Hi! I'm a med student at UVA and was accepted to EVMS back when I applied...
It's kind of a tough question because I think they're both really good schools. I'd say go with your gut and choose the school you're more comfortable with (also with the area where you'd like to live, and any other factors) and go in with a positive attitude - and you'll be fine wherever you end up. That' s just my take on things though...maybe someone else can provide more information. I think both schools do well with matching for residencies. I think having a good attitude and just plain luck have a good deal to do with your experience, so it's hard to make any kind of definitive statement. I've been impressed with a lot about UVA, and I think it's a school definitely worth considering.
My only real suggestion is to visit both schools again if you get a chance, talk to more students and see if you could see the school being a good fit.
I'd be more than happy to try to answer any specific questions or just provide more info...sorry if this wasn't any help.
Good luck and most importantly congratulations! Either way, you're going to med school! 🙂