We weren't talking about IMGs in this thread, it's international students who studied at Australian Medical schools. This is an entirely different subset.
See the conversation topic:
http://theconversation.com/why-inte...deserve-a-place-in-australian-hospitals-10261, which was written by Lesleyann Hawthorne, an Australian Healthworkforce (when it used to exist) officer and University of Melbourne researcher.
It's also been discussed by AMA
https://ama.com.au/ausmed/australia’s-internship-crisis-national-process
and AMSA:
https://www.amsa.org.au/node/861.
BigPikachu, what you've said is completely valid for IMGs, but it is not applicable to international students (so non-Australian Citizens or PR) but are studying on Australian soil at Australian medical schools alongside domestic Australian students. There is a separate thread on the 10 year moratorium, it's a different topic that is perhaps out of scope in this one. There are also other threads where IMGs (so non-citizens with non-Australian medical degrees) are posting queries, desperately needing posts like the one you just put up.
Bit confused on whether it was a misunderstanding of this thread, or uncertainty on the difference? I can see that you graduated from Bond University - where there are maybe 1-2 international students per year graduating from your school, so I'm assuming minimal exposure?
I attended UQ. We had up to 200 international students (myself included - but I am now a grad), mostly from Canada and the USA in our cohort of up to 550 per year (other schools in other states had different compositions - some have mostly Singaporean/Malaysian). Australia-wide at most public Australian medical schools (i.e. the ones short on cash) have large proportions of international students (full-fee paying), along side CSP/domestic Australian students.
So, to further emphasize my point (for the prospective and current international students attending an Australian medical school school who may be reading this) - I am one of those said international students from an Australian med school now intern in Australia, and I don't work in the rural precinct, nor is there a requirement for me to for the next decade, and I've been through no tedious accreditation process. Because I graduated with an Australian medical degree. I was treated exactly like my domestic Australian peers except in one exceptionally important regard which I will clarify below.
The only difference international students from Australian schools face compared to domestic Australians is how we apply and receive an internship in Australia. Domestic Australians on commonwealth supported places (so public schools with federal subsidy/loan etc) are guaranteed internship in Australia. International students are not. however, with substantial effort (as I've discussed in above posts), it is possible to obtain an internship for anyone with an Australian medical school degree. Regardless, we still rank higher than IMGs. IMGs will be at Priority 8 if they are even on the priority lists at all, and have to write the AMC exam outside of medical school. International students rank from Priority 1 in ACT, Priority 2 in TAS or VIC, to 3 or 4 in NSW & QLD etc. and write no extra exams.
Much of time, yes, most international students will end up rural as domestic Australian are always priority 1 (as in they get first dibs) and they always choose to go to metropolitan positions first, typically filling up all spots there. Generally, remaining positions unfilled by the time international students (with Australian degrees) come to "match" in Australia are in rural areas. Which in my opinion, is fair, although there's many perspectives on this. I choose to take the public health pov, in other words, Western governments invest millions if not billions in training a medical workforce among their citizens. They have to protect the investment they made in domestic students, in particular where they have subsidized their training/are on government loans. Lesser known, is that the government also covers the cost of training international students (the full fees primarily go to the universities - it doesn't cover their teaching and learning in public hospitals where they spend 2 years). So, it is still a loss if international students leave Australia after they grad, but much less substantial than say if a domestic grad left the practice of medicine.
Much more detail on priority groups across Australia in the following article on the Conversation -
http://theconversation.com/factchec...-given-priority-over-australian-doctors-16327.
The only return of service - where international students with Australian medical degrees are required to work in a rural area - is the Commonwealth Medical Internship program, a federally funded program that was created specifically for international students who graduated from Australian medical schools, and were unable to obtain a state funded internship. They are required to fulfill 48 weeks (up to a year) of return of service in regional or rural Australia within 5 years - so anytime in 5 years, you can do rural rotations as a medical officer, intern year included. In other words, you can still do a mixed year of metro and rural rotations, no one says it has to be done consecutively either. It is much, much less severe compared to Canada or the USA where return of service is anywhere from 3-5 years.
I definitely,
definitely agree with that reality of having an oversupply of doctors and the competitiveness of training. Hence my being incredibly direct and blunt with both prospective and current students (who do not have Australian PR or citizenship = international) BUT are students paying full fees to study at an Australian medical school on Australian soil for 4-6 years. I would encourage anyone to strongly consider and research where they're going before they drop 250-300k for a degree outside of their home country. The downfalls to studying at an Australian medical school for a North American student has a tendency to be under discussed or overlooked or both.
However, I qualify for PR a year after work (after the intern year). Currently (this may actually change within the next few years) medical officers, even junior ones, are still on the Australian government's list of 'needed' professions. This means, I compete for future training placements like any other Australian citizen or permanent resident. Since the government (finally) projected an oversupply of doctors, they are contemplating removing some medical professions from the list.
The state of international students studying at Australian medical schools has been a massive topic in Australia for several years now. In terms of the realities faced by this group and it's impact on both Australian medical workforce and the workforce in Canada and the USA. Any Australian graduates, even citizens of Canada/USA, are considered IMGs to North America. The process for any Canadians and Americans to return home is substantially more tedious than remaining in Australia, they are required to take exams (8 hour MCQs, sometimes 2-3 of these and an OSCE - aka USMLEs, MCCEE and NAC OSCE). There's no requisite for Australian grads no matter their origin, to take the AMC Qs for instance that IMGs take to practice in Australia. (My understanding is that Singapore is so short on doctors, Australian grads are readily welcomed and needed).
To clarify - I'm not picking at your post.
Merely trying to ensure the large numbers of International students looking to study medicine as students in Australian medical schools are clear in their minds what they're facing when they come here. A lot of them rely on these forums to get outside information, apart from what medical schools and their recruitment agencies (like Oztrekk) feed them. Most have never been to Australia, they wouldn't have any clue. They will when they start training in Australia, but prior to that, nada.
The medical schools (even if they come from the best intentions) are terrible at guiding them through the post-graduate training process. Some don't even try. (Not entirely their fault, more often than not, I find faculty are just not in touch with what's going on, they're as lost and hopeless as their students. Over saturation of the market for doctors, is kinda low on their priority list, while they're busy promoting and selling degrees).
Education is a booming industry in the billions, it's the top export in Australia. Medical degrees are highly prized and among the most expensive. Even if the market's over saturated, the universities don't benefit from over-saturation, actually quite the opposite. Eventually, like everything else, the government probably will catch up and put a much needed cap on student numbers, but it's already too late. Too many new schools, too many students, been that way for a decade.
https://ama.com.au/ausmed/new-medical-schools-could-worsen-intern-crisis.
Despite, this there's yet another a new medical school opening up at Perth, which will also include an intake of international students.
http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-11-...-medical-university-campus-in-midland/8044240. Here's what the university is saying (and what it was saying for years to get traction for its med school): "The university believes the school will go a long way to addressing a "critical shortage" of doctors, especially in rural, remote and outer-suburb locations". The government didn't even stop them -
https://ama.com.au/ausmed/‘captain’s-call’-medical-school-won’t-fix-doctor-shortage (Abbott at the time, but still. For a conservative government, closing the tap on a billion dollar industry - education & full fee paying students - goes against the grain, they get away with it because there's no guarantee or no legal obligation on their part to provide post-graduate training or jobs to any of these students). Irony is that now there's actually people with Australian degrees from WA unable to find work.
https://thewest.com.au/news/wa/uwa-doctor-out-of-work-next-year-ng-b88335098z. But yes, let's do open up more schools and encourage more internationals to attend to pay full fees and live with the stress and prospect of having no post-graduate training, while they spend four years as students in Australia.