Interview Advice

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

pietachok

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2008
Messages
967
Reaction score
183
When choosing which interview offers to accept/decline, do we need to make sure we interview at a certain number of less competitive programs? Or is there enough selectivity on the part of programs with regards to offering interviews that as long as we go to 10+ interviews, it is perfectly reasonable to only interview at 1 - 2 such programs?
 
I think this is a great question. I am also curious. Where are we supposed to find time to interview with Neuro, Prelim and finish up 4th year rotations?
I am also interested in knowing how to judge selectivity with interviews so I can appropriately manage the next few months! I want to make sure I dont set myself up for failure in March.

As always good luck to everyone interviewing this year... see ya'll on the trail!
 
I am also interested in knowing how to judge selectivity with interviews so I can appropriately manage the next few months!

I have been looking at what schools the current residents attended. Some programs are entirely FMG or DOs. Nationally, US MD grads make up about 50% of the applicant pool, so I think that gives some idea as to where the program falls in terms of competitiveness. There are some exceptions for programs in undesirable locations and that do a wonderful job facilitating the visa process and thus attract a disproportionate # of FMGs of higher quality.
 
I think this is a great question. I am also curious. Where are we supposed to find time to interview with Neuro, Prelim and finish up 4th year rotations?
I am also interested in knowing how to judge selectivity with interviews so I can appropriately manage the next few months! I want to make sure I dont set myself up for failure in March.

As always good luck to everyone interviewing this year... see ya'll on the trail!

I'm having the same problem, I don't know how to manage the neuro and prelim invites all while still doing rotations, especially being that most neuro interviews are 2 days with the preinterview dinners. I feel like I'm asking for an unreasonable amount of time away from rotations.
 
Firstly, I think it's perfectly reasonable to have 1-2 safety programs if you've got a total of ten interviews planned. Just make sure one of them is a place you know that you really will have a spot (e.g. your home program). Stuff happens and great candidates do fall through. That being said, this is neurology folks, not interventional rads. Take a deep breath. With the exception of the tippy top programs, it really is a buyer's market still. It's no different than applying to college or med school. A few "dream" programs, a few reasonable matches, and 1-2 "CYA" programs.

Schedule each interview as you get them, but be making a pre-interview rank list somewhere so that you can cull out less-desirable programs as you start racking up more interviews. So go ahead and schedule with Po-dunk State. Once you've filled out your dance card with programs you're more interested in, you can always cancel. Every, and I mean EVERY program has cancellations and expects them. In fact, better to let them know early so they can offer the spot to someone who may be more interested that you are. A polite "I'm sorry but my circumstances have changed/ I'm unfortunately going to have to decline the interview but I really appreciate being considered and invited." will suffice. The program's just going to call the next person on the list... and there's ALWAYS a next person on the list.

If you've got a reasonable number of programs (let the NRMP match stats guide you), there's no reason to interview at Po-Dunk State if you know you'd rather not match than live in You-Can't-Get-There-From-Here, Nowhere.

Prelims get trickier. I was at a med school where we had all but guaranteed prelim years if we needed them and I mostly applied to categorical programs. I did the one prelim year interview and that was it! Clearly it's not that simple for most folks. Talk with the programs you're interviewing with. Many will work with the IM department to get you an interview while you're already in town, though it may be an abbreviated one without all the bells and whistles.

Most med school programs will work with you and expect you to be MIA as a fourth year. We've all been there. Try to cluster interviews when you can, say in the NYC or Boston areas. Don't be shy about calling the program to swap your dates around. Most all of them will work with you. No program expects that they're the only one that you're interviewing with and will at least try to work to accommodate you.

Other than that... Be nice. Be yourself. Enjoy the ride. 😀
 
Top