yes, i got asked this question at all of the schools i interviewed at. ARRRRRRRRRRRGH! what made it more annoying was that i applied to all first tier schools but just happened to get interviews ONLY at three of the best schools i applied to, and my state school (which i declined...LONG STORY!) and it certainly raised an eyebrow...and all asked, "why only those schools?" or "why didn't you get an interview at X school?" so what was i supposed to say???? were they hinting that i must have foiled the process somehow on purpose, or was this supposed to be another variety of the "what is your weakness?" question? why do they even ask, to ascertain what your chances are of getting in somewhere else? at one school in particular they asked me why i didn't go to my state school's interview, and although i answered as honestly as possible, the guy then proceeded to ask me how i was going to pay for medical school, and tried to convince me to go to the state school (apparently he'd gone to HIS state school...but shouldn't he have been selling me on the place i was interviewing at????)! i thought that was completely inappropriate, and better left for the fafsa! obviously if i wasn't willing to take loans to go there, why would i have applied there...
at another school, the guy asked why i didn't apply to albert einstein -- i had actually just not turned in the secondary after i was running out of money, but this was my third interview and i was getting sick and tired of explaining, and knowing that they didn't get a copy of the last page of amcas, i thought it would be simpler to neglect to say i even applied -- when i had applied to nyu and columbia. i answered as honestly as possible without going into the whole shpiel, saying that sometimes it comes down to what looks best in the brochure and on the website when you haven't actually gone to visit the school, and monetary reasons restricted me from applying everywhere. turns out he'd gone to albert einstein. and then he brought it up AGAIN later on!!!
so at these two schools where they really drilled me on this question, i got rejected post-interview. i am waitlisted at the school that semi-drilled me...and whether or not this question was THE determining factor in my admissions is certainly pissing me off...
whew. <taking deep breath>