- Joined
- May 27, 2009
- Messages
- 4,020
- Reaction score
- 6
It's not about daring to be different, but having the confidence to be yourself.
Definately!! I'm sick of worrying about having enough EC's or defending/explaining my choices of EC's. Frankly, I don't have the time to be president of six student organizations AND volunteer AND shadow 75 hours. I work hard just to get good grades...why should I have to jump through hoops to beat out pre-meds that do nothing but study and participate in every relavent EC?
What makes you think of it as "beating out" everybody. Yes, you have to be a desirable candidate, but I don't think most of us think of it as "beating" anyone out; at least I don't.
I was just talking yesterday with a fellow adcom member about the "motivation for medicine" question. Next year I'd like to change it to "how have you tested your interest in medicine as a career?" I should hope that the idea didn't just pop into your head and you took the MCAT and filled out the application!
Unlike everyone else, I'm not trying to be unique.
Eh...that isn't always true. For a lot of people, that isn't true at all. Agreed with the rest, even though it seems like we have different definitions of "playing the game."
Also, one things that people havm't really talked about is that being "interesting" requires money. The most interesting people i know who have doen all kinds of cool stuff like camping in mongolia, skiing the alps, and went sailing around the world. They aren't so much as interesting as just rich. These are people that can afford to go volunteer in africa for months at a time, or backpack through asia. I mean, i would love to do any of these things, but where am I going to just going to get teh 10,000 dollars to do them? So bascially, if you think about, by demanding "unique" ECs is an indirect way to screen out less wealthy candidates.
Do only those ECs that you like...but no research will red flag you at many schools.
Plus you pretty much have to volunteer at hospitals (which often tends to be very tedious)....
The schools that will red-flag you for no research are schools that are trying to focus on producing the next generation of academic physician and physician-scientists. If you aren't intersted in that career trajectory, if you don't want to do research, then those schools are not a good fit for you. Don't blame the school.
How can you know that you want to engage in a career that involves the care of the sick if you've never been around the sick. Hospitals are not the only place where you will encounter sick people but hospitals are ubiquitous and easily identified. Willingness to perform humble acts of service for others, particularly if those others are sick or injured seems to be a good measure of the heart of a physician. Also, keep in mind that you will be asked to perform your share of "scut" as a trainee and if you aren't willing to do your share of the tedious work, then you aren't going to be a good team member through your training.
Also, one things that people havm't really talked about is that being "interesting" requires money. The most interesting people i know who have doen all kinds of cool stuff like camping in mongolia, skiing the alps, and went sailing around the world. They aren't so much as interesting as just rich. These are people that can afford to go volunteer in africa for months at a time, or backpack through asia. I mean, i would love to do any of these things, but where am I going to just going to get teh 10,000 dollars to do them? So bascially, if you think about, by demanding "unique" ECs is an indirect way to screen out less wealthy candidates.
I'm not blaming the schools at all, I'm saying that it's a rational, even necessary way to differentiate applicants. But some schools that require research certainly train a fair share, if not a majority, of medical students who will not go into academics.
Secondly, I agree that all premeds should volunteer at hospitals. That doesn't make it any less tedious; there are exceptions, of course, I do remember enjoying a few of my hospital volunteering shifts.
👍Unfortunately, the process and requirements often aren't rationally founded. Most of the things you have to do to make yourself qualified for med school admission have very little or nothing whatsoever to do with med school or being a doctor.
I maintain that the best way to get into med school is to just brute force everything and not worry about it. Pick up some lame hospital volunteering for "clinical experience," take the easiest possible classes because we all know that a 3.9 in your breathing major from Neverheardofit U beats the pants off a 3.3 in world revolutionizing from Hahvahd, get some research experience in whatever comes your way, and call it a day. Voila! Instant resume. Play the game that's set out for you. If you happen to find things along the way that'll support your cause and genuinely interest you, awesome, but if you're actively trying to be unique, you're not going to be successful.
I am unique! I'm a delicate beautiful snowflake.
In a blizzard.
In the north pole.
During an ice age...
There are many hobbies that one can engage in at low cost. Several years ago, I interviewed a candidate who bought broken cameras and vintage electrical items, repaired them and sold them on eBay. Another made sculptures from found objects and yet another made silver jewelry.
Writing poetry, novels, or musical compositions doesn't cost much, nor does drawing with pencils or charcoal. The same goes for collecting seashells or rocks, or birdwatching. You can get into photography and artistic expressions using photographs and computer graphics at many different price points. Aside from the cost of gear, some athletic activities are relatively low cost.
Camping in Mongolia is exotic but the National Parks in the US offer a variety of opportunities for back country camping, hiking, canoeing etc that can be done on a very reasonable budget (some members of my family have been doing it annually for years at a rather modest cost).
Jobs can make you stand out. Over the years I've interviewed a union organizer, Senate staff member, Naval officer, ballpark hot dog vendor (2 of them, actually), a few ambulance drivers (full time after college), and I've reviewed applications from a professional athlete & a beauty pageant winner. I can't remember how many Teach for America and Peace Corps volunteers I've seen over the years. Everyone is unique but sometimes it is hard to stand out or be memorable. It is possible to be memorable (in a good way) without being a millionaire.
All the activities you mentioned is still very middle upper class. I am currently working with inner city population, and they didn't have parents that cultivated their artistic abilities or do they have much capability to travel as most families don't even have cars. I agree that it is possible to be memoriable without being a millionaire, but it's pretty hard when you are poor.
And the whole point is why do does one have to be memorable (collecting seashells, writing poetry, fixing broken cameras, being professional athletes) in order to make a good doctor? These things are important, but shouldn't be weighed in equalness to academic ability. I rather that my dcotor spend all their free time studying rather than palying football
If I'm reading applications and I have a half dozen from the same school and all have gpa between 3.67 and 3.76 and all have MCAT between 30 and 32, how do I choose which to invite for interview? (I can only recommend 3 of the 6 and only 1 or 2 will make the final cut). I'm going to choose the applicant who is memorable or interesting.
Believe me, you don't want a doctor who has no time or inclination to do anything but study. The healthiest people engage in some leisure time physical activity and some interests outside of their professional activities. My most recent surgeon runs marathons (in his 40s) and is a remarkable artist as well as a talented surgeon who also runs an academic program.
Don't make excuses for inner city kids. They have eyes, they have hands. Most anyone can afford the cost of a pencil and a scrap of paper. A curious kid can study and record the behavior of pigeons or squirrels, there are church choirs and pick up games of basketball.
I've interviewed some inner-city and otherwise poor kids over the years. One was in the Navy at the time of the application, another Air Force, yet another had worked a job during HS to buy school clothes & supplies for herself and a sibling, yet another had graduated, completed a master's degree and was teaching community college. So I guess you can say that inner-city kids can distinguish themselves through occupational pursuits after college. Stll, I contend that opportunities are available to anyone with the initiative to grab 'em.
Just be yourself. Med-school applications will be filled with unique robots - people trying way to hard to pass themselves off as being "well-rounded people". I think if someone is trying to make themselves well-rounded they probably aren't. They're just well-rounded robots. If your trying to be like them you won't be unique. Don't bother. It's a joke.
given that GPA/MCATs is very similar, then sure, memorability can be a selection factor. yet every year, many kids with very strong academics don't get into medical school while those that have very questionable academics do.
I agree that it is important to not spend all your time studying, and have physical or artistic pursuits, but relaxing activities like going to the gym, watching movies, reading books, talking with people, i think are all things that can be something that a person does well not studying, YET in medical school applications, they are considered worthless next to runing marathons and being an awesome artists (which both don't sound like something teen mothers have the time to be cultivating by the way).
Inner city kids have to deal with abusive parents, gang violence, drug dealing, truancy, teen pregnacies, working long hours, broken families, and the list goes on. While they can distinguish themselves through occupational pursuits, other opportunies (that everyone else have) are very limited.
I still believe that opportunies are availiable to anyone with the initiative to grab them because that's what I have been taught. But happens to the kids who never got to learn that?
That is a VERY different timescale. I wonder if the kids are really worth it.
I'd say no.
is anyone else sick of trying to be"unique"? having unique ECs, unique reasons for wanting to be a doctor, having unique life experience, being bent arrows. Why is not okay anymore to just want to be doctor because you love medicine, the challenge of medical school, the reward of healing, and nice job stability?
If they said you needed more volunteering maybe you didn't elaborate enough.
My best two LORs come from the physician I worked with (whose wedding and baby showers I attended!) who runs the medical mission abroad, and the chemistry department chair who gave me A's in honors gen chem and orgo, as well as jobs running workshops and coordinating the research grant. Both of them know me well and can attest to my capabilities, but he somehow believes that LORs from upper-level classes (in which there are 200+ students) will somehow be more meaningful. Wrong. But what can I do?
<snip> I earned the top score on 3 of 4 of our exams this year, and he likes me personally, but he just doesn't know me the way the other two know me.
Volunteerism is considered a measure of one's altruism.
Remember, you are unique, just like everyone else.
See here is what I don't understand. I understand people going overboard in things like volunteering, shadowing, research, etc.
What makes no sense to me is adcoms being impressed with things that are outside medicine and science like sports, or clubs, etc. Yes, they may show them you have certain qualities and that you are a well rounded individual with lots of different interests, but from what I hear about med school and medicine, its incredibly difficult to find the time for these things outside. Ive heard the medicine is very "cookie cutter" with not much in the way of creativity. Its pretty much just memorization unless you are a researcher.
To someone who is creative or likes to be very active, I would think that med school would constrain this type of person. And residency, which Ive heard really bad things about in terms of time, would seem to kill any sort of time to pursue your passions.
Idk, maybe someone would comment on this.
All the activities you mentioned is still very middle upper class. I am currently working with inner city population, and they didn't have parents that cultivated their artistic abilities or do they have much capability to travel as most families don't even have cars. I agree that it is possible to be memoriable without being a millionaire, but it's pretty hard when you are poor.
Few people get to have your perspective.
Please share some wisdom from your experience and some recommendations on what we should write in our PS ;p
No one said that you need to be "unique". In fact, each of you snowflakes is unique by virtue of your fingerprints.
However, what you need is a "hook". Something that makes us say, "how interesting! It would be fun to talk to this applicant, let's invite 'em to interview." Then when you are interviewed you need to show some enthusiasm and passion for something you've done as this draws people in makes them believe you are an interesting person.
So, let's say that you like to cook and you asked your grandmother to teach you to make a traditional dish and then you and your grandmother made 12 dozen of them for a special occasion. Now you might write in your PS that you learned your dumpling making skills from your grandmother but that she also provided your first introduction to [some chronic disease]. Then you go on about your mad dumpling making skills but also about how your interest in grandma's condition led you to do x, y, and z culminating in applying to medical school. Now you might get labeled as "the dumpling maker". Are you the only applicant who knows how to make dumplings? Of course not but that with your other stuff is going to be a memory aid to the adcom as your application makes its way through the system.