as a result, by the time I submitted my AMCAS, TCM had become a strong interest, but definitely do not drive my narrative.

i was afraid that my background in TCM is.. so biazzaro or something that people would react negatively to it, but so far at interviews, people have been really interested, curious and open. we discuss some of the possibilities for future investigation, some of the cultural implications for the chinese immigrant communities, possibility to complete a OMD degree in China during and after med school. in fact, at cornell, they thought studying chinese medicine in china is such a fantastic idea they even said "we probably have money for you to do it".

additionally, i don't know how much you really know about alternative medicine or is it more of a new interest. there are studies published in nature and jama that demonstrate the efficacy of tcm in coronary heart disease and cancer. find these things, read up on them. do you know how acupuncture works? have you seen the clinical outcomes of patients after acupuncture? if you are going to stick to it, you better know something about it so you can show people your knowledge and conviction on the topic.

so, alternative medicine is no longer a nono taboo or anything, just try to situate it within a large context of healing and medicine. You want your narrative to be cohesive and understandable for others, making alternative medicine the main thing seems.. after all, it is only a modality or method. you want to talk about your motivation for healing, curiosity for people, regardless of the method.. you learn the methods in med school and later, but your motivation is something you need to show postbac programs now. does that make sense?

why not holistic medicine?
you need to answer this question for yourself.

a lot of people will tell you oh it's detrimental to your application, blah blah.. everyone will think you are a quake... it's just not true. I know people with extensive TCM background before going to med school at baylor, harvord, yale, ucla, ucsf and going on to the excellent residencies. our background obviously didn't make us into some kind of med school admissions pariah in the end.

i also applied to postbacs awhile back, bm, scripps, and goucher, they were very receptive to the alternative medicine aspect even when it was more prominent in my narrative vs now, where my later experience occupies a larger proportion of my life.

sorry this is kind of long and rambling but it covers about most aspects in terms of admissions.
best of luck.



Hello,

As I'm writing my personal statement for post bacc programs, I want to write about series of alternative medicine (Chinese fire cupping and acupuncture) that partially contributed to my decision to study medicine. Eventually, I want to be a doctor with the ability to suggest alternative medicine (not really focused on it). Should I state that in my personal statement since some alternative medicine (e.g., acupuncture) is still controversial and has not fully been accepted here in the US?

Also, what kind of doctor is able to suggest alternative medicine? I haven't encountered one here yet. Does that mean they are limited or doesn't exist?

Thank you for your insights.
 
Last edited:
You'd be ok to talk about how you'd like to do clinical research to study the efficacy of it and incorporate it into practice on an evidence basis. That's honestly a neglected topic.

If you intend to practice it regardless of evidence basis, I'd still like you to include it in your essays to ensure rejection and prevent the possibility of your quackery down the line.


^This!

If you're going to do some research on it and look potential EVIDENCE-BASED clinical applications, it could be interesting. If you simply want to practice alternative medicine w/o it being within the scope of EBP, please go be a chiropractor somewhere else (try the far east).
 
To be honest I have no idea how ADCOMs would look at that. However, when I interviewed at Temple I was reading the TUH newsletter and there was an article about a doctor of theirs (I believe she did her residency there and is now an attending, not sure though) who practices accupuncture. She is an MD, American Med school graduate, etc. and the article was very complimentary. That's all of my input.
 
Hello,

As I'm writing my personal statement for post bacc programs, I want to write about series of alternative medicine (Chinese fire cupping and acupuncture) that partially contributed to my decision to study medicine. Eventually, I want to be a doctor with the ability to suggest alternative medicine (not really focused on it). Should I state that in my personal statement since some alternative medicine (e.g., acupuncture) is still controversial and has not fully been accepted here in the US?

Also, what kind of doctor is able to suggest alternative medicine? I haven't encountered one here yet. Does that mean they are limited or doesn't exist?

Thank you for your insights.


Doctors don't suggest alternative medicine unless it is evidence based and would not really be very alternative. Don't write about that kind of stuff. Now I don't see people doing a few of the spiritual approaches in addition to evidence based medicine but all the the stuff shouldn't even be legal. Most of it is bunk.
 
Ill go a step further and suggest that if you approve of non-evidence based treatment modalities, you shouldnt be allowed in.

Sent on the Sprint® Now Network from my BlackBerry®
 
Please let me know when you become an MD so I can get 'treatment' and then sue the **** out of you.
 
I'm going to disagree here, and say if you can justify your experience and talk about what you learned from them, go for it. I've seen the occasional doc prescribe acupuncture as an additional therapy in the outpatient offices. Most of it is just placebo, but if it's a placebo that works for the patient, why not? There's nothing in acupuncture or cupping that's particularly "harmful". Hell, my own school had a session during an interclerkship day with a lot of guest speakers who do various alternative practices in addition to their normal allopathic work.

/even more power to you if you talk about it in a "diversity" essay.


That's one pricey sugar pill.
 
I'm going to disagree here, and say if you can justify your experience and talk about what you learned from them, go for it. I've seen the occasional doc prescribe acupuncture as an additional therapy in the outpatient offices. Most of it is just placebo, but if it's a placebo that works for the patient, why not? There's nothing in acupuncture or cupping that's particularly "harmful". Hell, my own school had a session during an interclerkship day with a lot of guest speakers who do various alternative practices in addition to their normal allopathic work.

/even more power to you if you talk about it in a "diversity" essay.

Yeah, there is nothing in homeopathic remedies, harmful or otherwise, either. That doesn't mean that those appealing to the terminally ill with "alternative" treatments that are nothing other than water (or sticking needles in people, etc.) are anything other than exploitative snake-oil salesmen. Saying you want to be that kind of doctor would, I hope, convince adcoms to bar you from admission. Placebos have their place in medicine (primarily in controlled studies and trials) but convincing people to pay for expensive "treatment" that has no basis in fact and are impossible given a middle-school level of understanding biological processes, is quackery and fraud.

Missed the old bump, my bad.... :-(
 
Last edited:
Top